skip to main content

Gardening in Oz

too alkaline?

20 years ago

I have been using bags of mushroom compost, bought from a nursery, as an organic additive to my soil. Someone told me it may make the soil too alkaline. I also add homemade compost, cow manure and chicken manure, as well as sugar cane mulch and well-rotted woodchips. What do you all think?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

User
20 years ago
HI Little Digger ....Well that someone was right but..... Mushroom compost we bought from the mushroom farm was just passed 9 when I did a PH on it and another time I bought a bag from one of the big named stores and I reckon it was full of old potting mix..but I did not think to take a reading, but I do know it did nothing for the soil..

Nothing wrong with home made compost though why dont you buy yourself a PH Test kit then you can test all your soil and you wont have any problems..I myself now prefer not to use Mushroom compost even though we used to let it mature for months before we used it..I am more for the H.M.Compost and cow manure and chicken manure in moderation well aged mind you everyone has different idea's and all soils are different.. You do what you think is right and if your plants are coming along fine well you have done the right thing....Cheers..MM.
Little_Digger
Original Author
20 years ago
Thanks, Misty. I think I will buy myself a pH testing kit ... one of those things you think about but then put off. Re compost, when repotting plants, is it OK to add the old, depleted potting mix to the compost heap?
Related Discussions
Acidic Vs. Alkaline - Root Function
Q
Comments (11)
In order for plants to take up nutrients they must go into solution. That is, they must dissolve so that the plant roots can take them up along with water. If the pH is too high (aka "alkaline", the opposite of acidic) plant nutrients, especially metals like zinc, manganese, copper, and iron, don't dissolve and are in relatively large chunks or "precipitate". The plant roots have tiny little holes and these large chunks physically can't move into the roots. It would be like you trying to eat an orange through a straw. When the pH is too low, (acidic) then you get too much of a good thing. If too much of the plant nutrients in the soil go into solution, you get an overdose and end up with toxicity issues. One of the biggest players in toxicity secondary to low pH is aluminum. As mentioned above, some plants are adapted better to one condition or the other but must plants like the soil to be slightly acid but can tolerate a relatively wide range of pH values. Also as mentioned above, beneficial microbes that process organic material into plant available nutrients function best within a certain pH range and are less effective at very high or low pH values.
...See More
Soil acidity
Q
Comments (7)
Thanks, Michael. I won't do anything until I get the test back--detailed instructions came with the kit and it'll go to Virginia Tech for analysis. I have two kits--I'm planning on filling one with soil from beds and and one with container soilless mix since I have lots of container roses. I see chlorosis in beds and containers, about the same ratio. My roses are growing quite well--well, except for the ones that have had the life sucked out of them by spider mites, but they're trying to put out new growth. The choloris is only in the new growth on some roses and I have lots of new growth and buds coming along on almost every one. I realize I left out an important fact: almost all of my beds are raised and filled with bagged topsoil/composted manure. They've been in place for years so I just assumed *everyone* knows it and I forgot to mention it ;-) I mulch with shredded leaves and add compost as I have it. Only one bed is a combination of native red clay and bagged topsoil. Thanks again, Barbara
...See More
water ph 7.2 to 7.4 too alkaline?
Q
Comments (6)
It's your soil pH that counts, and irrigation water can slowly change the soil pH, but it is likely to be a slow thing. Most irrigation water on commercial citrus in Florida, California, and Texas, is up in the 7.1 or higher range, often 8.0 or higher. Not a problem at all, as along as the soil pH is monitored and adjusted as necessary. The more clay and/or organic matter there is in your soil, the better buffered (able to resist rapid changes in pH) it will be.
...See More
Too much garden lime, how to fix?
Q
Comments (14)
pH soil testing kits purchased at nurseries or garden centers are actually remarkable accurate - it is the probes or meters that are inaccurate. As long as you use distilled water with the test kits, you should get a very accurate reading. It's the nutrient testing kits that are a complete waste of money!! I also agree that testing now wll be inconclusive as it does take time for the lime to fully react and alter pH. And I'd also agree that I doubt the soil mix is salvageable for this season. You can use it as Babs described above or dump in an out of the way area and treat with garden sulfur to neutralize the lime.
...See More
Sparaxis
20 years ago
It really comes down towhat you are trying to grow. Mucxh of my time is spent here, trying to increase the pH, so mushroom compost is excellent for my needs. If you are trying to grow azaleas or natives, then you have a problem. It also depends where you live - what your soil is like to start with. Here it is fairly acidic and heavy, so the mushroom compost increases the pH and adds humus.
9 is way too high a pH for most plants though.
I must say we had a lovely feed of mushrooms out of our new soil last year. We were eating mushrooms on toast twice a week all through winter and Spring. Yum!
I would never add straight chicken manure to my garden either as a mulch or dug in. It is way too hot, even if it has sat for some time. It would be good mixed into a compost heap and allowed to sit. Cow manure is a favourite of mine, because rumenants destroy most grass seeds during the fermentation process, so you don't get much weed growth from it, unless it has sat in a heap and had seeds blown in to it.
tell us what plants you are trying to grow for more useful assistance :-)
Cheers, Jan
Robert_NSW
20 years ago
The pH of mushroom compost always tends towards the high side, but to varying degrees. Misty is right, you need a pH testing kit.
Little_Digger
Original Author
20 years ago
Thanks Jan. As for veg: lettuce, rocket, silver beet, tomatoes, beans, capsicums, zucchini, cukes. Ornamentals include roses, perennials, several camellias, gardenias. No natives or azaleas. The soil is quite heavy clay, although in cultivated areas it has been much improved.

