How do I know the difference between GREENS and BROWNS?

12 years ago

This is a popular question among many first composters or organic gardeners. Regardless of the name, "Greens" and "Browns" are not differences in physical color. It is more technical than that. These terms are functions of the C:N ratios in all once living creatures, plant or animal.

Greens and browns are nicknames for different types of organic matter to use in composting recipes.

Greens are high in nitrogen or protein, thus organic nitrogen sources. These products help the composting microherd to grow, breed, and multiply fast in the piles, thus creating extreme internal temperatures in hot compost piles.

Browns are high in carbon or carbohydrates, thus organic carbon sources. These products supply the energy and food that mostly all soil organism need to survive. Carbons also help absorb the offensive odors and capture and help prevent most of the organic nitrogen in the piles from escaping by evaporation or leaching. Carbons are also essential in the faster formation of humus from the organic matter in a composting process.

A simple test to determine if your organic matter is a "green" or a "brown", is to wet it, and wait a few days. If it stinks, it is definitely a green. If not, it's a brown.

Normal compost has a C:N ratio ranging from 25:1 to 30:1. This is considered the origin or dividing line for all organic materials.

Any organic matter that a C:N ratio smaller than 30:1 is considered a GREEN.

Any organic matter that a C:N ratio larger than 30:1 is considered a BROWN.

Alfalfa Hay can be brown in color, but it is always a "GREEN", or "NITROGEN" source because it's C:N ratio is around 12:1.

All Leaves can change from green, to orange, or to brown in color, but they are usually always considered "BROWNS" or "CARBON" sources because their C:N is on the average from 40:1 to 80:1. Evergreen leaves are higher in carbons than most leaves. Deciduous leaves are best for composting. Oak leaves (that is fresh green oak leaves, not the dry oak leaves) are an exception. They can be classed as a GREEN and should be added as a nitrogen material (Fresh Green Oak Leaves can have a C:N ratio of 26:1).

All animal manures, grass clippings, and food scraps are "GREENS".

All sawdusts, bark mulches, papers, and other wood products are "BROWNS".

Most sugar products are considered "browns" because they have a C:N ratio near 50:1. However all aerobic microbes love sugar as an quick, easily digestible energy food. So by adding a little tea made from molasses, sugar, syrups, or flat soft drinks, to your compost piles, you will increase the microbial activity and internal heating of a compost pile.

Just because an organic material has a C:N as a green or brown doesn't mean it will always act like regular high nitrogen greens or high carbon browns. The real test is in the experience of composting it. C:N ratios are just good guidelines or starting points for determining starting points for various green-brown mixtures in the pile.

For example, egg shells have a C:N around 12:1-15:1, however they act more like browns, because they may takes several weeks to decompose in the pile, based on the total amount of nitrogen in the compost pile. Seaweed is considered a green (C:N = 19:1), however it is really more a carbohydrate because it's so high in carbon, compared to its other nutrients in its makeup.

Do a web site search on "Compost Ingredients" for a more exhautive list of composting materials and their average C:N ratios.

Happy Gardening!

