Summer 2017 has been a complete disaster for my rose gardening

6 years ago

last modified: 6 years ago

I don't even know where to begin. I guess I will begin with last year. I had lots of flowers to cut and bring in for inside enjoyment. I left most of the bushes pretty much with no pruning to go through the winter, thinking that they would fare through cold winter better, having long canes, and then I could go through in the spring and prune out what didn't look so good. We had a pretty mild winter in NE Ohio, so there wasn't a huge amount of die back. I left the bushes pretty much as they were, until maybe the end of April and then thought that I should probably do something with them, so I cut them back a little in places. (I should add that I do not know what I am doing when it comes to correctly pruning roses, and I think that this is half my problem). I should also add that I have religiously fed all of them with a cup of either GardenTone or Plant Tone once a month since the end of April. It has cost me a fortune to do this, and I have gotten nothing for my efforts. I had Garden Tone left from last year and used that up first, then I purchased Plant Tone locally in a 36# bag, because that was what was on sale. From what I understand, the formulation from Rose Tone to Garden Tone to all the Tones is pretty much the same.

I will try and post a few photos of some of the plants. I have no flowers. Almost no new growth. They only thing I have managed to have is blackspot which I have sprayed for about 3 times for so far. I do no know what I have done wrong this year. I don't know if I have over fertilized, under fertilized, under watered, over watered, pruned wrong, pruned too late, pruned too little, pruned too much, etc. I am so distraught about this. I look forward to summer here in Ohio so much, because our winters are so dreary and drag on so. Summer is 3/4 over, so I can forget about this year. If I knew what happened, I would feel better, but I have thought and thought and thought about this, and have not come up with an answer. Does anyone have any idea? (I haven't posted a photo in a long time. If it doesn't work the first time, I will come back later and try again.)

Featured Answer

Patty W. zone 5a Illinois

6 years ago

last modified: 6 years ago

Vaporvac, I did not know the scourge has hit your garden as well. I have so many thoughts on rose midge that I don't know where to begin. I also don't enjoy contradicting the point of view of others. I have run the gamut from insecticide use to organic. I have had good years and bad.

Please forgive me those who disagree as I mean no disrespect. Man has tried to eliminate insect with insecticide for a hundred years or so. They failed but have succeeded in contaminating more than what can be listed here.

Insecticides are dangerous chemicals that have been banned by most of the civilized world. Not by the U.S. thou but this is politics that I can not go into.

In my opinion only if you are young I would never venture anywhere near them. Everyone owes it to themselves to at least look up the safety data sheets of the chemical that they are about to use. Then do what you feel is right. Remember you are choosing for your children, pets, and your neighbors as well.

I am convinced that rose midge increases in wet years. Many of us have had quite a bit of rain this year.

I believe that Ann is correct in viewing spider mites as possible predators of rose midge. The other possibility is that the dry conditions that bring spider mites out kill off many of the rose midge. Then it takes a while for their numbers to build again.

When we use insecticides we kill off something in the food chain that is responsible for keeping another insect under control. I used Bayer insecticide for 3 years when I first started garden and then it failed to work any longer.

Any thing that I have done is totally unscientific. So I can't really assume much of anything except that I have a sea of flowers out there without insecticides.

Three years ago rose midge was getting the upper hand here again. I thought perhaps I had too many daylilies by the roses. Spider mites and thrips love love love daylilies. So the spider mites never hopped onto the roses.

The wonderful cup thread saved my garden. Blue cups did not work for midge. I caught none on them. They where caught like crazy with the yellow cups. These are the midges that you are looking for.

I so hate to mention the yellow cup thing because they are ugly. So ugly that if you are a part of a home owners association I doubt you could use them. I used two cups per rose as I was desperate. They need two be somewhat close to the ground so the midge can be encouraged to use them as posed to your rose.

I do not know if they are attracted to the cups or blown onto them. However none where caught by my test cups in blue. I caught many in pairs of one female one male. I took the cups down in July by then I was tripping over them and they either worked or not. Lots of flowers on the roses by that time. The cups do need re-oiled if they become dry. The oil that worked the best for me was a good heavy weight motor oil. Everything else was too light and would come the cup in the wind and rain.

