Short answer is that I think as long as they have good looking greenery, they should improve since they have a few months more of growing to go before they are ready. Finally got back into the garden and dug around the shallots since I wanted to see about the "squshy" part before replying. I planted the same kind of shallot sets - Old German - at three different times: last fall, indoors in February and transplanted out in April and outdoors directly in late March. All of them have healthy greenery and are between 5 and 12 inches tall. The only ones that have anything squishy around the sides are the ones I planted in late March and I think that it the remnants of the bulb wrapper that normally decays and disappears as the shallot uses the energy stored in the bulb to put out roots and initial greenery. They are all small, around the diameter of a pencil, but that's been normal for them at this time of year. They should start putting out much more greenery over the next couple of months and the bulbs should start sizing up around the end of June in our area. I've never tried from seed - I wonder if you'll get good sized shallots this year or if you have to leave them for another year's worth of growth?

Certainly one gigantic list for a new collector. It does remind me of me. Here's a taste of similar conifer overdose a list of some plants I planted in the first five years. Abies(314 different, 488 total) Alba(23 different, 35 total) Aargau(UK)(2) Aurea(UK) (possibly Abies firma 'Aurea') Badenweiler(SD) possibly 'Schwarzwald' Barabits Star(LD) Bystricka(TM) Compacta(SD) Green Spiral(INT)(3) Hana(SD) Havel(SD) Hedge(SD) Holden Arboretum WB(SD) Hockstucki(UK)(2) Ibergeregg(MD) Kladsko(SD) Mlada Boleslav(SD)(2) Pancake(UK) Probably Abies koreana Pectinana Compacta(likely Compacta)(SD) Pendula(LG)(3) Pyramidalis(INT) Scarabantia(SD) Schwarzwald(SD)(3) Sejna(SD) Species(LG)(4) Amabalis(3 different, 5 total) Compacta(SD)(2) Procumbens(SD) Spreading Star(LD)(2) Balsamea(21 different, 34 total) Bear Swamp(SD) Bruce's Variegated(LD)(2) Eugene Gold(SD)(2) Frozen Fingers(UM) - dead Golden Eye(MD?) - dead Hudsonii(SD) Idea(SD) Jamy(TM) ?? (Jamie?) Jorma(TM) Mike S.(UK) Nana(SD)(2) Old Ridge(SD) Temp Piccolo(TM)(3) Piccolo(TM)(2) Buchholz Prostrata(SD)(3) Rangely Blue(LG) R. Stevens(SD) Tee Pee(SD) Treehaven Dwarf(SD) Tyler's Blue(SD)(4) Weeping Larry(INT)(3) Wolcott Pond(SD)(2) Verkade's Prostrate(MD) Concolor(10 different, 10 total, 26 dead) (Note many are suffering from a rust issue, working on a fix) Archer's Dwarf(LD) - dead Birthday Broom(TM) Blue Cloak(INT) dead Blue Sapphir(TM) Seems fine Bryce Canyon(SD) Bugy Wugy(SD) By Road(SD) dead Candicans(INT)(1) Compacta(SD)(2) dead Conica(LD)(2) dead Gable's Weeping(LD) dead Glenmore(INT) dead Hosta La Vista(TM)(Hidden Lakes WB) Husky Pup(TM) Igel(SD) - Probably Abies grandis King's Gap(SD) dead Kinky(LD) dead Kojakovice(TM) dead La Veta(SD)(3) Health Morton(UK) dead Ostrov nad Ohri(MD) dead Piggelme(TM) Pyramidalis(UK) dead Rochester(LD) dead Scooter dead St. John(TM) Health Wattezii Prostrate(LD) dead Wintergold(LD) Fraseri(11 different, 15 total) Compacta(SD) Dennys Doll(SD) Fastigiata Compacta(SD)(2) Flynn's Flash(MD) Klein's Nest(LD)(2) Nana(SD) Temp Old Glory(UK) Prostrata(LD)(3) Rawles WB(UM) Reeseville Selection(LD) Wingle's Blue Bonnet(SD) Vasti(SD) Grandis(8 different, 8 total) Aurea(INT)(x2) Cascade Falls(LG) Compacta(SD) Igel(TM) Leutenegger(INT) (x concolor)(x3) Leonovice(SD) Pendula(INT) Van Dedem's Dwarf(SD) Koreana(76 different, 143 total) X procera #2(INT)(2) Alpine Star(SD)(2) Amy's Afternoon(TM) Aurea(LD)(3) Aurea Jeddeloh Clone(SD) Beskid Gold(SD) Black Prince(MD) Blaue Zwo(INT)(5) Blauer Eskimo(SD)(5) Blauer Pfiff(LD)(6) Blinsham Gold(UK) Blue Emperor(MD) Blue Magic(SD) Blue Standard(LD) Blue Star(UK) Bonsai Blue(SD) Brevifolia(SD) Brilliant(SD) Cis(SD)(3) Compact Dwarf(SD) Dark Hill(UK) Dennis(TM) Doni-Tajuso(TM)(actually 'Gruebele') Eisregen(TM) Festival(SD) RIP Fincham's Seedling(INT) Fliegender Untertasse(SD) Fruhlingsgold(UK) Gait(LD)(3) Gelbbunt(SD)(2) Glauca(INT)(3) Gnome(TM) Golden Glow(SD)(3) Golden