General contractor vs. window company?

14 years ago

I'd like to replace my 35-year old aluminum sliders (and a couple of small picture windows) and patio doors now both because of the federal tax credit and because our HOA will be painting our townhouses next month. I also have termite damage and dry rot around some of the windows (and elsewhere). I'll probably go with Milgard Style Line for the Windows and Milgard Classic for the doors, which the contractor can provide, although I'm also considering Simonton 7300 (since I'd like a narrower frame) from the window company. I've gotten a bid for the windows and doors from the general contractor I hired to replace some of the siding and trim, and I've also gotten a bid from a couple of window companies (with good reputations). The contractor's prices are quite a bit lower for the windows (compared to the other Milgard estimates) and a little better for the doors. I'm wondering, though, whether I'm likely to get better installation from a company that specializes in windows rather than from a general contractor's crew. So far, it seems like the contractor's workers are doing a good job, but removing and replacing siding is different from removing and replacing windows. (P.S. I'll be getting new construction windows since a few windows now leak). What do others think about which kind of company does the installation? If you have any advice on Simonton vs. Milgard, too, I'd appreciate that. Thanks in advance. marilano

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

dennisgli
14 years ago
If your GC has experience installing windows I'd go with them - particularly for new construction windows. Assuming they follow the manufacturer's instructions you should be OK.
lakeyjim
14 years ago
With termites and rot, there is likely some hidden damage that cannot be seen until the windows are taken out. Be prepared for this regardless of who does the work. It would also be foolish of someone to quote you a firm price and then "discover" a whole wall has to be rebuilt. That may be an exaggeration though. I'll go with the GC who is probably more capable of taking care of surprises.

You may want to ask them about this.
Related Discussions
GC vs window company
Q
Comments (5)
The most important rule of thumb for any window replacement is the installation. By hiring someone you know that has already done a great job and earned your trust is ideal. The fact that he specializes in doors & windows is priceless. The extra money you pay for a good trustworthy installer is above & beyond going with an installer you know nothing about. The horror stories from people like yourself who got totally ripped off by paying big money for their best installer, is overwhelming. By having this contractor in advance is 75% of the task. He more than likely has his own supplier that can get you the Bay Unit you want without all the smoke & fire sales techniques used by the local window companies. Stay with the one you trust! I can't emphasize how important this is for any consumer. The extra money you pay is just like buying anything on the market today. You pay more for quality & craftsmanship. I can tell you right now that I'm not the cheapest installer in my neck of the woods, but you can ask any of my customers how their jobs have gone and if I stand behind my work. I've spent a lot of time training and grooming my installation crews to be the best. I seek more money than the others just because I pay my installers more than the others. This way I keep my quality installers happy and working, while offering the customer the best I can. I also offer my customers a 15 year warranty on the installation. This is something you don't see from many of the other installation companies. I can offer higher quality and better services to my customers because I have great trust in my installers. So it does pay to spend a little more money for the Cadillac than you think. Just don't go overboard and pay to much. Good Luck!!!
...See More
Window pricing - homeowner vs. contractor??
Q
Comments (3)
As to the question "Do contractors receive significantly better pricing than the general public" the answer is yes and no. It depends on the dealer. Some have a 10-30% difference in price and some don't differentiate between contractors and homeowners. Some contractors (more often the higher end ones) like to deal with suppliers that will give wholesale prices to contractors only. In contrast the big box stores like Lowes and Menards will have close to the same pricing for everyone (where the higher end contractors may not frequent). If you're building a home however and GC'ing it yourself many will give you wholesale pricing. After all, you're not buying one or two windows, but a whole housefull. And since you're building instead of doing window replacements, it's a nice clean transaction with no measuring (and liability) needed, since you're working off of a set of plans or a window schedule.
...See More
HELP me interview a General Contractor
Q
Comments (12)
I agree it is more about how you will interact during the job. Will he keep you informed or progress/budget? Is he confrontational or mellow when problems arise. Ask him about his procedures for the job...like what is he going to do to protect the other parts of the house during construction. Things like that to see if they have a plan or if they are by the seat of their pants type. Most contractors can hire electricians and other subs to get a project completed but it mostly comes down to communication. Our company- for a kitchen remodel or a house construction- sends out an email daily to summarize what has or has not happened that day and what is going to happen tomorrow along with a list of things the clients need to finalize so the project can move along. They know where the project stands budget and progress wise everyday so there are no surprises. Travis Alfrey Aberdeen NC
...See More
Frustration with General Contractor (GC) /Industry Obfuscation
Q
Comments (69)
We have signed a contract - with a different remodeler and it's in budget! We're so excited. The GC we were so frustrated with did lower his proposal, but was still $14K over budget. In the end, we feel that we are not his target customer and that's okay. We have found a GC that fits us and we are moving forward. We have a rough estimate of when work will start and will have a more exact date once he has a chance to plug us into their system. He expects they'll start work the end of October or the beginning of November. Monday we meet with our cabinets guy to go over things one last time before placing the order. We called and secured our granite today and then I had to swing by to ogle it and touch it. LOL I also started looking for alternative backsplash tile options, because the glass tile we picked out before is ridiculously expensive it turns out. I've found a good alternative that is $8.99 sq. ft compared to what The Tile Shop estimates the other one ran at $35.00/sq ft. We love that the GC we are going with will tell us that Option A costs $x more than Option B. That's the information we need so we can do our part to keep things in budget.
...See More
jdavis_2009
14 years ago
The two windows you are looking at are at the low end quality and the high end quality of vinyl windows. Milgard Styleline are low end windows. Milgard Styleline has a lifetime warranty but no glass breakage. Simonton on the other is considered a high end vinyl window. The price difference for each window is probably over $100. Most window companies deal with better quality windows while most contractors are pushing the Milgard low end line to make more money. Window companies seem to have their own installers who specialize in windows where contractors might have experience but might not. Since the contractor is probably trying to do windows because business is down you might want to ask yourself why he is trying to do windows?

If you want to go with Milgard get the Milgard Tuscany so you can have the glass breakage warranty and a better quality window. Another window to look at is Superior Ultima or Superior Deluxe. Both are good windows and have a glass breakage warranty.
johnallenmd4
14 years ago
I am shopping for windows and am looking for a window company to install my windows. I had a contract install my windows on my rental property and it turned out terrible. I called out Milgard to fix a window that wasn't closing correctly and the Milgard service tech told me I didn't have then installed correctly so no warranty. I got another Milgard dealer to look at the installation and they agreed with Milgard. I paid twice for my windows to get done correctly. The contractor didn't read the Milgard installation process on their website. He cut corners and now he won't come out and fix it. Since he only gave me a one year warranty on installation there isn't anything I can do about it. The contract did have great referals and had a clean BBB until I made a complaint. I am going with a certified window dealer of the window brand I choose for my own home.

General contractor vs. window company?

Comments (4)

dennisgli

lakeyjim

Related Discussions

jdavis_2009

johnallenmd4

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US