Other things that are helping.

Spiders, rose midge in my yard likes to bite swelling growth buds destroying new growth that would produce flower buds. Then the rose tries to grow again from a new bud which midge will once again destroy. All of this grow kill leaves a bunched up looking area of aborted growth. Used to take that off. Now I leave it on because spiders like it and they build webs down low on the bush. then when many midge fly up from the ground they can be caught in the webs.

Diversify, this is hard to do if you only have a small area or really just like a few plants. However if you only have one type of plant all they seem to draw are the bad insects. Having a variety draws the good guys as well. This is my first year ever that I did not need to squish a single rose slug. The paper wasps ate all of them. An extra plus that they are not aggressive.

I saved all my cups from last year and yes I washed all 300 cups last year to save for this year. They are not exactly environmentally friendly. Got them all up long before rose midge was active. UGLY UGLY UUUUGLY. This year when examined upon removal there were very few midge on there. What does this imply I don't know. maybe I caught most of them last year. What I did catch where about a trillion thrips. An odd observation so was I catch thrips that were present or attracting them I don't know. Either way I'm not having any thrips damage now maybe due to the high heat. I just don't know.

I totally agree midge is rose enemy number one.

That all I do, no insecticides, yellow cups, encourage spiders and diversify.

Donna if I were you with that many roses is buy landscaping material. Cut it to fit under the roses the best you can. Have it run out to the drip line of the rose. It will trap those buggers in the ground and keep any larvae from getting into the soil. Use landscaping pins to hold the fabric down. It is not a perfect solution but my guess is that it would help significantly.

I nearly gave up on roses when I first found that I had midge. Good luck everyone with what ever you do. Yes I know that very likely none of that made any sense at all. one of these days I'll remember to check where that cursor is.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (108)

kitasei
6 years ago
What are these blue cups everyone is referring to?
House Ideas
6 years ago
What are these blue cups everyone is referring to?

Part of the Solo family fortune. If you've ever been to a BBQ and had a beer out of a red solo cup - these are the same thing, but blue.

