Reasonable Expectations for Solid Wood Dining Room Table

8 years ago

My husband and I are furnishing a new-to-us house, and as always, I'm a value shopper (highest quality for lowest price). We are on the hunt for dining room tables.

Specifications:

Rectangular dining room table
Approximately 78" wide x 40" deep to seat 8 people
Plus a leaf for entertaining
Trestle or pedestal base to enable more seating (unlike our current dining room table, whose legs block the corners)
Durable and likely distressed, since we'll be having kids
Light wood or gray/greige stain or something else that contrasts with our dark hardwood floors (50% Jacobean, 50% Ebony)
No red undertones
Chairs are a non-issue, since we won't be purchasing matching ones.

I like this Z Gallerie table, the reviews are great, and the price seems reasonable, but it's MDF.

This Wayfair table also has a reasonable price but is a bit too large and doesn't have a leaf.

This Overstock table looks promising, but one of the reviewers commented on red undertones.

I haven't had any luck on Craigslist thus far.

I've seen people recommend custom tables in previous threads, but I get sticker shock when perusing local woodworkers' profiles on CustomMade (although I recognize that people should be paid for their handcrafted work).

I live in Ohio, so Amish may be an option, but I'm not sure about price points, and the styles/stains I see online often look too traditional for our tastes. Places like Furniture Fair sell Amish-made tables, but if I were to go that route, I would go straight to the source and eliminate the middleman (Furniture Fair).

My questions are:

What's a realistic price for a solid wood table that meets the specifications listed above? I was hoping to stay within $1,500; however, if that were a ridiculous expectation, it would be helpful to know that.
Am I looking in the correct places?
Is there a wood type (e.g., maple) that is preferable/superior for quality and durability?

Thanks for your input!

Featured Answer

barryv_gw

8 years ago

First, stunned you have not had any luck with Craigslist. I just did a search locally and found quite a few. If you still have no local, check antique dealers or estate sales. The market for used furniture is now a fraction of what it was like 10 years ago - the younger generation does not want to buy furniture, and when they do, they generally want modern style. Also, if you find something you like, and the color is not what you want, see what it would cost to refinish it. Chairs can be expensive to refinish, but tables are much easier to do, so should not be that expensive. If you are looking at an antique dealer, they should have a suggestion as to a refinisher. I have not priced new furniture lately, but much of the furniture offered today is veneered, not solid wood. Common hardwoods for tables include cherry, maple, and mahogany. The maple is probably the strongest, though it usually comes in a lighter shade.

Don't even think custom. The cost for decent lumber is pretty high, and the material costs for such a large table could be in the neighborhood of $500 or up, so with labor, I would be stunned if you could find anything near your budget.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

