Condensate Pump on new install very noisy, running constantly

9 years ago

This is our second winter with our new furnace - Carrier Infinity 59TN6. Attached to the furnace is a Honeywell HE100A1000 humidifier and a Beckett CB151UL condensate pump. The condensate pump is on the floor next to the furnace, but not attached to the furnace with screws. The HVAC equipment is in a utility closet on the 1st floor.

I noticed over the past couple weeks that the condensate pump is running constantly, for about 5-10 seconds every few minutes, and the motor noise is so loud that it can be heard throughout the 1st floor and in the bedroom above the closet. The noise is driving me crazy. Usually it's just a regular, really loud, motor noise, but once a day or so it's extra loud like grinding coffee beans.

It seems the constant running is due to the humidifier. Turning off the humidifier stops the constant running of the condensate pump, but it's very dry inside - 28% humidity currently.

Is there a problem with my install, or my equipment?

Is there something wrong with the condensate pump, that the motor is so loud it can be heard throughout the house, or that it's running every few minutes? Is it undersized for the load?

Is there something wrong with my humidifier that it's dumping so much water into the condensate pump that it's running constantly?

Is there anything I can do to remedy the problem?

Is there a better way of maintaining 40% humidity during the winter? It seems even with running constantly our humidifier isn't up to the task.

I'm hesitant to call our HVAC company again as it cost me $90 just to find out that the noise is coming from the condensate pump, and is considered normal and "quiet".

I would greatly appreciate any help and advice you can give me.

We just bought a new house, and need to replace the furnace there due to a cracked heat exchanger (that the home inspection didn't find - awesome...), so even if there's nothing I can do to fix our current house, I want to avoid making the same mistake in the new house.

This post was edited by Timobkg on Thu, Jan 8, 15 at 11:28

Featured Answer

Alexander Timofeyev
Original Author

9 years ago

Thanks for the advice.

I'm still not sure what caused the humidity level to drop that low. The thermostat controller was set for 40%, but maybe the window saving feature dialed that down without telling me because the outdoor temperature recently had a severe drop?

I've raised the windows protection setting to the max since, and it's back up to 34% now.

We had our HVAC company's Energy Auditor / Sales person out last week with a proposal for the new house, and he said that there's something wrong with the pump and they'll replace it for us (provided we buy our new HVAC system from them, of course).

It's just disappointing that the service tech comes and says, "Yeah, that's normal, it's supposed to make that sound all the time. That'll be $90", and it takes getting a sales guy out and the prospect of new business for them to say, "Yeah, it shouldn't do that. It needs to be replaced."

I mean, what's the point in spending $10K on a high-end, ultra-quiet HVAC system when it's undone by the noise from a $70 pump?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

tigerdunes
9 years ago
Something not right here. Condensate pump should be quiet...depending on setup/install, small transformer can go bad and buzzzzz.

Assuming your reading is correct, a 28% inside humidity tells me that the humidifier is not doing it's job. That's low and reading should be around 35-40%.

