Orange peel ceiling finish?

10 years ago

We're having the popcorn removed and the ceilings re-skimmed. One contractor told me that they put some sort of texture on it. Like very light or heavier orange peel, what ever I choose. (Some people have it match the walls). I told him that even though the walls are orange peel, I want a really smooth ceiling.

Our house was built in the late 70's, and it's not asbestos. But, it could well be a problem that the ceiling itself was rushed and not done right due to the blown in finish.
Am I being ridiculous here? I'm thinking you won't even be able to tell from the floor looking up much? I'm sure that even a light orange peel will look loads better than the nasty popcorn, and we can paint them. I'm just not sure.
Any thoughts are appreciated! Thanks
Mary

Featured Answer

southernstitcher
Original Author

10 years ago

I just wanted to report back that the orange peel was a money saver, and looks great. We went with a very light spray, and because of that, had to do primer, and 3 coats of paint. Was DEFINITELY worth it!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

User
10 years ago
Flat ceilings take much more labor than sprayed/textured ceilings.

So do walls. Most people have no idea there are at least three(and sometimes four)finish schedules for drywall finishing.

One is one coat/sanding of mud---seen mostly in garages. And on some textured ceilings.

Two is two coats/sanding of mud---usually on walls.

Three is the minimum schedule for painting with anything other than flat paint---three coats and sanding of mud. This makes the seams much less visible and decreases the waves in a wall/ceiling surface.

Four is four(or more) coats, and is done for walls that will be painted in gloss paint or other high finish materials(Glazes/etc),

As usual, the price---as does the time needed--- increases with the number of coats/sandings.

Popcorn could be applied immediately after sanding and cut contractor time to completion.
southernstitcher
Original Author
10 years ago
Well that might explain why this contractor's price for doing this was much lower than the other guy. He's spraying something up there, and I am just not sure how I'll like it. I've seen the google images, and my walls are orange peel, so I know what it will look like. I just would prefer smooth.
My kitchen ceiling and walls, which were done previously by another contractor who is now out of business, was really a great job, very smooth. I don't remember what he charged.

So I'm now wondering if orange peel walls done as fine as they can get it will look good. Most new construction I see is perfectly smooth. But, if there are inconsistencies in our ceiling, then I guess I'd better play it safe with the orange peel?

Thanks for the input.

This post was edited by southernstitcher on Thu, Jul 25, 13 at 0:13
Related Discussions
help!! wb satin impervo orange peel?
Q
Comments (4)
Foam rollers are crater makers. Fine for getting paint up but you need to quickly follow with a high quality brush to tip off. Test your skills first on the inside of a closet door to get the hang of it. In the meantime, let your cabinet doors dry a few days to harden up, then lightly sand them to smooth out the orange peel. Try the WBSI again - do one door and be sure you get the desired result, then do the rest.
...See More
Is orange peel wall texture 'dated'?
Q
Comments (13)
Granted, smooth walls are very hard to do well, and every little nick or wave in the drywall shows. But when done well, and painted well, it's pretty amazing. And it makes the room look bigger because you lose a visual sense of where the wall actually is, especially if you use a flat finish. I just got so tired of 11 years of that knock-down collecting so much dust and dirt. Another alternative is that with each successive painting of your textured walls, the pattern disappears as the paint builds up. When we bought our house, I immediately painted the bedrooms and noticed a huge difference, especially since I used 2 coats. I didn't do the common areas, and you could see the ridges and plateaus much more easily. To each his/her own.
...See More
Urgent feedback requested - Orange peel vs Level 4
Q
Comments (1)
Well, I'm not a pro but I've been hanging out in these forums for a few years. The consensus is smooth finish is preferable in nearly all situations. Not sure on the 6k. But it is more difficult for the drywallers.
...See More
knockdown, orange peel or smooth?
Q
Comments (1)
Smooth texture is always the way to go! I would recommend using a highly recommended drywall guy if you are going to consider moving forward with the texture of the walls. You could always consider squaring off the corners of the walls or changing your baseboards, casing and crown to a more modern squared off style but saving you on the bucks.
...See More
heavydaiper
10 years ago
The orange peel will hide imperfections much better but if you have to do any repairs in the future (I.e. drywall patch) trying to get the repaired drywall texture to match will be a pain. I'd go smooth all the way.
annzgw
10 years ago
When it comes to repairs, I've found making repairs easier on a wall that has a texture than one that is smooth. As shown above, with a spray can and a little practice one can achieve the same texture as the original.
sammyegail
10 years ago
When we were house shopping I saw one that had orange peel walls and ceilings. (built maybe 2004). I didn't like it, I felt like I was in some sort of dome because it was exactly the same. But thats my opinion. It didn't help that the walls and ceiling were the same color, off-white. The living area had crown molding, it helped break it up a bit, if that makes sense. I think if you have orange peel on your walls and ceiling, if you put crown molding up, keep the ceilings (flat based) white and have some color to your walls, it would look really nice. If you could get a 'finer' orange peel on your ceiling that would be even better. Its also how much money you want to put into it. Smooth ceilings will cost so much more. Would you want to do crown molding? I'm guessing orange peel ceilings and crown molding could cost significantly less than smooth ceilings : ).
southernstitcher
Original Author
10 years ago
Well two of the rooms will have crown. We are just going to go with the orange peel, as fine as they can do it, flat white ceiling. It would cost over $2,000 to do just the MBR ceiling, paint it, walls, and trim. We can't afford that! Thanks so much for the input.