skip to main content

Gardening in the UK

Planting over stumps

7 years ago

Hello!

We've just bought our first house, and with it our first garden, which I'm slowly re-adapting to make it my own. I was looking for some planting advice for an area towards the back of the garden, where I've got some tree stumps in the borders.

When we arrived, there was a lot of rubble covering some areas in our borders (raised beds with concrete walls) so I've removed that to reveal these partially-rotted stumps that were once reasonably large trees (trunk diameter would have been about 30cm) with some bare soil around them.

I would obviously like to make these look pretty by adding some plants, I'm thinking of flowers, but I'm sure there are complications around planting over stumps, does anybody have any suggestions for what sort of plants or methods I should use in this area?

West facing house in the south of England, fairly shady spot, see pictures below of the two stumps and larger photo of the area.

Thanks a lot!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

TaraMaiden
7 years ago
Hi, Ickle_Cat, hope you're still around! It's been nearly a month, so I wouldn't be surprised if you weren't!

Anyhow, let's see:
Have you any idea what these trees were?

The roots look pretty dead to me, but you may like to consider the hire of a grinder to eliminate as much of the surface remnant as possible.

The borders look quite tiny...

In your position I would look to be honest, at a total 're-model. Maybe build up the borders by constructing some brick planters, (3 feet high, and in whatever shapes would suit and fit.

We did this in our old garden. we built plant enclosures, leaving quarter-brick gaps at the bottom for drainage, filled them to 6" with stones and then poured in sacks a-plenty of good potting compost.

Given that the trees look dead, if you build over and around them, so that they are right at the bottom of the plant beds, they will gradually rot away....

Fifth picture, first row, and first picture second row, is what they looked like.
ickle_cat
Original Author
7 years ago
Hi Tara, thank goodness for email alerts!
I don't mind the look of the stumps, I'm more looking for small plants that are both OK in the shade and have a shallow root depth that can go around the stumps into the soil to make the border look nicer (think little medow flowers growing through a path). The brick planters are a good idea but not the asthetic I think I want to go for.

I've had a go at the stump in the bottom picture at trying to get some mushrooms to grow. I bought some closed cup ones from the supermarket (they looked like they still had the mycillim on them but I'm not expert) and just buried them. Nothing so far, but I live in hope.

I guess what I'm after is suggestions on plants with the right asthetic but also that are OK in the shade. Whatever is growing in the second picture is quite pretty and has some flowers now, I'd settle for some more of that!
Related Discussions
Can I plant a Vegetable garden over 2 ground pine tree stumps
Q
Comments (3)
I think you'll be ok, as others have said in different posts, you may need to add some Nitrogen. I would not just go adding lime or dolomite though. You should probably get a soil test done first to see what if anything you need to add to the soil. Check with your local university's agriculture dept, they often will do soil tests for low cost. I would also not worry about the fungus from the decaying wood, that will most likely help rather than harm anything.
...See More
planting grass over ground up stump
Q
Comments (35)
Hi Becky! This old thread is interesting. Do you still have problems with the ground sinking over that stump 5 years later? When I had my back yard redone, they removed a tree that was probably close to 2 feet in diameter. They removed the entire root ball pictured below to avoid a continual sinking of the ground above. I'm surprised you haven't seen more problems than it sounds like you have. I had a comparatively small dogwood removed due to age a good 8 years ago. This year just now is showing the greatest amount after effect from so many years ago. I have several holes up to 6 inches in diameter because the roots that were not removed are finally deteriorating. I've been trying to fill them with sand and soil but it will take time for it all to settle out completely. I fear you haven't seen the worst of it yet.
...See More
nandina filamentosa: can I plant it over a buried tree stump?
Q
Comments (9)
I would just LOVE to be able to get that stump out! There was another tree (a large, probably 40+ year old rhododendron) nearby that I also took out when all these changes happened, and it has taken me three solid days of 3-4 hours each day to get that particular stump out. I don't have a chain saw, so I had to use a combination of hand saws, a gravity-drop splitting maul, and other non-powered garden tools. I tried using the maul over the buried stump and it was like trying to crack a buried cement sidewalk about a foot in diameter. (There is also a sprinkler system and rock wall nearby so I don't have a lot of room to maneuver tools.) The guy who did the stump grinding asked if he could quit once he got down 8 inches and nothing showed above ground, and I said Yes because I wasn't planning on planting anything there at the time. So I'm pretty discouraged about getting the stump out now, even though that's what I'd really prefer. I guess I'll give it another shot trying to chip away with the gravity maul at the extremely hard, flat surface that's underground, but since it was so recently cut, it doesn't seem to be very much affected by that heavy wedge dropping on it again and again.
...See More
Garden beds over grinded tree stump?
Q
Comments (2)
I had a huge stump ground out of my front yard. I believed the stump-grinder that I wouldn’t have to do anything to that spot and grass would grow immediately thru the sawdust. Wrong, wrong, wrong. That was dumb on my part. After year 2, I started removing sawdust and replacing it with dirt and soil nutrients. It sank and sank and sank. Finally, last year - 5 years after the grinding - I got a good stand of grass.
...See More
TaraMaiden
7 years ago
Ah, ok, right: Plants that love shade:

