A sad, sad stem... Need advice, please..

8 years ago

I have a fuzzy Echeveria (E. pulvinata or E. 'Doris Taylor'? Not sure.. ) in a 10cm/4inch pot (measured at the top/rim) that used to look like this:

That photo was taken in early December, but then by early January it looked like this (the pic was taken after watering so it looked wet):

The leaves were yellowing, had brown tips, but not mushy, they just dried up from the lower leaves upwards and fell off. I stop watering after this (better under than over watering, right?). This week, all leaves have fallen off, only stem left:

I gave it a little tug and was met with some resistance. I took it out of the pot anyway, and the roots looked good to me, at least no rotting. I may have accidentally lost a little root when washing off the soil... ~_~

I'm leaving it unpotted and shaded in my windowsill for the time being. I'm planning to repot it in a smaller pot later on.

Does anyone has any idea of what's happening here? Will it survive and grow leaves again? I haven't had success with any Echeveria so far, don't know why (no chemistry?). This is my last one, the others regretfully didn't make it, lost their battles with rot and sneaky pests :(

Thank you in advance.

Featured Answer

kaktuskris

8 years ago

Looks like you had it in soil that was too water retentive, you gave it too much water, and not enough light. Predictable outcome. It may come back, with care, but why not just start over, with a new plant under better conditions?

Christopher

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

hellkitchenguy Manuel
8 years ago
Hi, I've never had any Echeverias, but those roots just don't look healthy to me. I would say your plant was drowning in a mix that is too water retentive. Going forward, I would get rid of all that dressing you had on top of the soil. It traps water inside the soil, prevents evaporation, and keeps oxygen out.

Truthfully, I would chuck it and start all over again. But, it seems that you are embracing the challenge of saving this one plant (I love doing that sometimes). If I were you and really wanted to save it, I would get a small bag of perlite, and plant that rooted stem in a small container with 100% perlite. Yes, perlite floats, and it's not perfect, but it will let oxygen get to the roots, and will give it a chance too come back to life. This would only be a temporary thing, until the roots have had a chance to bounce back to life. I have saved a couple of hopeless cases by doing that
chuckerfly thanked hellkitchenguy Manuel
rina_Ontario,Canada 5a
8 years ago
Looks like you are using rice husks? I don't have any experience with them and don't know how much water they retain, but know they are recommended for potting mixes. Are they mixed with anything else?

I use top-dressing on all succulents and many other plants I have - as long as the potting mix is well-draining, I believe the top-dressing doesn't cause any problems. What I don't know for sure is the more humid climate - we have some high humidity in summer, but not months and months of it.

Rina
chuckerfly thanked rina_Ontario,Canada 5a
Related Discussions
Sad palm-Need an advice
Q
Comments (2)
1st of all, there is no such thing as "very good natural light" indoors but "not direct sun light". Only shade loving understory palms will tolerate those conditions long term. Most palms need all the sun you can give them indoors. 2nd, besides what mike mentioned about the moisture levels, makes sure that the pot is not sitting in drained water that collects in the saucer. The salts that are leached out are in high concentration in drained water, and if given the opportunity to be reabsorbed it will lead to browning leaves. Elevate the pot with a brick or something similar so that water drains freely.
...See More
sad sad habaneros in need of help
Q
Comments (12)
I would not add any more Epsom salt unless you have checked your soils and are lacking it as for the rain that should not be the issue neither if your pots have good drainage some people say pepper roots do not like to stay wet but hydro grow shows that to be incorrect there is a big difference in being wet and not being able to breath then being wet with plenty of Air many people make that mistake i don't think it would be lack of nitrogen being your getting plenty of rain.... rain picks up nitrogen nutrients and minerals as it falls from the sky i would check to make sure you have good drainage in the pot & the roots are breathing ...... here is a few things you can try that may help get you some Standard Miracle Grow .... and a small bottle of Super Thrive along with a bottle of Alaskan Fish Emulsion mix it at half strength for indoor or potted plants in a gallon jug then put some in a spray bottle mist your plants every other day with this it will not burn your foliage but will make sure your plant have the right stuff to thrive if the plant is still giving you a issue i would add some perlite to the soil to help assure better air flow also if you are using tap water at any time be sure to put it in a gallon jug or a tub tote for 24 hours to insure the chlorine is evaporated & gone it is a enemy .....& will kill your beneficial micro organisms & Fungi in the soils that help aid your plants .
...See More
Need advice for my sad succulent!
Q
Comments (3)
You don't want to use sand in the mix, so it's good if there isn't any. But mix is not that great anyway. For succulents, the best potting mix is fast draining, containing more inorganic materials like grit, perlite, pumice, turface, scoria...I don't know if you can get any of these; also you didn't mention where you live. Adding general location or at least a growing zone next to your name would help. If you can't get gritty, mostly inorganic mix mentioned above (most of us make our own since that kind is not available in any store-garden center-greenhouse), at least get a bag of perlite and mix with C&S soil you have, at 50/50 ratio (could be even more perlite). It will be much better draining than what you have now. There are couple of sellers where you could buy similar mix by mail. I don't know how good it is since I never purchased from them. Plant is difficult to ID - close up may help, but plant needs to 'get better' to be sure of ID. It is probably one of the echeverias (?). Regardless what it is, they need just about same care: well draining mix I mentioned, container should have drainage hole, and lots of light. Your plant is most likely not getting enough since it is just stretching in search of more light (etiolating), growing long stalks but hardly any leaves.
...See More
Sad Peace Lily. Need advice
Q
Comments (8)
When you water it, do you flush out the entire pot? Or do you only give it small amounts, so that it doesn't drain through? It looks like it's not getting watered properly, causing mineral buildup within the soil. That's most likely why its leaves are turning brown along the edges. Judging from your photos, the soil looks way too dry. If it were my plant, I would soak the entire pot in water all the way up to the soil line. After about an hour, I would drain the water away and then flush it with plenty of fresh water until the murky water runs clear out of the drainage holes. This would help to remove most of the minerals that have accumulated within the soil. This, however, is just a quick short term fix. I would repot it with some fresh soil as soon as possible; using a fast-draining soil that doesn't stay soggy, such as a mix designed for cacti & succulents. With the sun getting lower on the horizon, I would move it closer to a window that receives plenty of filtered sunlight. It needs to gather up as much energy as it can to recover, and it can only do that thru photosynthesis.
...See More
chuckerfly
Original Author
8 years ago
Thank you all for the responses and advice. One question, would it be okay to leave it unpotted for the next 2 weeks or the sooner the better to pot in new mix? I'm leaving town the day after tomorrow for 2 weeks. I guess I'm just anxious that I won't be around if something happens to it during that time.. :/
Tamiya #1 (AU, SG, MY & ZZZzzzz...)
8 years ago
I have left barerooted E for over 2 mths (over summer here!) on a cardboard tray in shade... they start growing roots from several spots :) only just stuck them back into a pot of dirt last week

otoh mine had a few leaves on each 3-6" stem. Have doubts if your leafless stem has enough energy stored to do anything, I don't think it'll photosynthesise much via that stem :(

best get another cutting and don't water it until it screams for water by leaves wrinkling like a raisin... when it's humid or cold, that could be months!!
chuckerfly thanked Tamiya #1 (AU, SG, MY & ZZZzzzz...)
chuckerfly
Original Author
8 years ago
Well, I guess we'll see if my stem decided to do anything, hehe.. :p

A sad, sad stem... Need advice, please..

kaktuskris

Comments (6)

hellkitchenguy Manuel

rina_Ontario,Canada 5a

Related Discussions

chuckerfly
Original Author

Tamiya #1 (AU, SG, MY & ZZZzzzz...)

chuckerfly
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

A sad, sad stem... Need advice, please..

kaktuskris

Comments (6)

hellkitchenguy Manuel

rina_Ontario,Canada 5a

Related Discussions

chuckerflyOriginal Author

Tamiya #1 (AU, SG, MY & ZZZzzzz...)

chuckerflyOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

chuckerfly
Original Author

chuckerfly
Original Author