SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
hmoates

Farmhouse/Apron Front Sink Choices

Haley
4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

Initially, I was looking at a 36" farmhouse sink, but it has been discontinued and I haven't found another 36" sink that I like. So, I found these sinks and would love reviews on them or the company if you happen to have any. If not, what are your opinions on "work station" sinks? Any recommendations on sink size? The smallest sink I am considering is a 30". Thank you!


Blanco Ikon

Kraus Black

Signature Hardware Brumfield

Signature Hardware Torun


*It's a new build so I'm not worried about it fitting in an existing cabinet.

Comments (50)

  • jhmarie
    4 years ago

    You probably have already looked at and rejected the Kohler Whitehaven - but I love mine:) Mine is 36".


  • PRO
    Joseph Corlett, LLC
    4 years ago

    I'd get a 36" single bowl apron front sink if I were you. My customers love them.

  • Related Discussions

    apron front/farmhouse sink materials

    Q

    Comments (7)
    Hi We have had a copper farmhouse sink for a little over a year and we love it! The sink is built like a tank and will most likely outlast everything else in the kitchen. The cleaning of this sink is really easy - just soap and water. Âthat's it with an occassional (maybe once a month) wax to protect the surface. It's the easiest kitchen sink in terms of maintenance that we have ever owned. Besides longevity, one reason we chose this over fireclay was the living finish. We love how our sink has sort of a "personality". It doesn't change much - but it will change somewhat. That is part of the beauty of these sinks. Ânot to mention that they are individually crafted and every one is a bit different. Âand there is just something about the warmth of copper - much more inviting than what we considered the "sterile look" of a white fireclay sink. Although we didn't choose the bow front, I don't think that would be an issue at all. In fact, in the right kitchen, I think they would be stunning. We purchased from Copper Sinks Online (I'll include a link). They were recommended by several folks on this forum at the time and they were certainly outstanding. We had no problem matching a faucet to the finish (Oil Rubber Bronze) and the faucet/sink combo came with a discount. I'm not sure they still have the special going but you might ask. One thing you might check out on their site is the photo gallery. They also had a lot of information there about copper sinks in general. Hope this helps! Here is a link that might be useful: copper farmhouse sinks
    ...See More

    Farmhouse/apron front sink

    Q

    Comments (5)
    Not sure who cluelessincolorado is, but thanks for the link. I can make one that would be almost flush. I can square off the sides of the apron so it can be virtually flush mounted. I hope that helps Taylor.
    ...See More

    Photos of 24" farmhouse/apron front kitchen sink?

    Q

    Comments (5)
    Here are my existing photos of the Whitehaven 24," color is sea salt and this is the "tall apron" version. I can take others if you want. The sink in the background is the 33" version. FYI if you want anything other than straight white in 24" its a custom order and takes like 2-3 months. Fortunately my contractor and cabinet people were so slow it was a non-issue... hahaha. It's great size for a prep sink, but would be small for a main sink... maybe could see it like in a small apartment with significant space constraints.
    ...See More

    Are apron front/farmhouse sinks messy?

    Q

    Comments (9)
    "You are obviously not a 5’2” average size and average weight few extra pounds female who has to get close to the sink in order to operate the faucet." No, but I a a 5'5 female with short legs, so not too far off. "Farm sinks are good fit for specific users, but they aren’t a golden ticket for everyone. Trying to pretend there are no drawbacks is a big disservice." Who's pretending there are no drawbacks? Sharing one's positive experience doesn't mean there are no negatives nor that there is a one-size-fits-all. "Those splashes that roll down the sink front NOT get immediately wiped up in most households. The result 5 years later is water damage to that sink base." That is the fault of the user, not a flaw in sink design. IME a non-apron-front sink resulted in under-sink cabinet damage, not the other way around (DH can be splashy and has a tendency not to clean up spills and splashes).
    ...See More
  • Shannon_WI
    4 years ago

    I have not heard good things about the Signature brand. I'd stick with Blanco, or as Jhmarie mentioned, check into the Kohler Whitehaven, though the cost would be more than double what you are looking at unfortunately.

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Yes, I noticed the Kohler Whitehaven is around $1,500 -- in the color we want.

    What has been said about Signature Hardware?

    I have been looking for a 36" sink, but not having much luck.

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    I just remodeled with a farmhouse sink and DEFINITELY get the ledge type of style.


    I have a relatively small urban kitchen and installed a 36" single bowl sink. I have the grid plus the cutting board plus a small "sponge shelf" and a cutting board with a hole that holds a stainless bowl.


    The ledge style effectively lets me have the advantages of a large 36" single bowl sink without losing functional counter space. Most of the time I keep the grid in place over the sink (it's 18" wide" so there is plenty of accessible bowl. I can dry anything I hand wash and it also is a great place to dry veggies/fruits etc. Needless to say the cutting board and prep bowl provide extremely functional counter prep space - in many ways they are more functional since prep takes place over the sink since there is less to clean up in terms of the counter.


    Here's a picture of my sink with the grid on




  • Shannon_WI
    4 years ago

    Beautiful Helen! Not just the sink, but wow on backsplash and cabinets! Have you done a reveal post? If yes, I missed it!

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    Thanks Shannon - No reveal because it's not completely finished yet - SIGH. I thought I was almost done and then my idiot upstairs neighbor decided to connect a rubber hose to his bathtub line and it flooded everyone. I was lucky because I wasn't below him so it was just a small portion of my wall that had to be dried - taken out WITH asbestos hazmat squad because evidently the original drywall had asbestos - SIGH. Then the exposed pipes which belonged to the building were in terrible shape so they had to be replaced by the building - additional asbestos wall came down. It's just this week that they finished dry walling the wall; priming, painting - including the ceiling because the tape used by the asbestos people to contain their actions took off paint on the ceiling.

  • PRO
    Joseph Corlett, LLC
    4 years ago



    Virtually any undermount sink can be installed with a ledge. The flanges on this Elkay Quartz Luxe are over an inch wide, easily allowing a 1/2" reveal or "ledge". Although Elkay recommends a 1/8" reveal and I think it looks the best, this ledge was a happy accident. I had to make the cutout large enough to avoid bisecting, exposing, and repairing the original sink clip mount holes.

  • jhmarie
    4 years ago

    Have you ever had a black sink? If so fine, but if not the ones I've seen tend to show water spots. Perhaps they were just in a hard water area. My white Whitehaven was $960 - but the colored ones are more expensive.

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    No, I have not owned a black sink before, but I don't think white or stainless will work.


    Don't water spots show up on everything?

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    I had a black sink and it was horrendous to keep looking clean unless I literally wiped off after cleaning. Any bit of water left a water spot and normal cleansing agents would leave a whitish film.


    While there might be water spots on every finish, they show up way more on a black sink.


  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    So far I have found these two in 36 inch if anyone knows anything about this brand?


    Bocchi Vignetto

    Bocchi Contemp


  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    I'm pretty sure we will go with black, but I will definitely keep that in mind in case we find another color we like. And for feature reference on keeping it clean.

  • ShadyWillowFarm
    4 years ago

    Here is mine. If your kitchen isn’t a bit spotty once in a while, you aren’t in it enough, which usually means it wasn’t well designed. I’m too much of a klutz to have a sink made from a hard material like iron; I’d constantly be breaking dishes and glasses. I went with copper.

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Isn't copper difficult to keep up?

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    It depends on entirely on the copper sink. Mine has a living finish and so it is extremely easy to keep up. It doesn't have a polished interior and so it changes - it gets shiny spots where acidic food hits it and then it quickly reacquires a patina.


    It is not for someone who wants their kitchen to be pristine and shiny.


    The cheaper lower quality copper sinks have a factory finish which will wear off - those are the copper sinks which give copper sinks a bad name. And of course, your sink won't be shiny as in a polished copper finish.

  • AboutToGetDusty
    4 years ago

    Also, if you do consider the Whitehaven...the rep at the store where I'm getting mine told me Kohler is still not promising the Whitehaven in colors...that white is the only option that is coming in, in a timely fashion. He said the company is still getting back on its feet after the fire.

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    The copper sinks do look beautiful, but I don't know how well I would deal with the constant changing in appearance. Plus, the ones I keep seeing recommended (Havens and Rachiele) are much too expensive for me.


    I don't need it to be spotless or perfect or anything, I am going with Soapstone countertops. However, the countertops won't have green in them or as little as green as I can get. I like the black and dark grey slabs.