Apparently, thrips are attracted to them so if you put something sticky in the cup they get stuck there and can't get into your roses/flowers.
Related Discussions
Is my soil a disaster for roses?!
Q
Comments (18)
Generally, when you buy an organic fertilizer i.e. fish emulsion, bone meal, or whatever, you will be given a number like 5-1-1. Like kimmsr says, those numbers are what is readily available. As far as knowing exactly how much is enough and what is too much goes..... Well, the short answer is that it requires more sophisticated soil testing and then sufficient, yet not excessive, rates can be calculated based on the material being used, plant choices, and the soil chemical/physical properties. Of course, there will always be wild cards such as unexpected rain, but that goes for organic sources as well as synthetic. I'm perfectly comfortable with synthetic, but it is important to think ahead and be responsible with them. With that in mind, and the fact that you've got the manure and slow release in there already, I would scratch the 13-20-7-3 because that would be overloading with phosphate(#2 to nitrate on the list of stuff you don't want leaching into your ground water). I've found through experience that a good rule of thumb is that many plants (roses among them) will do well with approximately 1.5 lbs. of actual N pre-plant per 1000 sq. ft. with maintenance follow-ups of about 1 lb per 1000 sq. ft. applied when color and growth dictate. (The rates above are in the neighborhood of these approximate rates) Again I say 'approximate' and 'about' an awful lot because we're kind of winging it here based on a lot of un-knowns and generalities. A more expensive test could really nail it down though. Phosphorus and potassium pre-plant applications are best based on testing. However maintenance, once at sufficient levels, is generally lower than nitrogen (hence the 16-6-8 and only twice a year). As far as sulfur goes. Keep in mind that it does not easily move through the soil and will only affect the pH as deeply as it is incorporated. For this reason it should be blended with native soil as uniformly as possible to a 6 to 9 inch depth where the majority of feeder roots are. Again, this change will be slow and is only temporary. As far as a sulfur rate goes, that's really tough to say. The three main factors for calculating that rate are 1)pH 2)lime content and 3)half saturation percentage of the soil. We have a sketchy idea of one of those. Let's assume the pH of 7.5. If you were dealing with a sandy loam with a half sat. of 14 and a low lime content, you would need about 1/2 pound per 100 sq. ft. (or 5 per 1000) to get you somewhere in the range of a pH of 7 over time. If you have a clay or clay loam with a half sat. of 35 and high lime content, you're looking at about 4 times that. That's a call you'll have to make based primarily on estimated texture and the pH that you derived from the home test kit (unless you have the soil tested by a lab). More sand = less sulfur. More silt and clay = more sulfur. I'd go low to start because sulfur tends to burn roots if over-used.
...See More
My Summer with Roses (in Containers)
Q
Comments (4)
It is SO encouraging to read about your roses in containers on a balcony!!! I, too, have all my first Old Roses in containers on my balcony. They were all in bands from Vintage, three of them received in the Spring, and three more that I bought from Vintage quite recently. Because we went through a protracted move from Merced, CA to Sacramento, CA this summer, the Spring ones (which I had potted up when I got them) spent June and July in the garden of relatives here in Sacramento, but they are on my balcony now. The other three are also potted up doing OK. FIRST GROUP: Devoniensis - still with the relatives, but doing all right, not growing a lot. Mme. Antoine Mari - doing very well, in spite of my having made a few mistakes. Only a few flowers, but getting ready to give me a few more on longer, more vigorous canes. Nigrette - a small 1935 HT, doing very well, and with a lovely growth habit. NEW GROUP: These are not all Old Roses, as my sister wanted Oklahoma. Mlle. Jeanne Philippe - came with a few lovely little light yellow blooms on it (blooms should eventually be apricot). Hanging in there. Mlle. Cecile Brunner, the shrub - swinging right into action, making new branches, buds, etc. Oklahoma - also came with a bloom and bud, truly gorgeous in color, it is now apparently working on roots. I don't really have enough sun, either, but I'm going to give it a good try. So far I've been moving the pots around, trying to find the optimum sun conditions for each of them. Parts of my balcony get about five to six hours of sun, but it's afternoon sun and can be terribly hot in the summer. It was too much for little Nigrette in the last hot spell, about 3 weeks ago, and I moved her into the shade as soon as I realized it. To know that your roses have done so well in even a bit less sun has really made me feel more optimistic!! Thanks, Laura
...See More
Help! My garden is a disaster for roses and I'm a sucker for puni
Q
Comments (10)
Some posters from your area will probably come along and give you some good advice, but in the meantime, let me get you started. If you are not going spray, then you are going to have to search out the roses that are very disease-resistant. That includes roses like Knock Out--which is why it is doing fine. I haven't grown most of the roses on your list, but I have seen roses like zephirine drouhin and abraham darby on blackspot magnet lists. In other words, don't even try to grow them if you aren't going to spray. Two things you can do now. 1)Check out the thread I started tonight about "Year-end Review: What are you Blackspotters" (or something like that). You don't want to grow any of those roses. 2) Go to the search box at top or bottom of the page and type in "disease resistant" or "blackspot"--that should call up dozens of threads talking about what roses you should or shouldn't be growing. And yes, there is hope for you. Since you are already becoming obsessed with roses (like the rest of us), just continue on learning more about roses, and you too can develop a lovely garden of roses--I promise you. Kate
...See More
Summer has arrived; I guess rose season is almost done...
Q
Comments (24)
Bart, in my blog there is an article whose title is: "Calculator of shadows and other systems to know where to plant a tree that protects a plant at noon" If you want to visit, this is the link: http://eljardindelaalegriaenmadrid.blogspot.com.es/2016/11/calculadora-de-sombras-y-otros-sistemas.html In this article you will find a tool that I find very useful. It is a "shadow calculator". You put the geographical latitude to which your garden is located, the height of the adult tree, and the day and month of the date you want to calculate. It will give you how much the shadow of that tree you will imagine on the date you have entered (The shadows projecting any object in summer are much shorter than in winter). Maybe I'm not the one to explain it well using the translator. But if you visit the page you will understand what I say. It is a very valuable tool to know where exactly to locate the tree so that during the summer it projects its shadow towards the zone that you want. I think you should use as measures meters and centimeters (there are pages on the web that will translate your unit of measurement that you use meters and centimeters) I hope that helps. I also speak in this article of another design program that is free and you can download the web. It is very easy to use and is in your language. Easy to use and very useful to know how the shadows of the trees will be planted in a certain place. The program is SketchUp.
...See More
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
Could someone who has used the cups explain how they're used? What color blue- light or dark. How high from the ground etc. Any info would be appreciated.

