Help with hairline crack in granite

10 years ago

We had our polished Princess White counter tops installed about 5 weeks ago. Just now, I noticed a hairline crack in the small portion that is to the side of our range top. It's right at the edge of the pen. (In the photo, the crack runs from left (the bottom) to right (tar part of the counter)) because the orientation of the way the orientation of the photo came out) I can feel it when I run my finger over it and it follow the vein for a good six? inches. The area around the start of the vein near the edge (maybe 1/4 - 1/2" wide) is a little rough too. However, the edge feels smooth so it doesn't seem like a very deep crack. There is also another section in the middle about 2" long where I can feel the vein.

Is this normal, especially for my type of granite which has a lot of veins and crystal-like areas where the stone has visibly been compressed? Or should the entire counter feel smooth? Do I need to ask the stone company to "fix" it? Does it need more sealant and is it at risk of cracking more? I really like this section of the granite as it has a little bit of blue color (not in the photo) which is rare in this stone so I'd rather not replace it.

Any thoughts as to when this crack occurred or if there was an attempted repair? I'm not sure if it is a new crack or if I didn't notice it when it was installed because there was a lot of gunk from the sealant leftover and it took many different scrubs to get it off. Also, we had kept a box and papers on that spot for a while which covered it Ironically, I had been worried about the big L shaped part of the granite but that is fine.

Please advise.

Thank you!

Featured Answer

socalsister

10 years ago

I have this stone in my bathrooms. I took close-up photos of the slabs in the stoneyard. Upon install, I noticed two of these 'cracks' in the counters and backsplash. It turns out that these were in the stone prior to fabrication--I found them in the photos when I magnified the picture! I haven't had any problems but, again, these are bathroom counters, not in the kitchen. I rejected several slabs of this stone due to major cracks that were less visible from the front of the slab but readily so from the back (I made them pull them out so I could see both sides). I was shocked that I ended up with any cracks but couldn't fault the fabricator. My fabricator hated working with this stone by the way. (The counters were installed in 2010.)

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

texaspenny
10 years ago
Maybe it's me, but I can't see the picture.
romy718
10 years ago
I can't see a pic either.
Related Discussions
Hairline crack in porcelain bathroom sink
Q
Comments (4)
OP, Before you replace just the sink, consider the cost of replacing the entire unit. I have a very similar vanity/ top / sink that came from Lowe's and was not terribly expensive ($350). The one that you have isn't in bad shape, but if you wanted to change styles, or if it was otherwise damaged this would be an opportunity to swap it out. BTW: The bowl is probably sealed to the granite with silicone sealant - you will have to cut it from the top after removing the bolts. You don't use plumbers putty on granite. Also, the top is pretty much permanently attached to the base. I was going to take the top off mine when I brought it home to make the installation easier and lighter... I think it was epoxied on to the sink base. I do agree, however, that the sink is probably fine. If the crack gets bigger or leaks, deal with it then. Here is a link that might be useful: Sink and base This post was edited by jakethewonderdog on Wed, Sep 3, 14 at 9:02
...See More
Fiberglass Tub - hairline crack-What to do?
Q
Comments (3)
I'm trying to diagnose a leak from a fiberglass tub area. It's proving challenging because there are multiple spots under the tub that appear wet, yet when you see the inside of the tub, there is no apparent damage. Particularly I see water stains on the outside of the tub about 20 cm below where the tub spout is. The tub spout was not finished flush with the fiberglass, and the caulking has failed. I re-caulked it today. But the drip marks were not immediately around the hole for the spout. The white water stains have drip marks to the ground and the floor under the tub is soaked. But I also notice water actively getting through the tub where the tracking is for the shower door. Just in the one end of the outside of the tub which I have exposed, I saw 2 more wet spots. Does fiberglass sometimes get multiple pinhole leaks and cracks which are hard to see?
...See More
drain of bathtub, caulk problem, hairline crack in sink
Q
Comments (2)
I am sorry not to provide pictures here. It would be another week before I can drive there to take pictures...
...See More
New shaker cabinet panels on appliances have hairline cracks. Help!
Q
Comments (31)
I am hesitant to solve this problem as there is significant possibility this is a small part of a larger quality issue. So first let me talk about what we expect, what we love and what we are surprised by with pictures (note: this is very subjective). What we expect to see in a joint... This is pretty much the standard scope and stick joint for U.S. cabinets. Even incredibly cheap cabinets will use this as it is also very price effective. This is what we can't see but would love on these types of cabinets. this is a haunched tenon and there are other versions that are just as good. It gives more strength than the traditional cope and stick joint. This is what yours looks like and is not what I would consider acceptable for cabinets. I am concerned if cabinets that are going to see any real use are constructed like this. Maybe a curio cabinet with glass inserts type of thing would be fine. However, it could actually be this... this is a rebated mortise and tenon and would be superior to cope and stick. But probably inferior to a haunched tenon, at this point in quality it really doesn't matter. Japanese and thus really Korean joinery is something of legend. Structures built without a drop of glue or nails that have withstood hundreds of years of earthquakes and storms. So it is entirely possible that these cabinets were constructed like that, I would be floored if that were the case and the bill should be very impressive if they were. ---- As to the fix. It is a lever problem on a door where only one side is important. Router and chisel in a small pocket, epoxy in a 1" wide flat corner brace and drink to your victory. This is my take on what I see. Others may see it differently and certainly we are moving out of my wheelhouse, so I will claim no authority. Hope this helps.
...See More
PRO
Granite City Services
10 years ago
I am a fabricator.

