Kitchen cabinets: paint, reface, or buy new... oh my!
allijanelewis
5 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (6)
Related Discussions
Kitchen refacing with new cabinets in the mix - is this possible??
Comments (2)My sister just did this by using a custom cabinet maker. He refaced all the lowers and turned some of the cabinets into drawers. Then he built new uppers. I think there was one upper, or maybe two that were in good shape, so they refaced those and added another cab on top. Since he made the doors, for the refacing and the new cabs, they all match. When she compared stock, semi-custom and custom, his bid actually came out the lowest. Not sure why that is. Maybe because to make things fit right, there was a lot of customization needed on site during installation by the stock and semi-custom people. Paint was sprayed on site. It turned out beautifully. No appliance changes, so it was a relatively easy process, except for the painting week....See MoreWant to change kitchen cabinet color (either paint or reface)-
Comments (15)these are photos from the listing Theresa, first, let me say-I'm in love with all the cacti! Incredibly cool. many great things about the house. I'll try to answer the question about white cabinets. There will be many who'll say white kitchens are classic, and they'll be right, in a sense that there'll always be houses where white kitchens would look great and appropriate. Whether it's white glossy contemporary kitchens in some urban apartments, or white beaded doors in a cottage, or many others. Then there'll be many who'll say a white kitchen is at the end of its cycle, and they ill be right too, because too many people install same kitchen everywhere, and in 7-10 years another trend comes, and the other new trend is already here, and it's stained wood again. (especially certain woods in certain stains) There are also painted (or colorful) kitchens that are not white, and they can be also very nice, and fit a house like a glove. There's not one color that will make a place modern, or traditional, or whatever, all by ttself, because every color is a part of the bigger context. And our associations with it will depend on our own traditions, our own likes and dislikes, and how it correlates with the rest of the place. So I'd take the "whether white is here to stay" out of equation, and my questions to myself would be: -how white will work in my house, its style, where it stands, etc? how it will work with all the other elements, and what these elements are/will be? and -do I love white enough to look at it every morning and evening for years to come? Second question, only you can answer. In terms of the first question. Your house is transitional (whatever it means because it's not a very exact term) already. The legs on the island are the most traditional thing about our kitchen from what I can see. White itself wouldn't make it more contemporary kitchen. It might make you personally happier, but it won't be significant change in the feel of the kitchen. It will stay a transitional kitchen, pretty nice at that, just in different color. Now, I can't see the backsplash-but changing backsplash can give it more modern feel. Or changing legs on the island and refacing, say, to slab doors will give it more modern feel. But I need to understand whether that's what you want-or you just want departure from dark wood because you don't like darker wood. which is totally fine. For example you want just the departure from stain because your preference is painted. And your preferred color is white (which it doesn't have to be. My kitchen is taupe for example, and another colors I seriously considered were purple and, to the less extent, green) Then you need to decide-you keep your counter which is softer taupe..you take very clean bright white out of equation. But look for a softer "muddier" version of white. The one that'll work the best with your countertop..and the backsplash if backsplash stays. Maybe it's an off white, and you'll have to try several(ask for samples done on wood if you enlisting a pro) and look at them in your kitchen with your countertops etc, to make a decision. For us to give the best advice it'll be best to see the countertop and the backsplash up close. When you say "taupe" I guarantee you, well almost, that my brain pictures one color, and you mean slightly another one. There are hundreds of neutrals that we call white, gray, taupe, off white, etc, etc-and while it gives general description, it's not enough to then say "in your kitchen, with its light and all the unique things it has, color X by brand Y will work". All these colors change with light. and also in presence of other colors, and you need to narrow onto several and try them there. And it might be that while looking for that white you'll see another color you'll like more. Or you'll decide to go not for paint but for a different stain. That you like more. Or melamine (which means refacing. But maybe that what you actually want when you say "contemporary") Now don't forget that you'll decorate differently than previous owners did. It seems like too much dark wood because there are many elements in same stain. Most of them seem built in, but maybe not all of them are? You can also go with different materials when you pick tables, and chairs, and whatnot. You can introduce different lighting. (Layers of it too-very important) You can layer textures and add colors. You'll bring in your own art. Plants. Etcetera. In short, you won't see just the kitchen. The kitchen will be a part of a whole. Look at many pictures if you haven't yet. and see how they make you feel, to choose the general pallette for the house first. A start. Can be interiors but many images can be inspiration for colors, from fashion to cinematography. And also nature. Especially landscape surrounding your