I used Restorafinish on my old mahogany dining table that has seen many, many better years.....lol! With the first application with a cloth only, it didn't seem to make much difference, it still looked pretty bad. So I went ahead and did it again, using fine steel wool and really putting some elbow grease into it, and it DID improve the overall appearance. At least well enough for me to finally, finally, take off the tablecloth that I've always needed to use to hide the damaged finish. The finish on my old table was dulled and scratch and had rings from people putting glasses on it, etc. Although it's still dulled, and needs a good sealant, at least now all the surface stain is the same color and looks decent enough to go naked. I can't post a photo today because my camera's out of batteries, otherwise I would. If your stuff looks like "crap", as you say, I don't see how it could hurt it any worse to try the steel wool technique.

I am still undecided between BM White Dove and BM Cloud White. I love the BM Simply White with my new tiles but it is so white and I want my cabinets a little bit darker. I had planned on using BM Cloud White but it seems BM White Dove is a little darker so I may first try painting one door in this since the painted boards do not look like the painted chips. Anyone have pictures to post? Is there anyway to show a piece of white paper next to a BM White Dove or BM White Cloud door? I wanted to buy new cabinets but for now, I will paint mine after I do the floors and lighting and see if I like living with white so when I buy new cabinets in 2 years, I will know to go with white or a cherry stained door.

I am happy to report that I did buy it. It is truly stunning and has much more presence than the pictures show. It's very solid and hefty and at 7' long it is a beauty. I couldn't wait to get home from work today so I could sit in the room and look at it. Now I need to finish the room it is in ! I was thinking some cool wallpaper would be a good back drop..

Thanks for the close up. I think you will be OK with the Crema. For example, even if this counter gives the effect of a solid from a distance, there are many examples here of wood cabinets, white or cream backsplash and dark soapstone (Which can look like a solid) and these kitchens look great. As you say, the Crema will pick up on the cream speckles. Put the board sideways and take a picture so we can get the idea if you like. You will be fine. I understand what you are going through!