Comment

Related Discussions
Green Leaves - Carbon or Nitrogen?
Q
Comments (9)
Cattle ranchers know that the color of the leaves is only coincidentally related to protein (nitrogen) content. Tree leaves have little protein compared to grass leaves. While both are green in color, only grass is considered "green." Similarly wheat flour is white (really brown) in color but is highly "green" as are dark brown coffee grounds. Lettuce is very green in color and contains little to no protein so it is a brown. I have solved the green/brown problem for myself by dispensing with it. I'm only concerned about protein. Materials that have recognizable amounts of protein are green. This would include grass, seeds, beans, nuts, legumes, milk, eggs, meat, feathers, and skin. Everything else is a brown because it has very little protein. If you are new to composting, then forget about trying to compost meat, eggs, skin, and milk. Wait until you learn how to make a hot pile without the animal byproducts and then you can get into the more advanced topics.
...See More
Composting sugar
Q
Comments (30)
There are trace minerals and vitamins in honey, but most of the sites that come up on a casual search talk about the possible value for humans, not bees. Since hummingbirds have been introduced to this discussion, I do know that that there is a product called NEKTAR PLUS which is used as a substitute for sugar solution when a complete diet is required for maintaining hummingbirds. A caveat is that hummers also eat insects as well as nectar so a comparison to a bee's diet may not be valid, since the protein source (insects for hummers and pollen for bees) is different. It's an interesting topic and I hope there's some research out there. Anyway, bees in my yard go for sugar water in hummingbird feeders, not just wasps. A few days ago I was watching a hummer at one feeder and as soon as the bird left a bee flew up and tried to feed. The bees much prefer the jam feeder though, when the orioles and catbirds aren't around. My apologies to the OP, but this is an interesting discussion. I learned about the NEKTAR PLUS when I was trying to understand how people could keep a lost hummingbird alive over the winter on sugar water alone. Claire
...See More
What is the difference between Green and Organic?
Q
Comments (39)
ORGANIC: CHEMISTRY: relating or belonging to the class of chemical compounds having a carbon basis; "hydrocarbons are organic compounds" GEOLOGY: being or relating to or derived from or having properties characteristic of living organisms; "organic life"; "organic growth"; "organic remains found in rock" MEDICINE: involving or affecting physiology or bodily organs; "an organic disease" GARDENING: of or relating to foodstuff grown or raised without synthetic fertilizers or pesticides or hormones; "organic eggs"; "organic vegetables"; "organic chicken" CULTURAL: simple and healthful and close to nature; "an organic lifestyle" In gardening, the definition of "synthetic" is pretty stretched (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organic_(food) ) and some truly nasty "natural" compounds can qualify, such as rotenone and 20% acetic acid and copper compounds. READ the labels and the MSDS of these things. "Harmless", "natural" pest controls like Bacillus thuringensis kill butterflies ... if you want butterflies you have to tolerate caterpillars. Also, some of the "certified organic" fertilizers and additives are shipped long distances, and have a big "carbon footprint". ******************* "Green" considers the environmental impact of producing and shipping and disposal of something, and does the minimum necessary to solve a problem: Maine kelp extract, green sand, or Italian dolomite powder might be fabulously organic and OMRI registered, but when shipped to Arizona they are definitely not "green" because of the shipping. The all-natural, locally produced Ironite (mined about 100 miles north of here) is a lot greener. The soil sulfur I use is a byproduct of the copper smelting operations 100 miles east of here (when they cleaned up their emissions, the found out they were collecting substances they could purify and sell for a profit!) My backyard compost is REALLY GREEN because it's converting waste that would be trucked away into fertilizer. It's not strictly organic, because I use small amounts of ammonium sulfate (by product of natural gas production and purification) to boost the nitrogen content, but it's local.
...See More
are "greens" always "greens" and "browns" always "browns"?
Q
Comments (8)
Mary, this is an excellent question and one you shouldn't be embarrassed by :-) The terms 'green' and 'brown' to describe either carbon or nitrogen sources really do describe their coloration as well. Greens - the N source - really are "green"....or very close to it. They are fresh plant parts - grass clippings, debris from the veg garden, plant trimmings, weeds (without seeds), seaweed, fresh leaves, kitchen waste, etc. The non-green greens also include coffee grounds and eggshells (as considered kitchen waste). And fresh animal manures. Browns - the C source - are more "brown" than not: fall leaves, twigs, stems, chipped brush, other wood products, straw or hay, cardboard and other paper products, sawdust, pine straw, etc. IOW, dry or dead material. And yes, some materials can be both, depending on the stage they are in their life cycle. Green, fresh leaves, like might be generated by pruning, are a N source - dried, fallen leaves (dead) gathered up in fall become a prime source of C. It is a little bit more complicated than this - what determines whether a material is really a green or a brown is its ratio of carbon to nitrogen. But in general, most greens are green and fresh and most browns are brown and dried/dead. From th Organic Gardening Forum FAQ:the difference between greens and browns.
...See More

How do I know the difference between GREENS and BROWNS?

Comment

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US