It was an interesting concept that was a bit confusing. I was constantly having to think through each scene so I could wrap my head around what exactly was happening and if you got some of the sequencing wrong, it quickly turned into an creepy story of male public exposure with an innocent young girl.

When I heard it had been made into a movie, I really had my doubts as to how well they would be able to pull it off without total confusion but the film version was in some ways easier to follow.

Jodi-

I read that book last year. It took me a while to get into it, and I almost gave up on it, but I did start to get hooked after a while and then it was easier to read. The time travel/jumping around was tedious to me at first. Henry sure was a complex character.

I enjoyed this book but, as others have said, it could be hard to follow at times. It is not a book you could put down and then pick up a week later. But as far as being a good love story and tear-jerker, I'd give it an A.

I resisted reading it for a long time because it had been so hyped as a book one must read. I gave in, read it and thorougly enjoyed it.

I can't remember if I read it or not but I did see the movie, it was good.

Just could not get into it at all! Never even
made it through the first chapter.

I loved the book. When DH saw the previews for the movie, he said he wanted to see it, which surprised me. I didn't think it was his kind of movie. He loved it, and I always enjoy a movie after I've read the book.

Saw the movie and thought it was silly.

Great book, really enjoyed the fact I had to think about the time travel aspect to really follow the life of Henry. Disliked the movie because it didn't exactly follow the book, tho it did make the daughter Alma more of a major character. Book is a good read. I lost my copy-gave it to a friend who never returned it. That's the second time she's kept a book I recommended.

add my name to Marry's comment.

I loved the book first, then the movie. I might have liked the movie so much because I loved the book.

I read the book about 6 years ago. Loved it. :)

I didn't read the book but saw the movie on TV a few weeks ago and loved it! I recorded the movie for my husband to see later but when it got to the time travel part he promptly fell asleep!

I can see that the book would be rather hard to follow but I thought the movie was great!

Never read the book but watched the movie, it was ok.

I think I'll add, tho I liked the book and bought it, hubby refused to read it. We saw the movie together and neither of us was impressed.The movie left out a lot of the details in the book.

I loved the book!I have always been fascinated by the time travel theme and usually read any book that has time travel as a part of the story!
Joann