Dream(SD)(2) Green Ball(TM)(2) Green Carpet(LD)(6) Green Compact(SD)(2) Green Spreader(SD) Gruebele(TM) Hexenbesen Wursten(SD)(3) Horstmann(SD)(2) Inge(Grazil)(SD) Inverleith(UK) Kleiner Prinz(TM)(probably same as 'Inge'/'Grazil') Kobalt(UK) Kohout's Hexe(TM)(2) Kohout's Icebreaker(SD)(3) Kristallkugel(TM)(2)(actually 'Gruebele') Lippetal(SD) Same as 'Hexenbesen Wursten'? Moll(UK) Ordered Nadalkissen(SD)(4) Nana(SD) (Possibly 'Oberon') Nanaimo(LD) Nigrans(MD) Oberon(SD)(2) Ohltacca(INT) Ottostrasse(TM) Pancake(?) Piccolo(TM) Pinocchio(SD)(2) Prostrate Beauty(SD)(4) Rodzyn Gold(UK) Schwedenkönig(SD) Silber Zwerg(SD) Silbermavers(SD)(2) Silberperl(SD)(3) Silberkugel(SD)(3) Silberlocke(INT)(6) [Silberlocke Seedling #1(UK)] [Silberlocke Seedling #2(UK)] [Silberlocke Seedling #3(UK)> Silberreif(SD) Silver Show(LD)(2) Stark's Dwarf(?) Likely 'Starker's Dwarf Starker's Dwarf(SD)(4) Taiga(SD) Tannja(SD) Tundra(SD)(2) Vengels(MD)(x2) Verdener Dom(SD) Ordered Wellenseind(TM) Wiki(SD)? Winter Goldtip(SD)(2) Unknown(MD) - Rare Tree, probably 'Compacta' Zehucise(SD) Zwergform Wuestemeyer(SD)(2) Lasiocarpa(25 different, 35 total) var. arizonica 'Glauca Compacta'(LD)(4) var. shastensis 'WB' Possibly Abies magnifica? Alpine Beauty(TM) Argentea(LD)(3) Blue Bear(LD)(2) Probably 'Argentea' Blue Waterfall(LG) Compacta(SD) Cvikov(TM) Daycreek(SD) DuFlon(UM) Frank(UK) Glacier(INT) Green Globe(TM) Hoyt HB(LD) Kyle's Alpine(SD) Jorg(SD) Logan Pass(UM)(3) Lopalpun(UM)('Logan Pass) Martha's Vineyard(SD) Mulligan's Dwarf(SD) Prickly Pete(SD)(2) Pride's Select(UK)(2) Siskiyou(UM) Siskiyou broom(UM)? Species(LD)(3) Stanley K(TM) Steven's Blue(TM) Utah(TM) Nordmanniana(24 different, 36 total) Barabit's Compact(SD)(x2) Brandt(MD) Berlin Dahlem(TM)(2) Broom H(TM)(3) Columnaris Szmit(?) Dobrichovice(?) Durham Dwarf(UK) Eifel(TM?) RIP Golden Spreader(LD)(5) Hunnewell WB(SD) - Probably Broom H Hupp's Perfect Pillar(INT)(2) "Hupp's Seedling #1] [Hupp's Seedling #2] [Hupp's Seedling #3] Jakobsen(SD) KBNG WB(TM) Now named Broom H Lennartz Midwinter Gold(UK) Muesterland(SD) Pendula(INT)(3) Petra(SD) Robusta(LG) Species(LG) Starker's Dwarf(SD)(2) Silver Del[Kaiser's Creamy](MD) Tortfolia(LG) Trautmann(SD)(correct form) Trautmann(INT) Perhaps not nordmanniana Bethlehem WB(TM)(2) Pinsapo(10 different, 14 total) Atlas(#2)(TM) Aurea(INT)(3) Fastigiata(LD) RIP Fatima(#1)(SD)(2) Glauca(LG)(2) Horstmann(SD) Kelleriis(INT) Marokko(#3)(SD) Monteverde(SD) Soltan(UK) Tuarek(#4)(SD) Procera(38 different, 57 total) Bizarro(SD) Blaue Hexe(SD)(3) Blue Spiral(LD)(2) Blue Wonder(SD) Ordered Danish Column(INT)(2) [Danish Gold](UK) Delbar's Cascase(INT)(5) Glauca(INT)(2) Glauca Procumbens(SD) Glauca Prostrata(SD)(2) Hupp's Blue(INT)(2) Hupp's Christmas Tree(LD)(3) Hupp's Compact(SD)(2) Hupp's Dwarf(TM) [Hupp's Seedling#1(SD)] [Hupp's Seedling#2(SD)] [Hupp's Seedling#3(SD)] [Hupp's Seedling#4(SD)] [Hupp's Seedling #5(UK)] [Hupp's Dwarf Weeper(UK)] [Hupp's Golden Seedling(UK)] Hupp's Single Snake(INT)(2) Hupp's Weeping(INT) Probably Delbar's Cascade La Graciosa(INT)(3) [Leo's Seed Orchard Dwarf(SD)] Medusa(LG) [Mier's Fastigata](UK) [Mier's Variegated](UK) Noble's Dwarf(SD) Obrighofen(SD) Pendula(INT) Pesek(SD) Pospisil(TM) Procumbens(SD) ?? Rat(INT) [Rice Hill Weeper(UK)] Rick's Foxtail(SD) Robenek(TM) Seattle Mountain(UK) Sherwoodii(LD)(3) Silver(LG) Species Yin(TM) [Tolines Farm WB(top)] Yang(TM) [Tolines Farm WB(bottom)] Veitchii(14 different, 27 total) var. olivacae(INT)(2) var. sikokiana(UK)(2) Aurea(UK)(2) Drevenack(TM) Glauca(LG)(3) Haltern(TM) Heddergott(SD)(3) Heine(SD)(3) Kohout's WB(SD) Kramer(SD) Pendula(INT)(3) Rumburk(SD)(3) Schneverdingen(SD) Species(1) Rare, Misc. Fir(51 different, 69 total) borisii-regis J.K. Greece(SD) bracteata Saint Lucia Fir(INT) On order - Bethlehem cephalonica(3 total) Anthione(SD) Meyer's Dwarf(SD) Minityp(SD) chensiensis Prostrata Glauca(LD) cilicica Greg's Broom(SD) Hunnewell WB(SD) likely same plant as 'Greg's Broom' Spring Grove(LD)(3) delavayi var. delavayi(LG) var. Forrestii(INT)(4) Buchanan(SD) Major Neish(SD) Nana(LD) durangensis var. coahuilensis(UK) fargesii Species(INT) Temp Headford(LD)(2) firma Golden Hue(UK)(2) Halgren(UK) Sol(LG) georgeii Species?