Sharon
Vaporvac Z6-OhioRiverValley
6 years ago
Check out this link from last year: http://forums2.gardenweb.com/discussions/3816744/omg-blue-cup-thrips-control-actually-works?n=22
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
thanks so much for the link vaporvac. I'm almost positive I have midge. Ughhhh!!! i'm ready to throw in the towel. I don't get many blooms since our summers are so short and this is just another nail in the coffin between Gypsy moth caterpillars, rose slugs, aphids, and voles!!! I'm just about ready to concrete the whole yard!

Sharon
Vaporvac Z6-OhioRiverValley
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
I'm feeling you, enchanted! Very disheartening, especially as it's only my second season really growing roses and I bought so many new ones this year. My only hope is to eradicate them in the beds with plastic sheeting and maybe some selective spraying and covering the soil on the potted ones and keep them on the concrete porch where the dropped maggots can't pupate. Then maybe spray the tips selectively. Has anyone ever gotten rid of these things once they're in the garden? I considered them different to thrips which are everywhere and blow in.
Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
6 years ago
No one that I have read has ever eliminated them. Sadly they are considered a forever pest like mosquitos. Like Sharon I seem to be having many moments where I have considered blowing the whole thing up. Actually I'm not sure why I'm still gardening. I guess I'm a masochist or something. Lets see there are midge, thrips, Japanese beetles, critters that eat the roots (my kitties are older and do not hunt), cucumber beetles, plant bugs etc. and I love gardening. Seems odd sometimes. I shall try to explain my cups a bit later. Time for some soul soothing food. :-)
rosecanadian
6 years ago
Don't give up enchanted. :) Please try the cups...I mentioned them to a friend, and she says she's getting blooms and growth now.

Vaporvac - maybe once you selectively spray, then you can use the cups afterwards without having to spray?

Carol
Vaporvac Z6-OhioRiverValley
6 years ago
That's my hope, Carol. If I have time after doing the pots and ground, I may try to rig up some cups. I can't keep plastic on my beds indefinitely and hope to get the pots in the ground next year at the latest.
rosecanadian
6 years ago
Keep us posted, and good luck! :)
Carol
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
rosecanadian

:-)

I will try the cups. It just is getting a bit discouraging and overwhelming.

Sharon
rosecanadian
6 years ago
I know. You have lots of problems with pests, etc. That's so hard for an avid gardener.

Carol
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
thanks Carol. It's so nice to have a place to vent.
User
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
I feel so sorry for everyone that has to deal with rose midge!!!! I wonder if they would be attracted to the blue light on a Dynatrap. I have one in my back yard and haven't had hardly any rose slugs this year. I don't know if that is from the trap or just a coincidence. I do know I see lots of small bugs and moths in the catcher basket and they are supposed to catch Japanese beetles. I got the huge one acre trap for my yard because we get west nile virus here from mosquitoes. Not only does it trap the mosquitoes, I am seeing other benefits as well.

Rebecca
User
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
I think that would be good for rose Midges. Thanks I will look it to that myself. I saw it at the big box store.
Vaporvac Z6-OhioRiverValley
6 years ago
Does anyone know the exact range of midge? I read varying distances and don't know which is true.
jim1961 / Central Pennsylvania / Zone 6
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
Hang in there everyone! Got the fight going on myself this year with Rose Midge & thrips...

Eye of the Tiger!
Kristine LeGault 8a pnw
6 years ago
Holy moly, just when everything is looking good, the weather reports that the temperatures this week will be as high as 114. Geeze, I live in the PNW not Death Valley, although my plants aren't so sure.

