I don't have the info on the bar stools that we bought, but here's some random thoughts. There are 2 different heights for kitchen stools, we bought the 30"; the other ones are shorter (I forget the measurement, 26"(?)). When the stools are "tucked" in at the bar, they wood gets damaged where it comes in contact with the counter top edge, from pushing in the stools too far. We have already changed (after 2 years) the material and the foam under the material; the foam was just cheap and it was like sitting on an uncomfortable wood bench. We also got the stools that self-spin back to face the counter after leaving the seat. Outside of the damaged wood backs, these bar stools are holding up fairly well.

I read through some of the reviews, and one person complained the footrest sticks out too far which is great news for you! And as with anything, people either love them or hate them. Good advice from colonel115 about checking the weight capacity. Price is for two stools. https://www.allmodern.com/furniture/pdp/adjustable-25-swivel-bar-stool-mnq1423.html?piid=9325419 This one is twice the price, but looks very comfortable. https://www.allmodern.com/furniture/pdp/urban-unity-travis-adjustable-height-bar-stool-snpn4478.html

We have 4 upholstered room and board cora swivel chairs that have held up really well with a cat, dog, and lots of use (plus one move). Swivel was great for our set up that sounds similar to yours. I wanted to get their leather versions but we couldn't swing the expense in the cora style, but I'm pleasantly surprised how well the fabric versions have held up. The one slightly (but not very negative) thing about the fabric is that pet & human hairs seem to cling to it altho I might be the only one who notices. The legs show no wear and tear whatsoever despite banging around them with a vacuum, and we sit there so often that I would've expected more scuff marks and whatnot.

@cawaps good catch! Paint or stain on existing stools. But if they're ugly, they can be replaced. Not totally sure if they can ever real go with the tractor seat stool or not. for that matter...