Retail markup for carpet

7 years ago

last modified: 7 years ago

I am bartering services with a carpet store. They are supposed to sell me the materials (carpet, pad and whatever else is needed) at their cost and provide the installation for free.

They told me what the regular price is for materials and labor then they deducted 40% from the total, this is what they say their cost-installation is. I don't feel like they are being forthright. I don't know about carpet but for most retail products there is a 50% markup or more. So I feel like I should be getting 50% off the materials plus an additional discount for the installation. They way the presented it their markup on materials is less than 40% since the installation is part of the 40%.

I'm hoping someone who is familiar with the carpet industry can tell me if they think this store is being honest. The thing I am giving them in exchange has a value greater than what I am receiving (this doesn't usually happen but long story) so if they are even breaking even on the job I am being cheated. They should break even on materials and come out of pocket on the installation.

Any advice please? If this is sensitive information that you don't want to post for the public to see please private message me.

TIA

Featured Answer

User

7 years ago

last modified: 7 years ago

40% would be a high margin on carpet. 20-30% is more the standard. There is zero money in carpet anymore since hard surfaces took over. Most stores sell it as a one stop shop convenience factor for those also purchasing hard flooring.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

PRO
Carpet One Columbia
7 years ago
The best way to verify the material cost is for the dealer to present you with the invoice or price list they receive from the manufacturer/distributor. This would prove the value of the trade and help you feel more at ease. They should be willing to deal with an open hand, especially if the value of your service exceeds the value of theirs.
Related Discussions
Retail pricing on grafted conifers
Q
Comments (8)
Bob Fincham has a great article regarding this on his website. I've attached a link at the bottom. Basically the price is generated by several factors including how hard it is for the cultivar type to propogate, how quickly/slowly they grow(longer time at the nursery will inevitably cost more money), how rare they are(rare things are fundamentally more coveted, and thus more expensive)as well as several factors related to the nursery owner's expenses and labor finding, caring, repotting, watering, etc of these plants. I think the biggest hurdle for me was surpassed when I realized I might go to a sh(tty movie or a ballgame and pay $20-30 - so why can't I spend $20-30 on a plant that will beautify my surroundings for years, likely increase the potential home resale value and give me so much pleasure over the years? Even for someone on a tight budget, an order of a half dozen cultivar conifers or other 'high value' landscape plants once or twice a year should be within reach. If you're 'collecting' plants, a consistent, over-time approach is probably your best bet to stay out of the poor house. Me, I decided to drive a beater, econo-car an extra couple years to begin a conifer/Japanese maple collection rather then buying a new one. :) -Will
...See More
GE Profile: is sensor worth the markup)?
Q
Comments (3)
Whether the sensor feature is justified depends on your microwave usage habits. Do you cook with it frequently, or mostly boil water and reheat? My GE OTR unit has sensor functions. I usually *don't* run sensor reheat for dinner plates as it tends to overheat ... but I do use it for baked potatoes, frozen veggies and a few other instances. The fish setting undercooks. Pasta reheat is wayyyy overdone. The rice setting works nicely. I wish it used the sensor for bacon (it has presets for bacon but by slice/time, not sensing). One of my previous units was a Panasonic that used the sensor for bacon, worked very well.
...See More
markup for furniture
Q
Comments (1)
For some high end brands (Henkel Harris, Stickley), you wonÂt get more than 45% off, even for floor samples. 35-40% off is typical. ThatÂs because the manufacturers have a minimum retail price in place, and nobody is allowed to sale less than that. Manufacturers only authorized additional 5% off once or twice a year. If you really love their stuff, that is the time to buy. Less-known brands discount more aggressively, some time even 60-70% off MSRP.
...See More
Do all GC charge 25% markup on material and some labor?
Q
Comments (10)
Supplies does not equal materials in my ledger book. Supplies are the disposable and used-up goods that are necessary for a project but do not generally stay in the structure. Tape, rosin paper to protect floors, temporary walls& doors, plastic sheeting, blades of any kind, solvents, cleaning products, towels, bits, etc. It's a myriad of stuff that costs the contractor but is not reimbursed. That's why we need to make a profit somewhere besides on our hours. That said, 25% on materials is high, unless he is taking on the risk of many unknowns. Like having something made for you overseas and taking the heat if it arrives broken, if it arrives mis-measured due to a language barrier, etc. If you had ordered it yourself and cut out the contractor, you'd have to fix it yourself, at your own expense. The add-on fee gives you some insurance that he will back up the stuff he is sourcing for you. The stories I could tell. Homeowner provides "X", GC's crew shows up to install "X". It is wrong, does not fit, etc. Who pays the men for showing up and having nothing to do, finds them work for the rest of the day? etc. In this situation the CG is getting squeezed. How many times can this happen on a job before the profit is all gone? Casey
...See More
weedyacres
7 years ago
A couple other ideas to verify if you can't ask them directly (which I would have no problem asking them to show an invoice as Carpet One suggests).

Go to another flooring store and ask them to price carpet only (say you're doing the install yourself). You need to pick a product similar to the one your barter partner is providing. Compare this to the barter partner's claimed cost.

Ask the other flooring store what their installation price per square foot is. Compare this to the price that your barter partner subtracted.

Big box stores will give you a breakdown on materials and labor, so they'd be a good go-to alternative.
uscpsycho
Original Author
7 years ago
It just occurred to me that Carpet One Columbia might be able to help me out here since it's a Carpet One store in Los Angeles that I'm working with.

Would you be willing to privately share your cost with me on this one product?
User
7 years ago
Cost for the same exact product will vary widely across the US due to transportation costs from the mill, COL, and volume buying power for larger selling stores. A carpet store close to the GA mills who is a major seller will pay half what someone all the way across the country that only sells carpet a couple of times a month. It will be a red apples to green apples comparison, even if they come from the same tree. Then there is the labor variance, which can be more than double in cost difference.
PRO
Carpet One Columbia
7 years ago
My cost would have no correlation to their cost. Ask them to give you a copy of the invoice or price list from the manufacturer or distributor. It is really okay to ask for it and I have no doubt they would provide that to you. That is the only way to know.
Torrey B
6 years ago
For future reference most retail items don't have a generic 50% markup. The markup a retailer charges will vary due to a great number of factors.
James Foulk
2 years ago
Theres a big marke up on flooring carpet especially.. and ive been done floors for about 28 years ..theres never free installation.. and it has everything to do with mark up the carpet and pad that tou have to select from are t.op grade ..they raise the price and give you a discount.. technically would they just did is have you by their high-end carpet at its regular price..

Next flooring project that comes up..give me a call ill take care of ya .. .i handle the sales and installation progress of the projet cutting out the middle man .. and im not a greedy corperation.. .. its simple.. i sell my materials at my cost .. that in return lands me the contract (usaly). .. then i make the labor.. and to be honest with ya thats usaly the greater bill out of the 2 .

Addictive Creations Flooring llc

717.979.8816

James Foulk Jr

Retail markup for carpet

User

Comments (8)

Carpet One Columbia

Related Discussions

weedyacres

uscpsycho
Original Author

User

Carpet One Columbia

Torrey B

James Foulk

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Retail markup for carpet

User

Comments (8)

Carpet One Columbia

Related Discussions

weedyacres

uscpsychoOriginal Author

User

Carpet One Columbia

Torrey B

James Foulk

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

uscpsycho
Original Author