I'm cheap. I'd keep it if I liked it. As long as you stick with another one-hole faucet, future replacement is EASY. It's not a forever choice like a sink or countertop so you can always decide later. :)

On the other topic, i don't think a tall faucet would be bad, even off-center.

The advantage to the high-arc faucet is that it's so much easier to to use. No clunking pots into it or maneuvering large stuff under it. For me, function far outweighs whether of not it's exactly lined up with the center of the window. Do you really notice it when you're not actively contemplating it? Me, I'd go for the better faucet. (Great view, BTW!)

I had a faucet just like that one in the kitchen we just renovated and I couldn't wait to get rid of it. I found the pull out more awkward than the pull-down I had in the kitchen in my old house. I also bumped pots on it constantly and the handle was unbalanced to it would tun off if I tried to keep the water streaming at a low level.

Loonlakelaborcamp - it will still be a divided sink, possibly 60/40. Suzanne_sl, I don't notice it now but am afraid I will after I get a tall one in there :) And yeah, so glad to be above my neighbors for the most part!

I bet you won't notice the higher faucet being off center either. I think it's just one of those details that we "normalize". It sounds like you're happy with your current faucet, but there's something about a new sink that seems to be shinier with a new faucet, not that I'm influenced by marketing. I kept my sink, so I kept my faucet to save the $$.

I'd change it to a pull down instead of the pull out.

I love pull out faucets. I have a similar one and liked it. Now I have the Moen Walden pullout. It is a higher arch with a pullout feature. I would probably keep it for now. As someone above said, it is not a forever decision.

Center the new faucet on the middle of the window where there is trim. It will be less noticeable.

i would change it to pull-down., they are so much easier to use., function over form for me, i don't think u will care after its in for week...i think mine is about that high (with a window) and i don't even notice it., but then again i gave the height not much thought, i knew i wanted a pull down so i got what i wanted....

What's the flow rate? Will a new faucet be significantly lower in flow?

It looks like your current sink is a 50/50 divide with the faucet centered on the divide. If your new sink is 60/40 the divide in it will be either a few inches to the left or right depending on which way you orientate the bowls. If you continue to line up the faucet with the divide it will be it will not be in the same position it is now. How much it will be moved over depends on the overall size of the sink and the size of the divided bowls. It could be enough to have the faucet centered on the window if the smaller bowl is on the right which could make the new divide 3 or 4 inches to the right (I can't tell from the photo how far off the faucet is now from the center of the window). You will need to look at the specs for the sink you are going to use. In my 33 inch Blanco Silgranite 60/40 sink, the large bowl is 18" wide and the small bowl is 12" so the divide is 3" different than in the 50/50 version of the same size sink.

With all that being said, there is no rule that says a faucet has to be aligned with the sink divide. You could put it so that it is in line with the middle of the large bowl or the middle of the small bowl and then it would look like the placement was a planned, deliberate decision rather than being a mistake.

I have a similar layout as yours but my kitchen is slightly smaller. The old sink was centered around the window but the cabinet placement was horrible so I offset the sink to get more usable cabinet design. I thought it would bother me but I chose functional over it. I ended up loving it and it doesn't bother me a bit! I have a tall pull down faucet with a single bowl sink.

Love that!