lindac92
8 years ago
I agree....look for antiques. You are describing my 75 year old semi-chippendale light mahogany table. There's one on eBay, a little narrower than you describe for $850>
Watch for Estate auctions.....
kleighj thanked lindac92
Related Discussions
Solid Cherry dining room suggestions?
Q
Comments (24)
Check out this site. It is Henkel Harris, some new discontinued, and some preowned. www.gncantiques.com They appear very nice on the phone, so you may want to call to find out what they have in new stuff. I know that you said new cherry. If I had $10,000 for dining furniture, I would get as much Henkel Harris as I could get.LOL
...See More
Engineered wood - reasonable/expected costs for mid-grade?
Q
Comments (10)
SJ McCarthy - thanks for the response. To clarify, those quotes are not for the cost of the wood. They are for materials and installation - everything. I am not considering any products where the flooring cost alone is above $8/sf. That would mean a total cost that would be far outside of my budget. Note that I do not need an engineered wood that can be resanded three times, as I am never going to do that. This is my permanent home - I don't care about resale-specific issues. It is just me living here, no pets. Of course my BF is here often, and my son stays with me when he visits, but traffic in my home is very light. The Harris product that I am considering is actually my top choice as far as appearance (Hickory Roaring Fork). It is by far the most appealing to me, over everything else I have seen. It is not a wire-brushed finish (which adds a lot to the cost) but since I don't love that look, it works for me. (I also cannot stand the hand-scraped, or distressed barnwood-looking stuff.) Its cost, that I am being quoted, is between 4.70 and 5.00 a square. I could beat that price online, but that opens up more issues for me. As far as "NWFA certified installers", there are none within 50 miles from me. So for my purposes, using an authorized flooring retailer/installer would seem to give me more protection as far as warranty, would it not? Totally agree with what you are saying on the LVT - I am fairly certain I'm going with an Armstrong Vivero glue-down LVT - and it is a stone-look - not wood. Even the finished install cost of that winds up being around $7 a sf. Not cheap. I have thought about doing LVT everywhere, but frankly, I have not found any that has a look that I would want in those other areas, It has actually taken me many many hours (which means actual months!) of searching to finally find 2 or 3 engineered woods that I actually like, that would not empty my bank account. It's a curse being this picky. :-(
...See More
Mixing wood tones in an open concept kitchen/dining/living rooms
Q
Comments (2)
It is really hard to visualize without pics. I know you aren't in the space yet, but could you at least link to a pic of the dining set? And the sofa? And a photo of your chandelier since it sounds like you have that in your current home? It sounds like the kitchen is a black/white color scheme. A lot of people pair that with greige walls, which (if my web search turned up the right sorts of images for "mink") seems like it would work with your dining set. I think "fawn" walls would not work well with "mink," at least if my understanding of what you mean by those colors is on point. Fawn conjures up a warm color with orange undertones, and while that could look nice with a sage green living room set, I think it will fight the cooler tones of the kitchen and the proposed dining set. It sounds like the peppercorn floor is not installed yet, so I will throw this out there: Dark floors have a reputation for showing every speck of dust. The elements you've described would look just as nice with a less dramatically dark floor. Just something to think about. I haven't found it to be difficult to find black tables in styles other than country. What style are you interested in? More modern? More traditional? I'm sure we could help you find something. But if you stick with the peppercorn floors, black furnishings might be too much black. You could do white (tie in with kitchen cabinetry), chrome (tie in with your proposed chandelier) or something else. Congratulations on your new home! (I probably should have led with that...)
...See More
Updating Solid Wood Table with Unfortunate Finish
Q
Comments (15)
I love upcycling old furniture. My advise to you is keep the tabletop wood. sand all the varnish off and get it back to it orginal wood. paint the rest of the table and chairs with a couour that suits your room. sand them by hand first to make them feel rough then primer them a couple of times before adding the top colour coats. give the wood surface of the table a coat of quick drying varnish (colour of your choice) once dry, then gently sand wipe down with a slightly damp cloth then start again until desired affect. but chair cushions from a good home store and you won't be dissapointed
...See More
jakkom
8 years ago
Estate sales are your best bet, but it can take time (and often they only take cash, with delivery extra or not available).

Ballard Designs is a company I've used occasionally for over a decade. They were recently mentioned in an interior designers article as "this is my secret place to go for well-made, stylish, moderate-priced furniture." I've bought mostly small pieces from them but been very satisfied.

They have the Casa Florentina table in a variety of color washes for the pedestal base. The price is $1799, solid beechwood which I have found to be extremely fine-grained and durable. In fact, you have to like whatever color it's stained (the top, in this case, is walnut-stained) because it's said to be almost impossible to strip and re-stain beechwood by any home method.

Ballard recently had a 20% off sale, which would have been $359 off the full price to bring it down within your budget. You might want to call them and find out when they're having their next sale, or at least get on their mailing list.

Casa Florentina table

http://www.ballarddesigns.com/casa-florentina-tarvine-double-pedestal-table-with-walnut-top/furniture/dining-kitchen/dining-tables/314661
kleighj thanked jakkom
lindac92
8 years ago
I have had no trouble buying at estate sales. There have been a couple in the 40 or so years I have been buying that did ask for either a letter of credit guarantee from my bank or asked to have a credit card as back up for my check....but that isn't the rule.
And I would much rather buy fine quality vintage hardwood furniture than cheap new....which isn't really as cheap as the good old vintage stuff.
kleighj thanked lindac92
iowabuilder
8 years ago
we have had great results working with www.amishfinefurnishings.com in Iowa
patty Vinson
8 years ago
And don't forget consignment furniture stores. Just about all my furniture came from consignmet/antique stores, as well as auctions and estate sales. The only new pieces I have are the upholstered pieces. All are solid wood vs MDF, and cost a lot less! If you have an appreciation for antique/vintage, and don't have a problem with it being 'used', that really is the way to go.

Reasonable Expectations for Solid Wood Dining Room Table

barryv_gw

Comments (6)

lindac92

Related Discussions

jakkom

lindac92

iowabuilder

patty Vinson

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US