(UK)(2) [Hupp's Seedling #1(Good Form)] var forestii(Forestfarm)(UK) holophylla Species, moved to Arboretum homolepis F.R. Newmann(SD) Havel(UK) Prostrata(LD)(2) Species(LG) Tomomi(UK) Wintergold(INT) Variegated(UK) koreana X lasiocarpa (koreocarpa) Diskus(SD) Freundenberg(MD)(3) Inga(MD)('Hurricane Blue')(x3) Species(UK)(2) lasiocarpa X shastensis Horstmann(TM) magnifica Mt. Si(SD) Nana(SD)(3) Prostrata(SD) mariesii Dr. Fricks(SD)(x2) nebrodensis Sicilian Gold(LD) nordmanniana subsp. equi-trojani Frank(SD) Barney(SD) Same plant as 'Frank', proper name 'Frank' [Hupp's Spire](INT) numidica Glauca(UK) Pendula(INT)(2) Select(UK) pindrow [Mier's Fastigate](UK) siberica Liptovsky Hradok(TM) Serko(SD) Wiry(UK) siberica var. alpina Species(unknown) squamata Flakey(INT?) vejarii Mountain Blue(LG)(3) X arnoldiana(veitchii x koreana) Poulsen(LD)(2) X umbellata Species(LG)(2) -Will

I wouldn't give up and I would try not to get too discouraged. After all, the last two years have had horrendous heat and long periods of drought that have left even life-long gardeners who've gardened successfully for decades shaking their heads and wondering if things possibly could get any worse. Sometimes you can do everything right and things just don't work out. Gardening is not an instant gratification type of activity. To get the results you want, you have to be as persistent as the most persistent of plants, like bermuda grass or ragweed. Plants sometimes die, seeds don't sprout, a neighbor's herbicide drifts through the air and kills your plants....hail smashes your seedlings that you've grown from seed and carefully nurtured or maybe a tornado hits or hail falls...or pests eat your seeds or deer and rabbits devour your plants and the birds and squirrels eat your nut and fruit crops, etc. There are no guarantees and even the folks with the greenest thumbs around lose their share of plants. It happens. I never decide that a plant "won't" or "can't" grow here at our place until I personally have grown it and killed it three times. Even then, I sometimes come back a couple of years later and try again, feeling like the plant that won't/can't grow for me is just a riddle to be explored and solved. The key is to learn from each experience and adjust your processes accordingly. That is how we humans (sometimes ever so slowly) turn our black thumbs into green thumbs. If you have trouble keeping purchased plants in containers alive, you should examine your watering practices. Most people who have this sort of issue are watering their plants too much, a phenomenon known as "loving your plants to death". If you feel like you may be watering too much, purchase a little hand-held moisture meter. You can find them in big box stores, especially in spring time, often near the seeds and seed-starting supplies. You stick the probe of the moisture meter into the soil and you do not water if it shows the soil is moist. Or, use the good old finger method....stick your finger 2 or 3" down into the soil in the container and do not water if you feel moist soil. Sometimes new gardeners over-water because they touch the surface of the soil and it is dry. The plant roots are not on the surface...they are down deeper....so that is the area you need to check for moisture. If your plants are fine while in containers, but die after being put into the ground, examine closely the timing of their planting. Even plants raised from seed in containers or purchased from a store have a time that is best for them to be put into the ground. If you are transplanting them at a time that is either too early and too cold, or too late and too hot for each type of plant, that may be the problem. With seeds, are you wanting a list of some you can start indoors now in flats? Or outdoors in the ground? Let me know and I'll suggest some that meet your needs. When attempting to grow anything, it all starts with the soil. I cannot emphasize that strongly enough. If you are having trouble getting new plants to grow outdoors in the ground, something likely is wrong with the