house(they did a great job with it)-whatever you see from your window is still your space)) Part of it. So let it inform you too and inspire you, when you choose. Most choices that look great throuout years and never bore us are these that go with the house and its surroundings. I quite like the bathroom, and it doesn't feel dragged down to me. It's just largely empty because they staged for resale. As they did with other places. Add but a flowerpot-and it'll feel differently. I really tried to make this post short, but didn't quite succeed))) Bottom line: I can see why you like the house. The previous owners didn't do anything majorly irritating. They neutralized for resale and had quite a lot of one-note things, certain stain, stacked stone that adds a bit of heaviness etc. But it's a nice house. I know that feeling of being in a hurry-but try not to be, give yourself sometime to figure out the pallette that works for both you and the house, maybe start with furnishings even as fabrics give us inspiration and ideas too..don't worry, you'll get to that paint thing, but you'll be happier with whatever choice you make when you make it not in a hurry. I personally would be inclined to yes, use sage green..or some other soft grayed green, yes..but would it be kitchen itself, or walls, or fabrics, or accents? Or maybe tonal shades in several of these? I don't know. I'd need to be in the house and think. Same goes for every other choice. It's a puzzle that you put together. And as with puzzles-there's fun in it. Enjoy the process. Enjoy your new house....See MoreKitchen Cabinet Advice - Paint vs. Reface
Comments (30)Ok, few things. cabs are maple or birch. don't even consider Minwax for your floors. bottom of the barrel as far as quality goes. if you want the floors redone, call in pro refinisher. maybe think about doing a very light natural, using Bona system. I wouldn't go darker. Cabs themselves are fine. However, I'd want to change the countertops. You can try paint first, but if you want gray subway tile, consider changing out that black granite. these are a similar color. if you went darker on the walls like this, it would make the cabs really stand out. (lighter countertop though) Do a black pendant over the island. I even like the idea of painting just your island black. (but I'd redo the countertops. c-below) tried to give you a black island. for sure you'd need lighter countertops w/this look. if you must keep the black counters, you could try these pendants. There isn't one thing white in that kitchen. doing a white subway tile for the backsplash would look odd. And w/the more modern style, I think if you want white, do something other shape. but if you really want to change something start w/the countertop. I'd do something like this. lighter countertops. Maybe insert some glass in few of the uppers. similar cabs with marble (or a quartz marble) Here's your white subway, but notice the granite. The white tile compliments the granite. Putting white tile against your black countertop would look horrible. here's a light maple with medium gray quartz. It's meh. not much diff that what you have also like this for your pendant. (have you thought about changing your hardware?) if you don't like the dark charcoal paint color idea, here are some others. another option. lighter countertops and a back painted glass backsplash. you'll notice that most of these all have the same light floors like you have. spend your money on new countertops, lighting and backsplash if you want more of a drastic change. options for countertop...See MoreNew contemporary kitchen cabinets---refacing
Comments (4)My thoughts? He probably has a supplier with a warehouse full of cheap chinese flat painted or high gloss cabinets, that he will make a nice profit on, if you buy them! Unless you really know your contractor very well, I would not be taking design advice from one. What do you like and want for YOUR kitchen?...See Moreallijanelewis
5 years agoallijanelewis
5 years ago
Related Stories

KITCHEN CABINETS6 Kitchen Makeovers That Benefited From Refaced Cabinets
These kitchens show how updating rather than replacing cabinets can keep costs down while adding style
Full Story
KITCHEN CABINETSPros and Cons: Painted vs. Stained Kitchen Cabinets
Wondering whether to go for natural wood or a painted finish for your cabinets? These observations can help
Full Story
MOST POPULARRefaced Cabinets Brighten a California Kitchen
White cabinets, a new island and modern farmhouse style create a light and roomy space
Full Story
KITCHEN DESIGNKitchen of the Week: Refaced Cabinets Bring New Style and Warmth
Updated cabinets, new countertops and a new backsplash give a New Jersey couple a fresh kitchen for under $20,000
Full Story
MOST POPULARHow to Reface Your Old Kitchen Cabinets
Find out what’s involved in updating your cabinets by refinishing or replacing doors and drawers
Full Story
KITCHEN CABINETSKitchen Cabinet Color: Should You Paint or Stain?
Learn about durability, looks, cost and more for wooden cabinet finishes to make the right choice for your kitchen
Full Story
BEFORE AND AFTERSSee How Refaced Cabinets Brighten This Dated Kitchen
By updating the cabinets, countertop and backsplash, designers help a homeowner create a fresh, modern style on a budget
Full Story
INSIDE HOUZZInside Houzz: Refaced Cabinets Transform a Kitchen
No walls came down. No windows were added. But this once-dark kitchen looks completely different, thanks to bright new surfaces
Full Story
MOST POPULARFrom the Pros: How to Paint Kitchen Cabinets
Want a major new look for your kitchen or bathroom cabinets on a DIY budget? Don't pick up a paintbrush until you read this
Full Story
KITCHEN CABINETSHow to Update Your Kitchen Cabinets With Paint
A pro gives advice on when and how to paint your cabinets. Get the step-by-step
Full Story
Filipe Custom Woodwork