A Busy Winter Ahead

7 years ago

After two years of agonising over whether to remove 3 established roses that are badly infected with die-back, I've finally decided to remove them. The decision has been made harder because they still flower pretty well.

This photo only shows Crepescule, which is in the middle of the three. On the far side is a Ms Tillier, and in front is Comtesse du Cayla. There are other reasons I want to remove them too.

Ms Tillier has small blooms in Summer, which I put down to him being short of water, as all three are on the edge of a north facing raised terrace, which bakes in the Summer heat. I had another in a different spot which didn't have small blooms at any time. Also his thorns are more that I want to deal with these days.

Crepescule isn't growing strongly enough to have much bronze new growth, which gave a lovely tapestry effect, and the blooms are not a particularly attractive colour except in Winter and Early Spring. The rest of the time they're somewhat mustard, with poor form.

Comtesse du Cayla is 'a crispy critter' as Adam Harbeck put it! She burns almost as soon as she opens. Another rose whose name I forget is near her, and will also be coming out.

I've ordered their replacements today: Anna Olivier, Mlle Francisca Kruger (or what's sold as MFK) and Lady Hillingdon. All of which I'll plant further in from the edge of the terrace. LH will be next to an established Mutabilis, which I think will look ok. I have another Anna Olivier and she seems to cope better with the heat than most, and LH is an old Sydney stalwart. MFK is new to me, but I think will blend in, and hopefully do well.

I've also ordered Mrs B. R. Cant for a spot under the Jacaranda where a large Dichroa appears to be dying. A couple of people on HMF have rated her as excellent in shade, and I've been wanting to find a spot for her for a long time.

So come the beginning of Winter (June here), I'll be in destruction mode. I know the die-back will be in the soil, but I'm not removing it, as presumably it will be through the whole bed, and that's just too much work!!!!!!!.

Does anyone have any suggestions as to how I might minimize the risk?

Trish

Featured Answer

portlandmysteryrose

7 years ago

Titian, if you have rose replant concerns, maybe Marlorena can speak to the problem. I believe she's mentioned it.

If the dieback you refer to is similar to what we struggle with here in the PNW, perhaps you have verticillium wilt? It shows up in our soil and causes shrinking foliage and blooms and then branch dieback. I've seen it take down mature trees in time. Lilacs, roses and many other shrubs plus a variety of perennials and annuals are susceptible. The monumental task of complete soil removal can help if a manageable bed space is the target. (I don't blame you for sidestepping that laborious course of action!) Otherwise, it's recommended that replacement plants are resistant species.

However, I have had some success with digging a large hole, removing the old soil and bagging it for disposal, sterilizing my shovel, filling the hole with clean soil and planting a healthy susceptible shrub with undamaged roots since the wilt enters the roots and spreads upward. I'd keep your roses well watered and the ground cleared of debris where the fungus can multiply. I've also read that in warm regions you can put down black plastic for a month or two prior to planting and essentially bake the fungus to death. Like you, I'm not keen on removing soil from large expanses of garden, so one or both of those shortcut approaches would be my preferred method(s).

In my experience, roses can survive incredible challenges, even formerly wilt infected beds. Your new teas are lovely choices, and I wish them well! Mrs. BR Cant is a classic and I'd grow her, too, if I lived in your climate. From across the Pacific, I'm cheering you on with your winter chores! Carol

