Hi crl_, I don't think of the Jaclo as a pull-out/pull-down because it doesn't actually retract into the faucet, it just sits on top in the channel so I think they call it a pull-off? I really wanted one but my husband did not like it so we have a wall-mount with side spray from Chicago Faucets. They have lots of side spray options if you would consider something like that. Or, might a wall-mount articulating faucet like the Kohler Karbon meet your needs?

Of course, everyone uses their faucets differently, but I'm glad my delta doesn't retract automatically. As I'd mentioned in another thread, I pull out my faucet and fill large stockpots, resting the head on the edge of the pot - using it as a pot filler. It frees up my hands to do something else. I also find that if I pull out the hose and wash out pots or whatever else needs to be washed, I get less splashing if the head is lower in the sink. I'd hate to fight against an automatic retraction feature. When I'm done, I just use my hand to push the faucet head back towards its dock where the magnet attracts it the last inch or so. Helene

"The improved clearance is fantastic for washing large pots and pans. Much less swinging it out of the way than I did with the lower faucet styles years ago. A taller arched fixture in the utility sink is also much handier than the low-set typical utility faucet." Well said, Olga. This size is pretty standard for many homeowners now, but smaller, sleeker options are still available, of course.

I've had cheap faucets and I've had expensive and have not observed a difference in difference in performance, quality, or longevity (with the possible exception of Chicago Faucets--those things are forever). They are also simple to replace yourself (if you don't change the hole pattern) so it's not a lifetime commitment. Use the one you wanted in the first place. I think the luck is random.