Related Stories

GARDENING GUIDES Grow a Beautiful Garden in Alkaline Soil

By Noelle Johnson Landscape Consulting

Got alkaline soil? Learn how to manage it and the many beautiful plants that will thrive in this ‘sweet’ soil

EDIBLE GARDENS Summer Crop: How to Grow Blueberries

By Marianne Lipanovich

Plant blueberries in spring or fall for garden beauty through three seasons — and a sweet superfood in summer

GARDENING GUIDES Have Acidic Soil in Your Yard? Learn to Love Gardening Anyway

By Falon Mihalic

Look to acid-loving plants, like conifers and rhododendrons, to help your low-pH garden thrive

GARDENING GUIDES Bigtooth Maple, the West’s Native Sugar Maple

By Susan J Tweit

Plant Acer grandidentatum for cool shade, brilliant autumn colors and songbird habitat

LANDSCAPE DESIGN Lay of the Landscape: Southwestern Garden Style

By Marianne Lipanovich

Water may be scarce, but color and striking foliage are as profuse in the desert landscape as the sunsets are breathtaking

FLOWERS AND PLANTS Bauhinia Lunarioides Perfumes the Garden With Its Fragrant Flowers

By Noelle Johnson Landscape Consulting

Bees and butterflies flock to this Texas shrub’s white and pink flowers in spring and summer

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING Have a Ball With Hydrangeas

By Living Small: City & Small Space Consulting

Even if you don't tinker with the hue by changing the soil, hydrangeas have an entertaining range of uses in all kinds of landscapes

GARDENING GUIDES What's Wrong With My Plant? Leaves Often Hold the Clues

By Noelle Johnson Landscape Consulting

Learn how to identify common plant ailments by reading their leaves

FARM YOUR YARD How to Build a Raised Bed for Your Veggies and Plants

By Annie Thornton

Whether you’re farming your parking strip or beautifying your backyard, a planting box you make yourself can come in mighty handy

PLANTING IDEAS Designing With Conifers: Layers of Texture for Your Garden

Sharp and prickly or fine like ferns, richly textured conifers bring unexpected interest to the landscape

Sponsored

Peabody Landscape Group

8 Reviews

Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting