Hi liptonjl, having fun yet? Picking out this stuff was such a headache for me. But then, now that I'm done, I miss the adreneline rush. LOL Two things; 1. Your floor color is very important in trying to choose your cabinets. What kind of wood floor? 2. Are you really looking at two different styles of cabinets? Or is it just the color? Those are so very different and like the others have said, the lighter one doesn't seem like the style you were looking for in Old World. That said, I do like the Burgundy ones in style but the brown appeals to me in color and looks nice with the granite. (probably because I have dark brown and an Old World theme) I did a quick mock up so you can see them side by side.

Thanks everyone! Mellyc123--Here's a photo (sorry it's so blurry) of the family room from when we first moved in. We've added some accessories and lighting, but the sectional, rug and credenza are the same. You can see it's much more masculine and darker wood and colors than the kitchen.

I like the round table, actually. It isn't enough table space to have a big knife-and-fork meal like a porterhouse ... but it is plenty of landing space for a cup of coffee and a tablet. Plus it is probably easier to navigate in or out of the innermost seats compared to a square table. I'm glad you were able to find a solution that works with what you have!

I would be wary of the vinyl planks as they can be slick, especially when wet. Scatter rugs on vinyl are exactly that...scattered around, slid somewhere you don't need them. We recently did a living room and hall with the vinyl flooring from Home Depot and the flooring is surprisingly slick, noticeably more than the oak floors in the dining room or the sheet vinyl in the kitchen. I normally wear soft soled shoes but had on a pair of boots with a harder sole and nearly fell on my rear just running into the room to grab something. I have solid rubber floor tile and also cork tile in my basement and I would pick either of them over vinyl for a kitchen. I do like the vinyl and will use it again just not in a kitchen.