IMO
jimct01
9 years ago
Sounds like you need to replace the condensate pump. Many current humidifiers run a constant flow of water through them so it's not unusual for them to run a lot. Sounds like the motor or pump is shot .
Related Discussions
Condensate pump running
Q
Comments (4)
Does your furnace vent up a chimney or out the wall? If it's high efficiency using through-the-wall venting it will produce condensate that needs to be drained periodically. the pump shouldn't run constantly--that's a pump problem that won't be solved by wiring it differently. FWIW, replacements cost less than $100 generally and you can install yourself if you're mildly handy.
...See More
TACO circulator pump running constantly
Q
Comments (14)
Yes if you have a higher pressure it is easer to push the air out. its the same way to circulate, if you pressure is to low it will not want to flow to the upper story, especial if the pump is too small. If you go to the hi velocity pump,and thats what i always use in a three story house, you will have one little thing you may not like. On a zone system , when only one zone is open you might hear a little water movement noise depending on you piping system. Engineering will vary from one engineer to another a little. But i am going to give you some facts. normal hot water system no more than 30' to 40' of radiation on one 3/4 in. loop or zone and standard zone values 3 to 3 1/2 gal.s per min. . Now if you have too long of loop you will slow flow down and lose too much heat, same if you have too much radiation on a loop. You said three story two zones. this sounds like long loops which means hi head pressure, and maybe too much radiation per zone. some times when i run into this i advice the owner that we will have to switch the zone values to a full flow zone value, they go up to about 7 gal.s per min. flow, this along with the hi head pump will take care of too much heat loss,and too much head pressure. I hope all this is not confusing you too much, But hot water in a older home can be a little complicated. and a lot of guys do not understand this. You can check a zone out one way by checking the temp leaving the boiler and then check the temp. coming back from the zone. no more than 15 degrees drop.. Later Paulbm
...See More
How to quiet some noisy circulator pumps
Q
Comments (10)
We still don't know what kind of pump the OP has. How many are there? If more than one, do all of them cause the same noise? Vibration could be transmitted by all the routes indicated by the OP. Another route is right up the pipes. Changing pumps can have two effects, One is changing the frequency of the vibration generated and the other is changing the mass of the system. Are the pumps mounted on the boiler or the pipes? If you hand a big BG pump on there, the harmonic of the pipes might change enough to eliminate the problem, that will be similar to hanging a big piece of inert metal on the pipe. Right now you might have a system with the motor harmonically coupled to the pipes. If so, you just have to uncouple them one way or another. Can you feel a vibration in the pipe that goes away when the circulator shuts off? Does the vibration in the pipe go away if you wrap your (gloved if necessary) hand around it? What kind of pipe is connected to the pump and does that kind go all the way to what ever is below the floors? What floor does the output pipe from the pump connect to first, the loudest room? If so, the pipe might be vibrating against a joist or something else right there. If so, you might be able to eliminate the transmission some other way, but you might have to cut into a wall or floor to see what is banging against what and eliminate it. Definitely do investigation at the boiler first, less messy and less expensive.
...See More
Noisy Compressor in Geothermal Heat Pump
Q
Comments (14)
mac I have an Econar GT heat pump in a second floor closet and had noise issues that were aweful. It turned out to be improper vibration dampening when the system was installed. The scroll compessors run between 50 and 60 cycles per second. The 3 stage fan in my 3 ton GT unit runs in the 1100 to 1800 RPM range (or 18 to 30 cycles per second). The guys who did the install laid the GT unit on the floor and put a rubber mat under the base. That mat became essentailly a vibration noise amplifier. I found that rubber can isolate very high frency vibs - not the lower frequnecies. The rubber is recommended at a minimum of 45 Hz - but it really doesn't work well until you get above 60. I know this is the case becuase my loop pumps in the basement run at 60 Hz and they are on rubber mats too - no vibration noise (there is acoustical noise from the impellar spinning - but that has to be dampened by other means). My solution was to jack up the unit - get if off the floor by 5 inches or so - and put vibration isolation mounts with springs on each of the 4 corners. These springs can dampen vibs down to a few Hz and up to 60Hz - they are much more effective then rubber in the frequnecy range of the unit. That fixed the problem. You can still hear the unit for the first 3 to 5 seconds after it first turns on - but once it is in steady state, it purrs. No louder than the hum of a refrigerator. My builder and HVAC contractor were stunned - appranetly they have this same issue in other houses they built with GT where people cannot sleep (but never told me that when they sold me the GT)! I think they owe me one. Your issue sounds similar to mine. Can you describe how the unit was installed - where it is, what is it resting on? What type of floor is it on - is it in a closet? Is the closet insulated? The site I used to but these products is www.acousticalsurfaces.com. Look under Vibration Mounts and then look under Housed Spring Mounts. The product is made by Mason Industries and needs to be chosen carefully based on your units corner weight. You need to determine if the noise you are hearing is acoustic noise or vibration noise. If it is acoustic noise - then you can use sound proofing insulation. If it is vibration noise - then you need dampeners. I used both - the walls of the room have insulation to dampen acoustic noise. The springs dampen vibration noise.
...See More
sktn77a
9 years ago
I think both of the above diagnoses are correct. Your water from the humidifier appears to be going into the condensate pump rather than the house and it sounds like the condensate pump is burning out because of this.
ACwannaBe
9 years ago
Here's a few additional thoughts - btw, I agree with the previous comments.

I looked up your equipment online, and you can find an exact replacement for your condensate pump for $40. As was previously stated, it shouldn't make any noise above a hum, so it sounds like that should definitely be replaced.

Is it possible that something is diverting the water away from the media pad and instead it is just going down the drain to your pump? That would explain why your humidity has been low AND why the condensate pump was running excessively. It may be as simple as redirecting the nozzle that sprays water onto the pad.

It stinks that you got bad service from that tech.

I wouldn't buy anything else from them - ever.

Good luck!
Alexander Timofeyev
Original Author
9 years ago
They replaced the condensate pump with a new one, and it's just as loud as before. I haven't heard it make a grinding sound yet, but the usual hum sound for pumping out humidifier condensate is loud enough to be heard throughout the first floor.

What's weird is that when the tech tested it by pouring in a pitcher of water, I didn't notice it outside the utility closet. But when it runs normally the hum sounds throughout the floor.

Is checking / redirecting the nozzle in the humidifier something I can do myself?
ACwannaBe
9 years ago
I have not seen your specific humidifier in person, and I don't know what mechanical skills you have, so I can't really comment as to whether you can determine where the water is directed.

I have included a link to the owners manual for your humidifier below. Spend some time with it to see how your unit works - it's not complicated.

You will note that the manufacturer specifies that it may take several days of operation before your home reaches the desired humidity.

Here is a link that might be useful: http://www.manualslib.com/manual/280257/Honeywell-He100a1000.html#manual

Condensate Pump on new install very noisy, running constantly

Alexander Timofeyev
Original Author

Comments (7)

tigerdunes

jimct01

Related Discussions

sktn77a

ACwannaBe

Alexander Timofeyev
Original Author

ACwannaBe

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Condensate Pump on new install very noisy, running constantly

Alexander TimofeyevOriginal Author

Comments (7)

tigerdunes

jimct01

Related Discussions

sktn77a

ACwannaBe

Alexander TimofeyevOriginal Author

ACwannaBe

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Alexander Timofeyev
Original Author

Alexander Timofeyev
Original Author