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    If you aren't into the living finish, then a good copper sink is definitely not your style. No right or wrong - it's just personal taste.


    My sink is from Havens because I wanted a specific configuration with the drain on the left but World Coppersmith makes copper sinks (or other stuff) with a living patina that doesn't require special care. They are significantly less expensive - about $1000 for a farmhouse style.


    World Copper Smith Kitchen Sinks

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    That's my concern. Though they are lovely, I'm just not sure how I would feel about them. I have seen the posts on here about them, are there any other places to check out to determine whether you love/hate copper sinks?

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    I don't know what other information you would be looking for.


    If you are unsure whether you want the aesthetics of a living finish - ie. patina - then it's probably best not to get a copper sink. It is what it is. It is an aesthetic decision based on how you want your kitchen to look. That is true of any material.


    The only objective advice anyone can give is that maintenance of a high quality copper sink is pretty easy - in fact easier than other sinks I have owned because I don't have to worry about whether it is shiny - just that I have cleaned it :-).

  • 2ManyDiversions
    4 years ago

    AboutToGetDusty, I ran into that situation, or rather comment, when I was ready to order my Kohler Whitehaven sinks. I think it was at a Ferguson's where I was told this. However, anyone wanting to receive their Kohler Whitehaven earlier should first check out their local (or not local) big box stores - the arrival date is listed for each color. Our Lowe's had a plethora of colors in stock at their warehouses so rather than wait the 1- 3 months we were told it would take, I just had mine shipped from a Lowe's warehouse. Both arrived in under a week. Might not apply to all colors, but just a heads up in case anyone is in a rush : )

  • 2ManyDiversions
    4 years ago

    OT: Helen, good to hear you are enjoying your living patina copper sink and consider it easy care. Though not for our kitchen sinks, I have been seriously contemplating a living patina copper countertop for the built-in in our tv room, just off the kitchen, which will house our coffee maker, grinder, espresso machine, and a mini snack bar. DH is the love of my life, but such a pig pen! I felt the living patina might be the way to go and really quite attractive... and I'd help it along with lemon and vinegar to get it going as regards various markings. Are you of the opinion something like that would make a good countertop that would be somewhat neglected on occasion?

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    @tMany - again this is really an aesthetic rather than a functional decision. In terms of living with a pig, there are many solid surfaces that are pretty bullet proof in terms of upkeep - i.e. they don't stain or etch. I have a granite for my kitchen counter which is extremely low maintenance.


    You kind of have it backwards as lemon and vinegar take the patina off and the traditional way to shine copper with home ingredients is ketchup and salt. You would want the copper to patina and then live with those portions which become shinier because of contact with acids. The sink I bought from Havens is shipped with a natural patina - i.e. it is exposed to elements so that it arrives looking like a used penny - then as it is used, it acquires blotches which change as it reacquires a patina.

  • 2ManyDiversions
    4 years ago

    I appreciate your response Helen. Yes, I don't think DH will have much affect on our busy granite, but he's the coffee guy around here, and I know the countertop in the tv room will escape my attention at times.

    I do understand that acids would leave the brighter marks - my intent was to create those markings, such as drinking glass rings as well as splotches, in the darker patina. I suppose it would make better sense to ask: when you wipe up your sink with just soap and water, does this affect the patina? I'm hoping the answer is mostly 'no', and that the patina is just ever-changing. Thanks for your patience, it was a long working weekend and I feel I'm not making sense!

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    The patina lives but soap and water doesn't all by itself change the patina. However, there is generally stuff that is being cleaned WITH the soap and sponge so that brighter splotches are left.


    If you don't want to deal with a patina, go with a bullet proof granite. I opted for Black Galaxy in my kitchen. It has little copper specks so that picks up all of the copper in my kitchen but otherwise is not particularly busy and I have to look hard to find any debris - which is either a good or bad thing :-).

  • M Miller
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Me personally, I love looking at the beautiful copper sinks like Helen’s and some others I’ve seen on this forum. However, I would not have one in my own kitchen. I am just not a living-finish person. Similarly, I love looking at the gorgeous marble counters on this forum. Oh, they are just heavenly! But I wouldn’t have it in my kitchen. My granite counters are impervious to everything, and don’t even need to be sealed. That’s me. For a sink, I currently have an undermount single-bowl heavy-gauge stainless steel sink. I can bang my pots around, or dump coffee or wine and let it sit, and the stainless steel is impervious. That’s what I like. I have too much going on with family, work, etc that I just can’t fit in even one more iota of upkeep of anything. If I had a more serene lifestyle, perhaps I could.

