Room Swap - What would you do? (pics)

14 years ago

I have been cycling back and forth on how and if to swap rooms around in my upstairs. I have a small, older house so there's no concept of a master BR.. I have two larger bedrooms and one very small but cozy room. The nieces and nephews who spend the most time here have asked for a larger guest room.. I am considering it because when more than 2 of them are here or when they have the neighbor kids over (neither of which is uncommon), they really have limited space. If I gave them a bigger room, I would use it as my art room and probably a yoga/pilates room as well. I need the third room for a fully functional office (I work from home 90% of the time).

Currently my bedroom is in the largest of the three rooms. It has two closets-- one is a decent size if you use the depth-- the other is a "walk in closet" of sorts made in one of the dormers. It is narrow but it does store a lot. This room needs to have walls done (wallpaper removed/painted).. it also faces a pretty busy street. The sound doesn't bother/affect me but lights from snow plows in winter and cops in summer do bother me. The picture is crappy but it is app 22 x 12.

The room that is currently my office is the big unknown. It could remain my office, I could put the guest room in there-- or I could move my bedroom. I think it's a lovely room. It has good energy, gets good sunlight and overlooks the garden/backyard. I do love it.. however it has only one small closet which would never hold all my clothes. I have two large hall closets-- one of which is cedar lined so if I was willing and smart about it, I could put off season or rarely used clothes in the other closets. It is smaller but there is plenty of room for any of my possible uses.

This is currently the guest/kids' room. It is also a nice space and very cozy. It has some odd angles and it's hard to get a good picture of it. I currently have a bureau, a queen size bed, a small bookshelf and a tv/dvd/playstation on a stand in there. It's pretty full. If I made this my office, it would hold a 30" x 60" table.. a small bookshelf, file cabinets and other occasional pieces as space allows. I'd have to give up my loungey chair, I think.

(all pictures were taken while PO was still there.. none of the furnishings are mine.. floors have been buffed)

So what would YOU do? What space would you claim as your own? I feel like I've lost all objectivity. Would you consider spreading your clothes between a bedroom and hall closet? I need to commit to a decision by the end of the weekend.. and every time I make a decision, I feel a pull for the other room. All I know is that I need a comfortable, relaxing space... and I need it before my furniture starts arriving.

And just to round out the view of the upstairs.. this is a full bath..

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

les917
14 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
A charming home!

I would make the largest room into a guest room/pilates/art room.

Use the second bedroom you described so lovingly as your office. If you work from home so much, you should be working in a wonderful space. This sounds like it, with a view to the backyard, great light, etc. Those things, while nice, don't really matter in a bedroom, since most of the time you are there at night, to sleep. That way you can keep your lounge chair in the office, too.

Then use the current guest room as your bedroom. If it holds a queen-sized bed and some other furniture, and has a closet, you should be fine. You will have to split your clothes out, but you would have to do that anyway. Just curious. Is there any way that one of the hall closets backs up to this room, so that you could access it from the bedroom? You could then eventually close off the hall access.
no_green_thumb
14 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Lovely home --- I love the "old" feeling and I mean that in a very good way. I would love to have a home with true character!!
I agree with Les. Your office should be in the space that gives you the most peace. My office is in part of my living room (which never, ever is used) and I love it as it overlooks the backyard (not looking great now).
I have my clothes in two closets and like it that way. Now that the kids are gone, I have all of my off-season clothes as well as my more formal clothes (not that I have many) in the other closet. The closet in the bedroom holds what I wear the most during the season. Uncluttered!! Love it!!
Related Discussions
Swap What are you bringing? What do you want?
Q
Comments (150)
Amserelda: I'd like some hens and chicks, please, to add to my collection. I'm not picky -- anything will do! Serpent Moon and I appreciate the Crown of Thorns cuttings -- she has already requested it for us. Would you like a cutting of Euphorbia trigona? Skybird: We already have some sedums from you, from the fall swap. I'm not sure what Serpent Moon has requested, but I'm fine with you giving some of them to others who request them. ---------- The tomatoes I planted a few weeks ago are still sprouting. I take back whatever I said about the potentially low germination of the Costoluto Fiorentino tomato seeds. Even though I saved the seeds over a decade ago, they are still in good shape. I have 3-4 seedlings per pot, of the 3-4 seeds planted per pot. If you are careful, you might be able to separate out the seedlings and pot them up separately. I don't think any have their first set of true leaves yet. If anyone wants seeds for them, please let me know and I'll package up some for you. Ditto for the seeds from the cherry tomatoes I grew last year from Plant Swap plants -- Black Cherry, Sun Cherry, and Riesentraub. All seem to be germinating well this spring. Costoluto Fiorentino looks a lot like Costoluto Genovese, for those who are wondering. It's a medium to large sized tomato with lots of ribs, rather like an accordion. They're a booger to peel if you're making sauce. The flavor is quite reasonable, and they grew well in my Oregon garden (coolish dry summers, fairly short season). The original seed came from Sementi, a gift from a friend who had visited Italy. I'll go through the thread this evening to write down names of people who've requested specific things. I'll make coleus and geranium cuttings tomorrow, plus maybe a few Euphorbia trigona cuttings in case anyone wants a thorny but vigorous succulent as a houseplant. I'm looking forward to seeing everyone!
...See More
What would you do? Please vote! Pic...
Q
Comments (21)
I would do as roseabbey suggested. That way you have the option of closing them on days you want the room dark. I don't like light in the room when I have a migrane, I'm sick, I want to sleep in, or when my GD wants to take a nap! Always think ahead of how you may want to use the room. If you're going to be able to close your drapes, then forget what I just wrote!
...See More
What would you do to change this room?? (pic included)
Q
Comments (28)
Very cute room. I found this forum very recently and love reading all the posts, so I will finally stop lurking and add my 2 cents. I know others have talked about the frames, but I don't think there are necessarily too many, I think part of what bothered me with the frames on the shelves was simply placement. The way they were arranged it is too symmetrical for my taste. I like to see more staggering of items. I currently feel there is a visual line drawn through the center of the shelves vertically. Also understanding the constraints of a budget all too well-- if the new mantel is too expensive for right now what if you remove the small white shelf below the mirror and paint out the top part of the fireplace surround, not sure how to refer to that part, but the area that creates a horizontal edge directly below that white shelf. I persoally like the green vase, but only if it is empty so it has a more contemporary "pottery" like feel to it. I think if you want a "vase" it is not the best. I like it empty off to the left of the mirror, but if you remove the shelf and do not add a mantel I assume the vase will not sit on that edge? I would definitely raise the curtain rod several inches to give the illusion of a more dramatic window. I was also wondering about switching the sofa to the wall below the window--does it fit? I just think it will soften the bottom of that window to have the sofa there, just move the chair to where the sofa was. I would think that it would be more comfortable to watch tv that way as well as you wouldn't be turned at the direct 90 degree angle you are currenty when seated on the sofa. I would then like to see a small table of some sort between the chair and the fireplace wall (under the wall opening) and then move the floor lamp over to the side of the chair closest to the kitchen. (so that pass through side would start with the lamp, then the chair, then a table. ) The table would be a great spot for a few more of those family photos. OK those are my thoughts, but keep in mind I always move my furniture 16 times before I decide what I like.
...See More
What would you do with our kitchen? Pic included
Q
Comments (8)
I agree about living in a space for a while to figure out it's quirks, how you use it and how you like to store your stuff. I wanted to tear into this latest house when we moved in, but a loss of my remodel money in a stock market account forced me to wait 2 years. Yes, I hated the kitchen everyday, but I was able to pinpoint exactly WHY I hated it, like the only oven in a blind entry, no place under the counter for trash, narrow passage between pantry and peninsula that created a bottleneck in the traffic flow. Well, I know this isn't about me, but you get the idea. The list gets pretty long when you have time to really think about things. Is your "front" room going to be your main hang out with the den as an office? Or is it just a sitting room with the den as a TV area? How do you THINK you're going to use the space? Hmmm, the toilet thing is bothering me. I've got kids who almost never shut the door, so if it were my house, neighbors, UPS guy, whoever would get an eyeful LOL! Is there space on either side of the toilet where it can be turned? How about a wall where a doorway could be opened to the den? A top view floorplan would help. Or pictures from all the entries. Do you really want to trudge up and down the basement stairs with heavy baskets of clothes? An uninterupted lenth of counter top makes a great folding table. If you've got kids watching TV in the den, you're right there. Is the house a single story or two story with a basement? If it were my space, I'd keep the laundry there and get front loading stackable w/d. I'm not too sure about the back door though. Will it be used as the primary entry from the garage/parking? Does the Den door have better access? Maybe this one could be walled off. Or if it's the better entry, maybe stack the units and create a coat rack/shoe storage. I kind of like the range in that location as your main traffic looks like it is now on the right side, a continuation of the hall to the den to the dining area and front room. If you close off the back entry, that will limit traffic too, out of the main cooking zone. Most people work left to right, so food gathered from fridge, placed on an island or cleaned/prepped at the sink, then move to the range to cook. I'd center the range on that 67" wall. A 30" range centered would give you 18" of countertop left to right. Or a 36" range with 15". It's a little tigher, but still doable. That's mainly a personal thing, I'm not a fan of cooktops/ranges in the island, I love having A LOT of prep counter. I'm not sure the range would work in the old fridge space. It looks a bit tight, maybe only 48" or so? How about budget? To be honest, just about anything can be accomplished with a well padded budget, but for the rest of us... well, concessions have to be made. How about inspiration pics? What's the style or look you're going for? Here's some from my personal inspiration file. A LOT of white kitchens ; ). Here's one with a mudroom or similar next to the range. Here's one on a slightly larger scale. You don't have an issue with supports, but the walk ways are similar. Note the prep sink in the island and the fridge and pantry on the right. Here's one with the cooktop in the island and fridge on the wall. Here's one where the opening to the dining room is centered and they've added returns on each side. No island. Here's another one.
...See More
valzone5
14 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
I have no suggestions- just wanted to say that I LOVE your home!!!!
oceanna
14 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
What a pretty home you have!

What I thought of was the queen bed taking up a lot of space. I don't know the age of the kids and exact situation but maybe bunk beds, and even with a trundle might give them a lot more space for play?
kitchenkelly
14 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
I love your house. Especially that door. I have been thinking of getting one for my garage. What are they called?

(I call it the Mr. Ed door. Google didn't get it.)
funkyart
Original Author
14 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Thank you all.. and funny, I consider this a "newish" house. It is definitely newer than the majority of homes I've lived in. I am still getting used to the small space (and close neighbors) but it has charm :)

I really appreciate your suggestion to use the "happy space" for my office. That is what I was thinking when I originally set up the office in there. Unfortunately, the small bedroom is not nearly big enough for my bedroom.. or bunk beds. It is an over the garage room and it has sharp angles that what can go on each wall. It has one longer wall that would accomodate my table/desk. I have a queen size bed without a headboard under one of the eaves now. Truth is an adult wouldn't likely be comfortable sleeping there under the wall... it is ok for the younger kids though. I usually give up my bed when the older kids sleep here.

What I should probably share too (because I know it sounds odd that I am working around nieces and nephews). I moved back to my hometown so that I could spend more time with the kids, my parents and my grandparents. My oldest nephew goes to college this year-- and I've lived out of state for many years. I am very different than my siblings and I think it is important that kids are influenced by lots of kinds of people-- even my kind hahah. We watch movies.. and draw.. and paint.. and talk about silly things and serious things.. and it is good for all of us. Keeps me young and them well rounded. I feel good about helping to shape young lives.

Thank you all for your thoughts.. and for the compliments. My home is so much more modest than many of yours but it does have its charms... and it's home!
funkyart
Original Author
14 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Kitchenkelly: hahahah it IS a Mr Ed door! (I think it is also called a dutch door.)
gk5040
14 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
I would take the biggest room with the closets for myself. I like all my things in my room. Afterall, its your house, you should feel like its your home and your room. You mentioned the lights could bother you, well, there are plenty of black out shades/curtains you can use to solve that problem. I think it is very thoughtful of you to give so much consideration to your occassional house guests. I would give them the second largest room. And the smaller room as the office. I like the Mr. Ed door too.
funkyart
Original Author
14 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
I appreciate your thoughts-- you have me thinking a little bit out of the box which is what I needed to do. Furniture placement is my weakness.. so I think I am going to try a few different floor plans on paper and see how it unfolds.

I really like the idea of making the kids room multifunctional so that it is a "me space" too. Right now the little room is kept closed unless the kids are here. Using a bigger room will let me use the space for painting, crafts, and light exercise (meaning sans equipment). I had hesitated to put MY stuff in the kids room-- but they are getting older and more responsible and frankly the space is wasted when they are not here.

Thanks again.. it really helps to get feedback from new eyes and new perspectives.

Room Swap - What would you do? (pics)

Comments (9)

les917

no_green_thumb

Related Discussions

valzone5

oceanna

kitchenkelly

funkyart
Original Author

funkyart
Original Author

gk5040

funkyart
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Room Swap - What would you do? (pics)

Comments (9)

les917

no_green_thumb

Related Discussions

valzone5

oceanna

kitchenkelly

funkyartOriginal Author

funkyartOriginal Author

gk5040

funkyartOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

funkyart
Original Author

funkyart
Original Author

funkyart
Original Author