Good grief
rosecanadian
6 years ago
114!!!! Oh my horrors!! Ii can't imagine.
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
Vaporvac- I noticed your comment on the ornamental tobacco and wondered if interplanting them would help since I read that prior to pesticides they would put tobacco leaves down to kill the rose midges.

Kristine-114!!! I can't even imagine temps that high. Yikes!!! We have had relatively cool weather here, more like the summers when I was a kid but lots of rain. Even my Kordes have disease this year.

Rebecca- I think I'll look into the Dynatrap too. We have millions of mosquitoes here since we're surrounded by swamp and live in a very rural area. We used to have bats but they moved on. They were living under the siding on our house but we still had mosquitoes. I told them since I was graciously offering them the shelter of my home the least they could do was pull their weight and keep my yard mosquito free ;-) so they left. We went to a friends house yesterday who lives in the city and sat out in his yard till dark. Not one mosquito!! It was heavenly.

Patti- what do you interplant with? I'm trying to keep my garden from becoming a tangled mess. I just ripped out tons of weeds, a million wild violets that have taken over my yard and any ornamentals that got too aggressive. I do have forget-me-nots which I pull once they stop blooming, daylilies, lilies, hostas, geraniums, astilbes, alliums, sage, daisies and veronicas plus various Hydrangea to try to attract insects throughout the season. We do have a healthy population of toads, frogs, spiders, snakes and wasps plus unfortunately grasshoppers, ugh, JB's, some new tan beetle that now eats my roses, red lily beetles, thrips, midges and aphids!! So ALL the bugs are loving my garden!

I also have voles that eat the roses in the winter. I've been replanting my younger roses in nursery pots with 1/2inch holes drilled in the sides for the roots to grow through, the bottom taken out and the pot then surrounded by a moat of seashells plus a layer of shells on top underneath the mulch which I'll be removing in the fall. They event my potted roses that were wintered over last year. I'm also going to sprinkle the ground with peppermint scented wax pellets used for aroma therapy in late fall to act as a deterrent. Hopefully this will work since I'm out of ideas. We used to feed the birds but this attracts voles which chew the electrical wires in our cars and build nests in them. They cause so much damage. So hence we don't have a lot of birds like we used to. I'm thinking of starting to feed the birds again though if I can figure out a way to keep the seed droppage to a minimum. It truly is a never ending battle!!

Sharon
rosecanadian
6 years ago
Sharon - sheesh...all I have to worry about are winds and hail. We don't even get mosquitoes. Did you put up a bat house?? That might lure the bats back. Good luck gardening!

Carol
Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
6 years ago
Sharon, I fear the day that voles may arrive. We used to have many active kitties and a large family of fox. The kitties are old and the fox came down with a disease that wiped them out. I saw my first mole ever last year. The rodents are getting thick here for the first time ever. I can go out now to find chipmunks scurrying away.

As far as plants go I'm sorry to say I have all of those that you have and add phlox to the mix. My neighbors has spices planted outside. There is a ravine with many varieties of weeds and wild flowers in the back. Or at least there was until someone introduced 5 horribly invasive plants loose down there. But that is another story.

I'm not sure about doing the nematodes as I'm having a very hard time locating a reliable source for them. May I add that I'm beyond sick of the yellow cup thing. Yet to date it is the only thing that works and works very well. I just have to many roses. If I only had say twenty or so roses the cups would be a cake walk. Added benefit of catching thrips the cups were covered from top to bottom with them.

As far as I'm aware no one really knows how far they travel. If I had to hazard a guess they are probably using mosquito estimates.
jim1961 / Central Pennsylvania / Zone 6
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
I'm ready to build a large bubble around our house & property... lol...

