I'm in agreement with you that for your situation something of low contrast would be best. You could have the shutters more or less match the house color (or even go ligher, say a cream color) or a soft green with yellow tones to it. I would let the landscaping provide the color (and I'm so hoping you're not doing grass in your tropical environment) and let it be the lush counterpoint to your cool-looking light colored house. I think it would be beautiful.

I was going to say turquoise LOL but I agree with browny - since your siding is a muted gray-green, and it looks like you have black shutters and door, then maybe mix black and the brick (*your* brick not generic) red. I don't know that people usually put cushions on Ad. chairs, so how about painting the footrests (yes, turn them around) and table one color and the chairs the other? I'd like the chairs black and the smaller pieces brick. If that bothers you then paint the chairs and the footrests the same color and just paint the table the other color - your choice, brick chairs with black table b/t the black shutters would look nice too.

Tough decision! I like them both. But ... I like the darker one(on right) a bit more. I like that it gives more contrast and is a deeper tone. Either would look great, though. :)

Beautiful home. Ask your painter how many days of prep and priming. Let houzzer's help narrow down a good warm white in the next day or two. Have your painter paint large samples of your top three paints in a few different areas of the house and look at it at different times of day. I presume doors and shutters can be painted last. If using FB for doors and shutters, get a FB fan deck over nighted. Narrow down the choices and get some Sampilze sheets overnighted. You might spend $100-$125 in shipping and sample fees but worth it to get the right color. I don't like color matching SW or BM paints to FB colors. I've done it with disappointing results. I think it is better to find a SW/BM color similar enough to FB instead. This has worked much better for me. Here's a good matching chart: https://www.colorsbykellyhaller.com/farrow-ball-colors-matched-to-benjamin-moore I like Wimborne White (FB), similar to Mountain Peak White (BM) - classic white with a tiny bit of cream. Review of Mountain Peak Whitehere. I can see pigeon looking too washed out, unless you have a very creamy white against it. Your inspiration pics are subtle and beautiful, but in north light, with lots of greenery around, a grey roof, and viewed from afar, you might want to punch the green shutters up one or two notches so it doesn't appear faded out. I'd go for a green black with the door so the contrast with the shutters is more obvious. HOUSE SHUTTERS DOOR