soil. My best guess is that you either have very sandy or silty soil that is low in nutrients and doesn't hold moisture well, so that whatever you plant is too hungry and too dry to grow, or you have heavy clay soil that is dense and compacted and won't allow root growth. Either of these types of soil can be fixed. You also might merely have sandy or silty soil that is highly compacted, which is almost as bad as clay, but much each easier to fix in terms of drainage but harder to fix in terms of nutrition. That fact that you have some established plants growing tells you that something will grow in your soil. However, many ornamentals grown from bulbs and seeds need a looser, more friable soil than shrubs and trees will grow in. At our house, we have many trees and shrubs growing in our dense, heavily-compacted red clay, but I'd never attempt to grow any sort of flowering ornamental in that soil without first doing massive amounts of amendment. Turning the soil you have into the soil you want so that you can grow the plants you want can take time. With the dense red clay soil in front of our house, I amended it for seven years and planted only annual flowers there until I felt it was well-amended enough for me to plant shrubs into it. It was sort of ridiculous to spend that long, but I saw what that clay was like when the house was being constructed and it wasn't pretty. I lost plenty of annual flowers in that area over the years...in wet years some kinds died, in dry years other ones did, but as the soil got better and better every year, less and less died. When the soil finally arrived at the place that I knew it was 'fixed' and ready for anything I wanted to plant there within reason, I planted shrubs, perennials and annuals and, nowadays, I can plant pretty much anything I choose in that location, as long as I choose plants that tolerate our summer heat and drought. Seven years is a long time to experiment and a long time to work to fix soil, but it paid off. I could have fixed it faster and planted in one year, but I was dealing with establishing several different planting areas on different parts of the property and I wanted to fix the soil right so I never had to come back and replace shrubs and trees because they wouldn't grow where they were planted (and I haven't had to do that either). To me, the fact that the trees and shrubs in this area survived the last two drought years with almost no irrigation is evidence that the slow, steady, long-term approach to soil improvement paid off. Please note that I am not saying it will take you seven years to turn the soil you have into the soil you want--just that with the worst soil on our property, that is how long it took me. If you haven't already done the soil jar test for soil texture and composition that I'm going to link below, I'd suggest it is a good starting point. I did this test for the soil in every separate area of our property where I intended to plant something during our first few years here. Our soil varies strongly, changing at times every few feet, so just because I have dense red clay in one spot doesn't mean I have it everywhere. In some spots I found some pretty nice clay with some sand mixed with it, and in other spots I found hideous sandy-stuff which drained so quickly that everything I planted in it the first 3 or 4 years died within its first year. That was another area that required massive soil amendment to make it hold enough moisture to sustain plant life in the summer months. Once you know what sort of soil you have, you can figure out what to do to make it more receptive to good plant growth. As for relatively fool-proof plants, I have a list of plants about which I say "they won't die and you cannot kill them". The list varies, though, depending on what sort of soil you have. Generally cannas, which traditionally are grown from tubers (but now can be grown from seed that will give you blooms a few months after you sow the seed) are on this list, although they can die in the winter in dense, slow-draining soil that holds too much moisture. Morning glories are another plant that is easy from seed, but they'll need a fence or trellis to climb. It may not be your soil. It may be watering practices or something else, or it may be an issue of timing. Zinnias grow great in warm weather, but the seed or even young seedlings can rot and die if planted too early into cold soil, for example. The fact that your lantana died makes me think you might have dense clay that drains slowly. I can grow lantana here only in areas with well-drained soil, and mine still don't get as big as my friends' lantanas get in their really sandy, really well-draining soil, but then, they have issues with tomatoes not growing in that soil because it drains too fast and is prone to nematodes, while tomatoes grow like mad in my amended clay. We all have soil types in which some things will thrive but others will not. The trick is to match up the type of soil you have with the type of plants that grow in it. My brother had white limestone caliche clay soil in Texas and you wouldn't have thought much would grow in it, but we worked and found trees, shrubs and flowers that did well in it. To grow fruit and veggies, we had to remove thousands of rocks and haul in a purchased topsoil/compost mix, but after that, he could grow anything. So, I'm confident that you can find something that will grow in the soil you have, and if you have to amend it to make that possible, then that's what you have to do. Some "die-hard" plants that have grown well for me in the years when I was amending soil and improving it for future years included daffodils, cannas, daylilies, hollyhocks, coral honeysuckle, alliums, dutch iris, dutch hyacinths, verbena bonariensis, four o'clocks, scabiosa, zinnias, morning glories, chamomile (a delightfully-scented herb with small white daisy-like flowers), Texas hummingbird sage, cosmos, malva sylvestris 'Zebrina', and pink evening primrose (horrifically invasive in good soil, but will grow in any soil on our property no matter how poor it is so I planted a lot of it in the early years here), poppies, Laura Bush petunias (not a standard petunia, a petunia derived from native petunias, making it heat-tolerant), and larkspur. All of these are easily grown when directly sown and for, most of them reseed and come back every year on their own with no help from me at all. Be sure you are sowing the seeds properly. Some tiny seeds need to be surface sowed and lightly pressed into the soil and left uncovered because they need light to sprout. I mist those lightly with a hand-held misting bottle because watering them with a hose will wash the seeds away before they can sprout. I also try to sow them and get them to sprout when heavy rain is not forecast because heavy rainfall can wash away the tiny seeds before they sprout. Some of the things you listed with which you experienced poor results really don't care much for our climate. I love the appearance of foxgloves, but they are not well-suited to our hot summers, for example. Elephant ears are tropicals and can fail if planted while soil is still too cold. With everything that's given you trouble, I can think of a reason that you might have had problems, but without knowing for sure exactly what the conditions were at the time they were planted or transplanted, I'd just be guessing. Please keep trying and do not give up. Instead of trying dozens of different plants from seed in a given season, pick out 5 or 6 that you really want to grow, and focus on succeeding with them. Then, every year, add a few more that are new to you. The orange daisies that you planted are a clue about what will grow for you, but to figure it out, you need to know what they are. Since you say they smell bad, I'm wondering if you're talking about marigolds. Marigolds are pretty easy to grow and often reseed themselves. I grow French marigolds, but don't usually plant the larger African marigolds. When I have a problem area where nothing seems to thrive, I deliberately plant something there that is known to be highly invasive....like mint. I'll buy a mint plant and put it in that spot and see how it goes. If mint won't grow there, I try sowing pink evening