Need help on deciding residential heating

7 years ago

last modified: 7 years ago

Purchased a home (approx. 2200 sq. ft.) in New England that we’re (husband and I hired GC) are in the process of renovating. The house was built in 1950 with an addition in 1972. The heating is a mix of oil fired hot water convectors and baseboards in the old/newer part of the home with a total of 4 zones. High velocity AC (Unico) was added in 2012. Our original contractor removed the original faces of all of the convector units, discarded them, and subsequently walked off the job. We just found a new, reputable GC.

Now we are left with deciding whether to convert convector units to baseboard heat (total of 7 units) and keep the 4 zones powered by the boiler, or remove all baseboards and retrofit the air handler for the AC unit in the attic with a hot water coil to handle heat, also powered by the boiler in the basement. However, this would effectively put us on a 1-zone heat system. A couple of notes to consider:

1. One baseboard is located under a window that we’d eventually like to convert to sliding doors to a future deck, so regardless we’d likely consider moving this baseboard to another exterior wall
2. We’re not sure if a boiler pushing 1 hot water pipe to the attic is more efficient than generating hot water for baseboards located throughout the home. Does anyone know which would be more expensive to operate?
3. If heat coming from the ceiling is inefficient. One HVAC subcontractor mentioned that 1 zone could make the 1st floor cold while another thinks the high velocity nature of the system would push heat effectively to the 1st floor. For the basement, half of it would be heated while the other half would not.
4. If we kept baseboards we’d have to reroute some heating pipes as some of them are running along the exterior wall, and also some of the baseboards were damaged during demo.
5. Some hot water pipes for baseboards run into an unheated crawlspace beneath the addition, and they have some type of foam insulation on them.

Any thoughts/suggestions/opinions would be much appreciated. I'm happy to provide more information if you need it. Also the house is currently gutted so we wouldn't need to rip out walls to remove old hot water pipes if we went to forced air.

Sort by:Oldest

Comment (1)

ionized_gw
7 years ago
It may be very difficult to make home comfortable with a single zone. It depends on how different the relative heat requirement change with time of day, sun-derived radiant heat and season. Lots of hydronic heating systems were chopped up into zones in an attempt to limit fuel use when oil prices spiked. Now, some are being recombined into fewer zones make them run better with modulating, condensing boilers. The gain from zoning can be marginal anyway with poorly-insulated homes.

I have some comments that speak to efficiency and the type of delivery device. Fin-tube aluminum convectors need higher temperature water than radiators. Hydronic coils sometimes use even higher temp water. (The hotter the water, the smaller the coil.) With condensing boilers you need low temperature return water to use the boiler in any way efficiently. The differing delivery devices can be combined to get good efficiency, but you need to find someone that knows what they are doing. With a complete gut you must be greatly upgrading insulation and air sealing. You need less emitter to heat with now and a smaller boiler. If you keep the emitters on the high side, however, you can run with lower water temp and preserve the efficiency of the boiler. A lot of engineering goes into the designs.

Enclose the pipes in the crawlspace in a way that couples them to the living space above and insulate the outside of them while removing the insulation between the pipes and the space above. Insulation around the pipes themselves is OK.

This is a great forum, but there are not a lot of hydronic heat/boiler heads posting here. There are more at terrylove.com and at heatinghelp.com, "the wall".
laurasteiger thanked ionized_gw
Related Discussions
Confused! Pls. read and help us decide- Trane a/c or heat pump??
Q
Comments (8)
We live 20 miles south of Houston. Our home is 45 years old, Brick with 2,345 square feet living area. We are all electric, no gas on the property. Our A/C is a 4 ton with electric heat strips that was installed in 1992. We have done everything the utility company recommends to make out home energy efficient. We still get over $800 electric bills. I have a bid from Trane dealer. (Home Depot) The salesman said our current A/C was a 10 SEER when installed and loses 4% per year. So using his figures I a running at about a 4 SEER. He proposes to install either a TRANE XL14i for $8,123.45 or an XL16i for $9,775.00. Also an air handler to match with 20 kWh of heat strips. All the above is with the ten year parts and labor extended warranty from Trane. They also want to service the new unit twice a year for $149 per year. We are currently paying .155 per kWh. Two questings. How much can I realistically expect to save on my electric bill with either of these two units and is the price reasonable.
...See More
Need help deciding which heat pump is the best
Q
Comments (8)
Your right..I checked my bid and the ruud is a 80% 2 stage variable speed blower furnace. With "N" style coil. Humidifier New touch screen thermostat, out door pad, whip, disconnect box. 8,222 As for the xr15...here is what was at the bottom of my bid sheet....Install..XR15, model #4TWR5042 for an additional $900.00*Not necessarily the best decision because the rating is still only 14.0 seer. So, could I replace the heat pump and not the furnace? I think I get caught up in the sales hype. The "N" coil and humidifier sounded good at the time. Also, the salesman said lenox does not match up with anything else so will the furnace work with the trane? Also..I don't think I will get the tax credit with the trane but at a price difference of 4600 it wouldn't matter. Thanks for giving me advice, Dawn
...See More
Need help deciding on a heat pump
Q
Comments (15)
I still have not made a decision, I am leaning towards the Lennox or Rheem, however Trane rep. called today and lowered his price by $200 I asked about his 2 ton unit when everyone else is quoting 3 ton and he told me that when he did his heat load calcs. that we came up 22,000 and a 2 ton can handle 24,000 so a 2 ton is what is needed, he said if we were not happy with the unit after install. then he would put in a larger unit until we were satisfied, of course I would make them put that in writing. So what are your thoughts? I have a few concerns, first his heat strips are not staged, he does not have tin plated coils, he said there units are made of the same metal so they do not have different metals rubbing and they only have 6-12 welds vs. other systems with 10 times that amount? 4TWR4024A1000A XR14 split heat pump 2 ton 4TEE3F31A1000A variable speed air tite air handler TCONT803A 3H/2C 7 day prog. auto changeover touch screen TAYREFLN230 Brazed insulated lineset BAYHTR1410BRKA Matched backup supplemental hear strips install new thermostat wire condensate drain condenser pad 4"riser for heat pump remove replace coil and outdoor until level 1 with furnace 10 year parts and labor warranty $7342.00 Also Lennox is offering a $500 rebate on this unit. XP19-036 3 ton 18.6 SEER/12.7EER/9.3 HSPF CBX40UHV-048 air handler with ECM motor $7321.00 without rebate only 10 yr parts 1 yr. labor warranty Thank you so much for your help!!!
...See More
I'm confused now! Please help me to decide before my heat dies!!!
Q
Comments (4)
April, You keep starting new threads so it is difficult to review what advice you have received. Contractor #1 Option 2 is the nicest combination in my opinion. It is a Infinity 2 stage furnace (58UVB)and 2 stage condenser (24APA7). You could consider upgrading the furnace to the 58MVC for about $400 in order to get the middle stage. I still think the 58UVB qualifies for a Carrier rebate. Please check this. I have not heard of a Carrier armour coil. I know the tin plated coil is an improvement of Carrier's old leaky coils. This is the coil I have. The contractor needs to size the equipment by doing a heat loss and gain calculation. This is known in the industry as a Manual J calculation. Have each contractor explain how he calculated the size. I assume the summers in Michigan are not too hot, so the 3 ton unit may be the correct size.
...See More

Need help on deciding residential heating

Comment (1)

ionized_gw

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US