I have Brookhaven and would get them again (love the framelss). I got them because they were one of the few available in frameless that we could find at the time, the finish was finer than most, the value was good, we could mix with Woodmode cabinets and features and in all my searching, I didn't find any significant problems or complaints with Brookhaven.

I'm not clear if the Kitchen Craft are also frameless or framed. If they are framed, there may be a visual difference and you may prefer one over the other. If you have framed cabinets with a full overlay, they will look similar. Framed will also have part of the cabinet box covered by the frame -- similar to the way a photo will have an edge covered by the mat or frame. That can make it more difficult to access your cabinet space or use it fully -- and it in my old cabinets, it made a huge difference in the drawers I had. Going with frameless cabinets really helped get better use of our space, which was important since we could not change the footprint. If the Kitchen Kraft are framed, I'd definitely go with Brookhaven.

Oh, Brookhaven has 13" deep uppers standard -- and that can be just enough difference to get larger plates or bowls, one more row of glasses, etc in your cabinets.

Thank you so much!!!

I believe Kitchen Craft is also farmless as well.

Also wondering which one holds up well, since I have 2 young kids (greasy and dirty little hands) and want a white kitchen ... and we live in the kitchen ... I really need the cabinets hold up well ...

Thank you again.

We have Kitchen Craft frameless Cherry Marquis. They are 10 years old. They have done well over the years - finish on the cherry is still nice. On the frameless cabinets, the face of the cabinet (covers up the particle board edge) is a PVC matched tape. Color matches well when first installed. Cherry gets darker over time - PVC tape does not. After 10 years, you can now see a "blonde" line where the face frames show (1/16" of an inch). I have tried to gel stain it - and the PVC does not take a stain at all. Next step would be to paint all the edges. We ordered a 4x8 piece of cherry to use as the wainscot for our peninsula. The finish on that piece was not the same quality finish as on the cabinets. We just lived with it - but it always bugged me when I walked by. Finally, the melmanine coating on the bottom of the drawers has bubbled over time (in the drawer where we put our pots and pans). They sometimes get put away while still slightly damp - I'm sure the water caused the bubbling.

Hope this gives you some things to think about and ask the sales people about. All the best!