skip to main content

Refinishing stair railing

6 years ago

When attempting to clean 35 years of grime build up off my stair railing (using soapy water and a rag), I managed to remove most of the grime, but also most of the finish and a fair bit of the stain too. No big loss as I never loved it.

I'd like to refinish the railing and the post with a black or almost black stain (I'm open to paint if stain will be a giant PITA, but would prefer stain. I'll paint spindles white. I'm pretty sure it's all pine, if that matters.

So, what is the best way to go about refinishing the post and rail? Can I sand lightly and use a gel stain? Or do I need to sand down to bare wood? The post still has far more stain than the railing--will a dark stain mask that or do I need to get them looking the same to start?

Also, please note I embrace the "done is better than perfect" philosophy. I'm ok with cutting some corners in the interest of the project actually getting done, so I'm good with "good enough" (ie, the approach that doesn't require me to spend 72 hours sanding).

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

User
6 years ago
It would be unusual for the wood of the rail and post to be pine, as pine is a very soft wood unsuited for those uses. Maple is more traditional. Also maple for the spindles.

If you do not want sanding time, primer and paint are the best options. Gel stain, IMHO, is a substandard compromise between stain and paint, since it is more paint than stain and does not have primer on which to stick.

I'd use a gloss acrylic enamel(water based for convenience) over BIN (Zinsser product) shellac based primer.
elohbee thanked User
elohbee
Original Author
6 years ago
Maple would make sense, I just knew it wasn't oak.

I don't mind sanding some, just didn't want to be sanding endlessly. Would a traditional stain work if I sanded off all the old poly but not the old stain?

I should probably just start sanding a bit and see how it goes.

Thanks for the paint advice if I end up going that route!!
Related Discussions
Ideas for replacing interior 1950s iron railings and stair rail?
Q
Comments (15)
Be sure to sell or give away that beautiful old railing and not throw it on a heap. I happen to like it. But indeed, it might look better in black. The railing you have posted instead gave me some shudders. Quite a contrary style and not one I'd welcome in my home. Way too modern for a ranch home, is what comes to my mind. If you are really going to get a new railing, I like the one Judy proposed, although I wouldn't want it in white at your place. Perhaps in black and the railing that matches the wood of the stairs? Or maybe something like this?
...See More
Curved Stair/Balcony Handrail: Different Pattern on Inside Stair Rail?
Q
Comments (6)
Leave it be. Stair work is some of the most expensive zero payback work that you can have done. And what you had was so much better than the overwrought 1997 fakery shown.
...See More
stain for stairs hand rail
Q
Comments (0)
Hi what color should I stain this basement staircase handrail? I have “golden oak” through the rest of my home but she’s nice this is a basement, I wanted to go slightly darker in stain. Advice on a min wax stain? Stairs will be grey carpet and newel post painted white.
...See More
do i paint the underside of stair railing black as well as the rail?
Q
Comments (4)
Yes, of course you do. Take a few minutes to construct a cardboard or plastic shield that can be slid around each of your spindles to keep the paint from getting on them and then carefully paint the underside of the banister.
...See More
User
6 years ago
When stain is applied correctly, it is absorbed into the grain of the wood. Woods with more dense grain(like maple) absorb less stain, so sanding is generally less time consuming. Wood can be stained darker, but not lighter.

Stain will not be absorbed through any finish(save what is called a wash coat of shellac which is used to minimize blotching). Blotching occurs when a section of the wood absorbs more stain than surrounding areas because of the grain density. Softer woods(pine/etc) and open grain woods(oak/ash/etc) tend to blotch more than more dense grained wood.

Sanding finish can be quite time consuming and expensive, especially when the old finish gums up the sand paper. Which happens more times than not as a rule. Scratch coat sanding is an exception, since the finish is not removed, but just roughed up so primer can adhere better.
elohbee thanked User

Related Stories

STAIRWAYS How to Update Your Stairs and Railings

By Affecting Spaces Design Studio

Take your staircase to the next level with these 13 ideas

REMODELING GUIDES Architect's Toolbox: Aim High with Interior Railings

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

Expressive, evocative railings can take your stairs to new heights

TASTEMAKERS Expert Talk: Maynard Studios' Masterful Railings

By Lawrence Karol

These steel stair railings are hand forged, and no two are alike. See how they're made and how they take rooms from plain to breathtaking

STAIRWAYS Beautiful Stairs: Safety Meets Style

Solid to Near-Transparent Materials Turn the Humble Railing Into High Design

REMODELING GUIDES Flat-Sawn Balusters Give Railings All-Out Style

By Rachel Grace

Showcase designs from Victorian patterns to hints at your hobby with this decorative wood railing detail

Design Opportunity: Style in the Stairs

By Becky Harris

From ornate iron scrollwork to spiral-cut wood dowels, balustrades are great supporting acts

REMODELING GUIDES Artful Stairs: Continuity in Steel

Ribbonlike Stairs of Steel Seem to Nearly Float on Air

BEFORE AND AFTERS Oh Say, Can You Believe These $200 Star-Spangled Stairs?

By Vanessa Brunner

Once sporting a mucky 1970s look, this staircase can now proudly be hailed for its beach cottage charm

HOW TO PHOTOGRAPH YOUR HOUSE Step Right Up: Expressing Movement on Modern Stairs

Seeing a person on a staircase changes our perception of the design

STAIRWAYS 17 Ideas for Storage Under the Stairs

By Mitchell Parker

It’s not just about the ups and downs. These clever staircases also provide storage, display and seating

Sponsored

More Discussions

Handrail paint advice needed

5

White Oak Stain Wash Difference

10

Architecture/design help for open concept 1st floor

4

General Contractor questions

4

Advice Needed on Installing a Wood Accent Wall

2