The plant in the picture is Vinca, more commonly known as Periwinkle,
Violas (lots of varieties, some with speckled petals, some perfumed)

Alchemilla Mollis (Lady's Mantle)

Cyclamen Coum

There's a great list here: Just look at the growth pattern, but remember that under trees, and in the shade, they may need copious watering....

Hope this helps!

Related Stories

DECORATING GUIDES Bring Nature Indoors With Tree Stumps, Trunks and Logs

By Janell Beals - House of Fifty

Furniture formed from wood in its natural state adds earthy elegance to any room

CRAFTS Bowl Over Guests With a DIY Air Plant Terrarium

By Lauren Donaldson

Air plants don't need much attention, but they'll get it anyway with a snazzy, gilded home you make yourself

DECORATING GUIDES How to Decorate When You're Starting Out or Starting Over

No need to feel overwhelmed. Our step-by-step decorating guide can help you put together a home look you'll love

GARDENING GUIDES Great Design Plant: Western Bleeding Heart

Delicate heart-shaped flowers belie a tough nature in this woodland spring perennial

SPRING GARDENING Spring Planting: Wonderful Wisteria

By Sheila Schmitz

Classic Vines Add Fragrance, Color and Romance to Garden Designs

GARDENING GUIDES Great Design Plant: Lonicera Sempervirens

By Ellen Sousa/Turkey Hill Brook Farm

Grow this long-blooming, flashy flowering vine to cover a fence or arbor and attract hordes of hummingbirds all season long

LANDSCAPE DESIGN Great Design Plant: Quaking Aspen for 3-Season Beauty — on Its Own Turf

It offers bright fall foliage, snowy winter bark and lush green leaves in summer. Just don't try to plant quaking aspen away from its home

TREES Native Plant Alternatives to Invasive Common Buckthorn

By Pollination Press LLC

Learn how to identify and control this aggressive plant, and what to grow in its place

FARM YOUR YARD How to Build a Raised Bed for Your Veggies and Plants

By Annie Thornton

Whether you’re farming your parking strip or beautifying your backyard, a planting box you make yourself can come in mighty handy

CONTAINER GARDENS Solve Your Garden Border Dilemmas With Planted Pots

Set your containers free from the patio — placed among plantings in the ground, they fill unsightly gaps, let you experiment and more

Sponsored

Dream Baths by Kitchen Kraft

12 Reviews

Your Custom Bath Designers & Remodelers in Columbus I 10X Best Houzz

More Discussions

Global Recognition: Certificate Attestation Services in the UAE

0