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

nanadollZ7 SWIdaho
7 years ago
Trish, I thought your dieback problem was due to lack of water during a drought. I've never heard of dieback being in the soil. Are you referring to rose replant disease? Whatever that is, we don't have it here, thankfully. I don't envy you having to remove large plants. I know I'm kicking The Prince out of my garden. I'm going to see if I can get an Astrid Grafin von Hardenberg grown from oldrosarian's budword that she donated to Palatine in Canada. I wish I had suggestions about the dieback problem. I'm not even vaguely familiar with it. Watch your back! Diane
titian1 10b Sydney thanked nanadollZ7 SWIdaho
titian1 10b Sydney
Original Author
7 years ago
Diane, ha! The die-back was probably due to lack of water, but I thought, as it is a fungus, it would be all around? I hope you get your A G v H - she looks a beauty. Trish
Related Discussions
No Snow This Winter, repair Business Dead
Q
Comments (26)
Walt: You may be right may have to have the Finn's or Russians Bring some over with a Few Gallon's of Vodka . Vancouver has fickle weather at best , being so close to the coast moderate temps prevail lol . Rusty: Saw a article last week where animal activist's were trying to prevent the Groundhog Show , stating it was inhumane having him all penned up all the camera exposure etc. lol . Heck the animal is getting better treatment then some humans . CG: Next your going to be informing us that your breaking out your swim suit lol . Sophie: Wow , Sounds worse than what we have experienced , being North West of Superior we also get the Lake effect which can dump the White stuff even during extreme colder weather. Our saying is very similar to yours "Ifin you don't like the weather wait a few minutes it's going to change" ! lol. P.S. You all have a Great Weekend ...Ty :)
...See More
Trying to think ahead - Winter chores
Q
Comments (6)
gpacker, I looked at the link above but can not open the bubbler construction or the source file for the bubbler. On the deicer construction, did you use a terra cotta pot to put the light bulb in; pvc for the square holder (or did you use a "noodle")? For the bubbler, can you tell me what materials you used? Thanks - they both look easy to make and efficient.
...See More
Planning Ahead (Seeds To Choose For Winter Solstice)
Q
Comments (4)
The balloon flower is a must, I spring sowed that this year and it is in full bloom now and I am in love with that little plant. I also spring sowed the false indigo, I just love the blooms on that and the foliage is so pretty and neat looking even while the plant stops blooming. The black eyed susans are very carefree, and very long bloomers, the bad part is that they freely reseed themselves. Though must people love that. I am anal so if I didn't put it there I don't want it there, LOL.
...See More
Busy Day Ahead Again
Q
Comments (7)
DH left early this morning to do some painting for a friend so I thought, here's my chance to get a lot accomplished...Well so far, made the bed and fed the cats...It's such a nice day here in SW. Pa., I'm having a hard time staying inside...But I do want to do windows and blinds and put up new sheers in the living room, work on a Tshirt quilt, bake something and then maybe tonight take in a movie with a friend..... Hope everyone is enjoying their day....
...See More
comtessedelacouche (10b S.Australia: hotdryMedclimate)
7 years ago
Isn't what we call die-back (in roses, anyway) what Americans call canker?
titian1 10b Sydney thanked comtessedelacouche (10b S.Australia: hotdryMedclimate)
titian1 10b Sydney
Original Author
7 years ago
Comtesse, you're right. I can't remember the proper name of canker I came to the conclusion it was - the common name is brand canker.

Carol, thanks for your input, and your cheering on! I need it! I've not heard of verticillium wilt, but will look it up and see if there are any parallels. The black plastic idea sounds good. Replacing the soil is extra hard in this case as the new soil would need to be carried down 60 or more steps, and the old soil would need to be carried down another 35, to be dumped at the bottom of the garden.

Thanks again,

Trish
ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9
7 years ago
I wish you the best of luck, Trish. Not a fun job, but if you're not happy with the roses you have or their performance, if you're anything like me it will forever bother you. I didn't have great luck with MFK but it wasn't in the best spot, and the flowers are very pretty.

I'm worried about my Le Vesuve specimens, who are losing their full appearance due to increasing dead branches underneath. They get plenty of water and mulch, so I don't know what their major problem is. Getting to all that dead stuff underneath is best left to those who have a death wish.
titian1 10b Sydney thanked ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9
titian1 10b Sydney
Original Author
7 years ago
Ingrid, I suspect I'm very like you - it will forever bother me! Another reason I have been putting it off, is that that bed will of course look very bare for a couple of years. And I have onion weed galore here, and I will unfortunately spread it like mad when I dig. Impossible to capture all those tiny bulblets!

I had a feeling I'd read on here that MFK was not a good 'do-er', as my lovely mother-in-law used to say. But that was the only rose I could get from the nursery I buy from that seemed to fit the colour scheme. I would have loved to get Clementina Carbonieri, but it's not available here. I'm not mad on LH, but she does well here, and the foliage is pretty.

Good luck with your Le Vesuves. I don't have one, but have read what thorny monsters they are. I dread getting under 2 Marie van Houttes I have, but I doubt they're a patch on LV for tearing one apart.

After all you have done for your roses, it seems very unfair!

A Busy Winter Ahead

portlandmysteryrose

Comments (7)

nanadollZ7 SWIdaho

titian1 10b Sydney
Original Author

Related Discussions

comtessedelacouche (10b S.Australia: hotdryMedclimate)

titian1 10b Sydney
Original Author

ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9

titian1 10b Sydney
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

A Busy Winter Ahead

portlandmysteryrose

Comments (7)

nanadollZ7 SWIdaho

titian1 10b SydneyOriginal Author

Related Discussions

comtessedelacouche (10b S.Australia: hotdryMedclimate)

titian1 10b SydneyOriginal Author

ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9

titian1 10b SydneyOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

titian1 10b Sydney
Original Author

titian1 10b Sydney
Original Author

titian1 10b Sydney
Original Author