your description sounds like a fissure which is common in many types of stone. a good tip off that its not a crack is that it doesn't penetrate into the edge.

its common for people to find features in their stone that are natural and were always there because many stones have a LOT of variation. I've had the tops in my kitchen for years and still occasionally notice a new feature.

I'd recommend asking your fabricator. they get questions like this often and by knowing your stone they can tell you if what you are describing is normal. If you want even more assurance ask them to stop by when in the area and look at the area in question.
CT_Newbie
Original Author
10 years ago
Here's another try at posting the pic. But it is hard to tell from the picture. One needs to feel it.

Thank you Mr. Fabricator. I will ask the fabricator. They are from our old town (25 min away) so not sure when they can stop by. Would they be concerned about any liability and would they give me an honest answer?

Thank you.

Thank you!
User
10 years ago
It's a fissure. It can be injected with a bit of epoxy if you are concerned. But, I wouldn't have any concerns as long as the counter won't be subject to teens hopping on top of it.
CT_Newbie
Original Author
10 years ago
Thank you both! Well one of the contractors was standing on the other side to reach in to get at the vent for the hood. I asked that he use a ladder where possible and mentioned the other thread where someone sat on the counter and it broke.

OK, livewire, I will ask about the epoxy and I do feel better that it is a fissure vs. a crack. I think I will go over every inch of the rest of the counter as long as the stone people might be coming out.

oldryder - I guess this stone is sort of like high heels; a little pain in exchange for beauty :)

Txs again
kompy
10 years ago
agree with LWO...looks like a fissure.
valencia brown
6 years ago
Hi, i just had my granite for one week, and had a backsplash place in the following week, when the tile installer stood on my counter to clean the tile grout. Would this cause a fracture? I noctice a hair line that i could feel with my finger. In the middle of the counter. Is this going to spread ? Or should it be replace.

Boggie
PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
6 years ago
" Would this cause a fracture?"

Not if your granite were properly installed.

" I noctice a hair line that i could feel with my finger. In the middle of the counter. Is this going to spread ?"

It may or may not, but it will certainly become contaminated unless it is fixed.I prefer to finish the break and reglue it.

Help with hairline crack in granite

socalsister

Comments (10)

texaspenny

romy718

Related Discussions

Granite City Services

CT_Newbie
Original Author

User

CT_Newbie
Original Author

kompy

valencia brown

Joseph Corlett, LLC

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Help with hairline crack in granite

Comments (10)

Related Discussions

CT_NewbieOriginal Author

CT_NewbieOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

CT_Newbie
Original Author

CT_Newbie
Original Author