    For my next kitchen, I would like an apron front sink instead of the undermount I have now. I have my eye on the Elkay stainless steel apron front because it is made of the impervious stainless steel, has a corner drain (the best!), and the apron is somewhat narrow (I don’t like the thick apron fronts). That’s just me - HTH.

    P.S. In a previous kitchen, I had a black (anthracite) Silgranit Super Single undermount sink with corner drain. I loved it, and it never showed anything, including water marks. Its surface has a somewhat slippery finish which means it is super easy to clean. The only reason I didn’t get it again was because a black sink would not work in my current kitchen, and the lighter Silgranit colors are not as easy-care. I am unfamiliar with Blanco’s Silgranit in an apron front version.

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    @2many - I realize I might not have answered your question because it depends on the copper material used for your counter. If it already has a patina and it is a natural patina, then just the act of using it will cause it to change. I don't think you have to take any measures to start it going as I have found many things cause the patina to alter - it's part of the fun.


    Of course you can have a lot of fun by writing messages to your DH in lemon juice :-).

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    M Miller, thank you! I'm afraid Stainless will not match anything else in our kitchen. We are going with black appliances and a black/dark gray soapstone countertop. But low maintenance is a must.

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    What about a Soapstone sink? Maybe a carved one? How difficult would it be to match, at least somewhat, to whatever soapstone we choose for counters? How do they stand up to daily wear and tear?

  • ShadyWillowFarm
    4 years ago

    Haley, if you’re kitchen is perfectly maintained you just are not having enough fun in your house. A well-lived in house is going to get dings and spots and stains, especially when you have kids. Copper is not hard upkeep, it just changes color if it reacts with something you set or spill in it. Then it goes back to copper. And I have yet to fumble while hand washing a wine glass in the sink and have it break, so I treasure how forgiving it is.

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    I don't expect it to be perfect, but I don't think I would like the sink constantly changing like that. They're pretty, but I think it would make me crazy.

  • OneRidgeOff
    4 years ago

    To answer your original question, I have the Blanco Ikon 33” in anthracite. Absolutely love it, and yes I would call it a very easy care finish. I’m far from being a clean freak, so I love that it does not show general dirt or water spots, unlike a black cast iron sink I’ve had previously, which showed water spots, and worse, showed a lot of scratches and wear, even though I thought I treated it with care; there’s no comparing the two. I also got both sets of sink grids for the Ikon, the full bottom grid and a partial shelf grid that sits above. I’m sure these are contributing to the sink’s still perfect condition.

  • OneRidgeOff
    4 years ago

    Just noticed you said you were going with soapstone and black appliances- that’s similar to my choices as well, and I love saturated, deep colors and zero regrets with following my own tastes. You may get comments that your kitchen will be too dark. If you take into account an updated lighting plan, don’t let it deter you.

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Oh it's beautiful!

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    I did like that it had a few accessories to go with it. I figured they would be useful. I don't remember what type of drain it has though. Is it stainless, plastic, or will one from another brand work with it?

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Sorry for the bombardment of questions!

    Does the 15.25 inch basin width plenty of room? I assume most things fit length wise at 29 inches.

  • OneRidgeOff
    4 years ago

    I think stainless and color matched drains are both available from Blanco. I went for the stainless 3 in 1 basket strainer, which I find very functional.

    And here is a view of a standard half sheet baking pan I used for tonight’s dinner, ready to be washed. It’s nice to be able to lay them flat for a good soak, impossible to do in my previous split bowl sink.

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    I like that strainer combo. And yes, I currently have a double basin and I hate it. Anything bigger than a bowl is a pain to wash.

  • cpartist
    4 years ago

    What has been said about Signature Hardware?

    Here is a link to Starcraft's in-depth research and rating of the company's products. They get a 5-6 out of 10 from Starcraft.

    Starcraft Builder's Write-up on Signature Hardware

    This is for their plumbing fixtures, NOT their tubs and sinks. Please don't conflate the two!

    I actually have a copper Signature Hardware sink and it's great. I also have Signature Hardware cast iron tub and it's been great. I would have no issues buying a Signature Hardware tub or sink.

  • Helen
    4 years ago

    FWIW I found a shot that gives a good idea of what a living patina sink looks like - it's virtually maintenance free.


    I did NOT wanted a hammered bottom on my sink because I thought it would be problematic for cleaning and in when looking at sinks, most of the hammered sinks were of poor quality and looked artificial and obnoxious. I did opt for a hammered front because I thought the bottom of my sink and the front would be exposed to different things and the hammered front would better disguise any discrepancy. Also the way in which Havens actually "hammers" the apron is very subtle and not the busy obnoxious look that most of them have.


    I do have a relatively inexpensive hammered copper sink in my guest bath because I am not concerned about maintenance in that room since it is used almost never :-). It is from Premiere Copper which is a great source for copper stuff. They supplied my copper hood as well as copper accent tiles. They also did a custom copper medallion - my designer sketched it out using an Art Nouveau statue of a crane that I have and we both love. I also have a copper ceiling. My old kitchen had the standard dropped plastic sheets covering fluorescent tubes and my new lighting now has lots of canned lights - under cabinet task lights. However, I have structural soffits so my designer used the higher space in the middle to create a dramatic coved copper tiled ceiling with uplighting.




    Here's a pretty good shot of the sink when it was installed. It pretty much still looks like this with some shiny patches that fairly quickly change.





    Copper medallion with crane and copper hood




    Front of my apron sink which has the very subtle hammered treatment




    Terrible photo of the coved ceiling :-)

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Helen, I'm going to go out on a limb and say you like copper.


    Looks beautiful by the way!


    We may get brave sometime in the future and try copper, but right now, we just can't afford it. I've looked at the more cost-friendly options, and I just don't like them nearly as much as the Havens or the Rachiele.

  • 2ManyDiversions
    4 years ago

    OT: (sorry to hijack for another minute, Haley), Helen, the interior of that sink is gorgeous! Your kitchen is beautiful, tasteful, and I can't wait to see the reveal... I'm sorry you've had so many outside issues.

    Haley, I understand about not wanting a living patina in the kitchen. I do love Helen's, and sure am glad DH hadn't seen her photos, otherwise he'd have strongly pushed for it. He has great taste, btw.

  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    2ManyDiversions, no worries! It's keeping the post active so people keep commenting.


    Yes, they're beautiful! Maybe one day we might be brave enough to try a copper sink, but I'm just not sure how I would like it. I know soapstone is considered a "living finish" by many, but it's a bit more predictable.

  • OneRidgeOff
    4 years ago

    This has been an interesting thread! I myself embrace both worlds of living finish vs. low maintenance/easy care. You’ve seen my kitchen which is on the low maintenance end of the spectrum (Silgranit and one of the more bulletproof granites, Volga Blue). But I have soapstone remnant counters in one bath, and living finish copper sinks in two other baths. I did consider soapstone for my kitchen, but ended up needing a very large slab for a seamless island, since visible seams really irritate me, so I had more options in granite.

    I’m a rather messy cook but fairly tidy in the bath, so I get to embrace both worlds :) My husband on the other hand is not the tidiest guy, so I am glad the living finish copper is contained to our private bath. (His toothpaste brand is helping the copper evolve in patina lol). Our powder room copper sink only experiences mild hand soap, so it looks virtually the same as since new.

    I’ve honestly loved how all of my choices have turned out. But that’s because I spent months reading different threads and asking many questions here before committing to choices. Ask as many questions as you need, to feel confident in your personal choices.


  • Haley
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Hahahaaa! I can imagine. However, I would probably be a worse culprit if we had copper sinks in our bathrooms. I'm a slight skincare fanatic and use chemical exfoliators on occasion. I can just imagine how many shiny spots would be in my sink.

  • D N
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @Helen, I love your backsplash behind your cooktop! Anything you could share about the name of the blue tile or where you found it? The crane is lovely too!

  • Helen
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @ DN - Thanks. The backsplash tiles are Pratt & Larson - from their metallic glazed line. C611. They have a slight iridescent glaze and are much prettier in person than in the picture of the tile from their website.



    Pratt & Larson Tiles

  • D N
    4 years ago

    Very nice; I love the iridescence. We'll see if the SO (significant other) can be persuaded, lol.