Last 3 years we hardly had any trouble with insects and years prior we mainly had trouble with just roses slugs which after this year of dealing with thrips & rose midge I've learned to appreciate the rose slugs...lol..And I'd gladly take the rose slugs back if all the others bad insects would just leave..lol

For years the railroad & paper mill kept this area across our street clean of all weeds etc... Which spraying all that weed poison year after year did not thrill me...BUT the last 2-3 years they been letting it grow like a jungle. Bad insects seem to plague us now...
Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
6 years ago
How I do my cups is different than everyone else's. It was born from desperation since I could not afford too do it their way. A pictorial will explain this better than words. I'll attempt that later. A side note here is that rose midge are very tiny nearly microscopic in size. There have been a few photos lately that are not midge but I don't have the heart to say it. Well I should but haven't.

This is the enemy and as you can see the image is blown up so that we are able to see them. It may be possible to make your own sticky cards using painted index cards with a hole punched in them. Then purchase the sticky stuff to roll on them and string them up. I just have not check to see how cost effective it is. The remade ones cost way to much for me.

Tools needed for cup traps.

Yellow cups - The only place I could find these were at Big Lots

ice pick - or something to punch two holes in bottom of the cups. Do one down thru the bottom and one up from the inside of the cups. It makes passing the string threw so much easier.

String - I use one that comes in a ball from Walmart made of hemp I believe. It is strong and holds up well to the weather and fairly inexpensive.

Something to hang them on. I already had wires from when I purchased plant labels from the Everlast Label Company. The shorter zinc wire works just fine. I straighten them. Then with a wrench I twist one end into a closed circle bend the circle down a bit to hang the cup. I use a good thick motor oil as it stays sticky longer than the canola oil. Have not tried mustard seed oil. The cups will hang down by the ground. This is good midge have a tendency to go for the first thing they find.

Another pain I go thru is washing the cups at end of the year. Plastic is so environmentally unfriendly. Plus who knows how hard it may be to find yellow again

Then store the mess till next year.
Dingo2001 - Z5 Chicagoland
6 years ago
I've been really lucky this year, fewer pests all the way around, I hardly even had all that much rose slug damage. The JB are here, but don't seem as bad as last year. The only thing I can think of that's different is the Cleome that self seeded all over. And I have a ton of birds coming, as well as dragon flys and the little red wasps. I do have bird feeders out - I keep the nyjer socks out for finches year round, and the other birds get the "no waste" mix that doesn't really grow anything if it's spilled. The doves come for clean up duty on the ground, I don't have issues with voles or shrews or anything, maybe the dogs keep them away. I've seen the finches land on different plants and pick bugs off for snacks. I know I have some thrip damage, but I just live with it. There has been some midge around, I've picked off some burnt / wilted tips, but less than last year. Do the birds eat the midge larvae? I see them digging around in the mulch in my beds. We've had a lot of rain too, maybe that has helped as well.
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
jim- can you send me the bubble blueprints when you do..lol I might just try THAT route!

Patti- thank heavens for the small blessing that you don't have voles. We border on about 500 acres of woods so most of the foxes, deer, coyotes and such stay in the woods. Since we don't have a lawn we don't ever get rabbits either. We had a possum living under our porch once. When we fed our cats he would come out and eat with them. We haven't had outdoor cats in years since they either get hit by cars or eaten by fisher cats. Talk about vile creatures. These are as vicious as badgers and just so creepy. Their cry sounds like someone is murdering a child or the witches' Sabbath. So eerie. Our neighbor who is a state cop actually went out investigating one at midnight thinking someone was being beaten or murdered. They actually believed that they're responsible for the decline in the bobcat population in Maine. So, sadly, no outdoor kitties to go after the various varmints. We have chipmunks but they don't do the damage that the voles do. They mainly empty my bird feeder and bury all the sunflower seeds in one spot then stand there "scratching their heads" when they go back to the stash and find a bunch of sunflower seedlings instead. Definitely not the sharpest tool in the shed!! I'm glad the yellow cups are working for you even though they're unsightly and such a pain. I ordered the sticky yellow tags from Amazon and am supposed to get them tomorrow. Hoping that they'll help. I'm trying to think of something that could be more decorative like a yellow pinwheel that would look more like garden decor. I'm crafty so I might be able to think of something. Maybe I could even make little flower fairies where their skirt is the cup. I'll have to put my thinking cap on ;-)

Carol- thank you for your kind words. It is a battle but your beautiful garden looks like so much more effort. I can't imagine packing up that many roses for the winter. We have looked at bat houses and I'm thinking of getting Mason bees, bumble bees and leaf cutter bees. We have no honey bees here even though our neighbor about 1/4 mile away has hives. I guess they don't like the offerings in my garden.