primrose or larkspur seed there.. There's almost nowhere on our property where I cannot grow either mint or pink evening primrose as both wlll grow in sand/siltyy fast-draining soil (though mint may not survive summer drought in really fast-draining soil unless you water it a lot) and both tolerate dense clay, though the pink evening primrose tolerate it better than the mint will. Poppies and larkspur perform great in my red clay, even unimproved red clay, in all but the wettest of years. In a very wet year, though, they rot off right above the ground. Sometimes we just want to grow something that we love, even though our soil may not be suitable for that plant. I love Texas bluebonnets and have tried and tried and tried to grow them here. The issue is that our clay soil tends to stay too wet in winter for them, except in the driest of winters, and our sandy-silty soil where I grow some flowers is too shady for them. I have had luck with them only in the area right alongside the gravel driveway, where they thrive in the gravel. In dry years we have a lot of them in bloom in April and May, and in wet years, there's a lot less and sometimes practically none. I've accepted I'll never have a wildflower meadow full of Texas bluebonnets, but I'll never give up on having at least a few of them in bloom every year. This is our fifthteenth year here and it is the first time that we have more bluebonnet plants sprouting alongside the driveway than I can count. Some years we've had so few that I could count them on the fingers of two hands. Last year, I counted 86 plants. This year, I stopped counting at 120. Still, if we were to start having a lot of rain that kept their area waterlogged, some or even all of them would drown and rot before they could bloom. That just makes me appreciate them all the more in the year when the weather and soil allow them to live long enough to bloom and set seed. If growing from seed is vexing, buy the kinds of plants you want to grow in six-packs in the spring months when they are easy to find and relatively inexpensive. Transplant them and nurture them. Once you've succeeded in keeping them alive from purchased transplants, then the following year, try growing them from seed. Many perennials are slow to grow from seed and often require cold scarification or even more complicated cold-wet or alternating-temperature scarification in order to get the seed from sprout. These are great candidates for winter sowing (see the wintersowing forum or wintersown.org for info on winter sowing) or you can just purchase them as transplants. When I want to try a perennial I haven't grown here before, I usually buy one transplant and plant it as a test plant. If it does well, then the following year I either buy more or raise them from seed. There are many beautiful perennials that grow very well in many parts of the country with cooler, milder weather but are very difficult if not impossible to grow here in our climate and soils. To find perennials that grow well here, look for the Proven Winners plant labels in nurseries or garden centers. You can google Oklahoma Proven Winners to find the website with these plants to get ideas for what to look for. One more thing. Be sure you are not using a weed and feed product on your lawn areas. The herbicides in those products, if they get into your flower-growing areas, can kill your flowers or prevent them from growing in the first place. Dawn Here is a link that might be useful: Soil Jar Test

A lot of plants look like that until they start to make flowers. OP is in New England, so the info from a college in CA might not be pertinent. The USDA plants database has about 50 different Plantagos, and the link says there are about 250 worldwide. Some introduced, some native, some are butterfly host plants. A lot of undesirable weeds have pretty cool flowers and as long as you remove them before they drop seeds, there is often no reason to remove them until you enjoy their flowers. Plantain wouldn't be one of those, but I'm not sure that's what it is. Especially if it's wilting in a flower bed. No self-respecting weed does that.