Sharon
Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
6 years ago
Geez I'm only about 70 mi. from you Julie and I'm living in bad bug heaven here. Another thought do they by any chance spray for mosquitos because of west nile virus. I do have lots of predators here. I'd be happy to try cleome. When I think of it there is probably some ridiculously easy answer to most problems. We just don't know what they are.
Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
6 years ago
Oh my lord I could not deal with fisher cats so horrible .Sharon I'm counting on you for a better looking answer to the cups. Please share what you come with.

Jim be sure to send those blue prints this way as well. I shall be eternally greatful.
jim1961 / Central Pennsylvania / Zone 6
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
Patty W. zone 5a Illinois wrote:

"When I think of it there is probably some ridiculously easy answer to most problems. We just don't know what they are."

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you want a blue print copy of my bubble plans too? lol

oh I see you do...lol
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
patti- what does Cleome do?

I also found some yellow and blue pinwheels. The Prospect Park Rose Garden in NYC has a 7000 yellow pinwheel display!

This would add some whimsey to the garden. Oriental Trading has blue and yellow ones for $10/36 pieces. I just ordered some yellow and blue ones. I'll let everyone know how it works.
Dingo2001 - Z5 Chicagoland
6 years ago
Patty they have sprayed a couple times for mosquitos but I don't know what they've used. They have sprayed in other years too. It just seems like I have more bugs in general. Do you think the mosquito spray keeps the midges and things down? I wouldn't mind being under Jim's bubble for sure! If anyone wants Cleome seeds let me know lol, I just pulled a bunch out today they are all over!

Julie
totoro z7b Md
6 years ago
Ooh, i like the aesthetics of pin wheels instead of cups. Enchanted, do share your results. i hope it works for you. I read that they can scare away deer and birds. I don't have deer, but I am trying to attract birds.

I fed the birds safflower seeds last year hoping they would eat bugs. I did not feed them this summer and I wonder if that is why I have midge this year. Who knows!

I finally put up my blue cups yesterday and I caught a bunch of tiny bugs on them. I have no idea what they are. Canola oil is pretty thin.
rosecanadian
6 years ago
Crap. Everything I wrote just vanished. :( I`m not going to rewrite it...so everyone imagine that I wrote pithy or encouraging words about everything you wrote. :)

Carol
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
totoro- :-)

I don't know how much the pinwheels will scare the birds. We are very sheltered here and don't get much wind. We don't have many birds since I stopped feeding them. We also fed them year round and always had chickadees, tufted titmouse and cardinals. I'm trying to think of a feeder that would keep the seed from dropping to the ground. I found a birdbath/ feeder which might work.

It would be a pain to keep clean though but at least the voles wouldn't be able to get at the food. It might keep squirrels away too.

Good luck with your blue cups. I'll keep everyone posted once these come in.

Sharon
Donna Roesink Zone 6a Ohio
Original Author
6 years ago
That is interesting about the pinwheels. I might try some of those. My blue surgical gloves are on stakes and are about 3' off the ground. Maybe that is too high. Also, how late into the season are thrips and midges active?
rosecanadian
6 years ago
Donna - that's a good question.

Sharon- where would the seeds go - the top little bowl?

Carol
Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
6 years ago
Julie

I'm just guessing of course but I'll bet what they have sprayed for mosquitos has knocked down your midge numbers. I would rather believe that the cleome plants brought in a predator that is helping with midge. Does anyone know if there is a short variety available.

Donna

I believe midge tend to increase during the season as each generation lays more eggs. I'm sure that environmental events influence their numbers. Wether that is a drought, floods, a predator or another I don't know the answer to that. Midge is caught closer to the ground or they will just head straight to the rose foliage. Thrips can be caught high or low. At least I know that low to the ground works because I catch them like crazy.

Sharon

I love those pinwheels they are so cute. Especially considering how ugly the cups are.

Unfortunately for here I think the cups might work better. The first year I did a better job with the cups than this year. That first year I had 2 to 3 cups per rose. I placed them so that the winds would blow thru the rose onto the cups according to the way spring winds tend to blow here. I was so desperate to catch these guys I even when out for a time and moved cups around according to the breeze. Midge are smaller than mosquitos and mosquitos have a hard time flying in a good breeze. That first year I caught so many midge and thrips it was unreal. This year thrips outnumbered everything caught.
Donna Roesink Zone 6a Ohio thanked Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
jim1961 / Central Pennsylvania / Zone 6
6 years ago
You using yellow or blue cups Patty??? I have blue cups here but I should buy some yellow cups and place close to ground to see what happens...
Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
6 years ago
I only use the yellow ones Jim. My blue ones last year did not catch any midge.
jim1961 / Central Pennsylvania / Zone 6
6 years ago
Ok thanks Patty!
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
Carol- the seeds go in the top, the middle is the bird bath basin and the bottom is a planter. I ordered two of these so i can see how it works out.

Patti- You have far more roses than I do. I'll see how the pinwheels work since it was relatively inexpensive. they might not work at all but if they do they definitely are prettier than cups. Your perseverance is truly admirable and it's great that you don't resort to chemicals which are so toxic to the earthen all the little critters we share it with.

Sharon
rosecanadian
6 years ago
Enchantedrose - that sounds awesome! What a clever idea! Show us pictures of it in your yard - hopefully with birds! I can't wait to see it!

Carol
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
Carol- I will. I just need to decide the best place for it. I have so many garden ornaments it's hard to find room to squeeze the plants in! I can't guarantee the birds though. Once we stop feeding them it takes a while to find our yard again. Hoping this will keep the voles from getting the seed and it might even keep the squirrels out too if they're afraid of the water. They can empty a bird feeder in the blink of an eye! I should see if there's a way to put bubbler in theses so we don't get mosquitoes.

Sharon
rosecanadian
6 years ago
Bubblers, that's a good idea! Although then the birds won't bathe in it.

Carol
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
hmm... I'll have to think on this. We get sooo many mosquitoes in any standing water.

Sharon
rosecanadian
6 years ago
I don't know...maybe the birds WILL bathe in it. :) I've never had birds in any standing/bubbling water...so I have no clue. :) Or you can do what I do...spray the water out, and then add more.

Carol
Vaporvac Z6-OhioRiverValley
6 years ago
I have to clean my BB daily, so no mosquitoes. It's always filled with feathers. I really have to research how to clean it to keep stuff growing in it. It's totally stained, but mine's concrete.
Donna Roesink Zone 6a Ohio
Original Author
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
enchantedrosez5bma, have your yellow pinwheels caught very many thrips and midge? I am thinking or ordering some from Oriental Trading. I assume that rose midge season is still going to last for a while. I treated my roses with the Bayer 2 in 1 product a little over a week ago. I am still seeing midge damage to bushes that have been treated. I guess it takes some time before the bushes are completely protected. (don't know) Bushes still aren't putting on much new growth.
enchantedrosez5bma
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
Donna- I haven't caught much of anything but I think the oil might be too thin or that I don't have that much rose midge yet. I'm going to try coating them with vaseline instead. I don't think too many insects could escape that sticky mess. They do look pretty though :-)

I'm trying vaporvacs method with the plastic bags and thinking of spraying or coating this too with oil, not vaseline, (that would take forever!) so if any larvae land on the plastic they won't be able to wiggle their way to the edge and into the soil. Just slowly pecking away at it between the rain, the heat and the curve-balls life throws at you. Hopefully I'll be done before winter!

Carol- I do rinse my bird baths once in a while. I did see some goldfinches in my triple fountain once and that has a bubbler at the top.

Sharon
Donna Roesink Zone 6a Ohio thanked enchantedrosez5bma
rosecanadian
6 years ago
Sharon - so a bubbler doesn't make any difference. That's great to know! Kind of like a jetted tub!

Carol