A Magic Eraser taken to any paint film is going to remove some of the final finish. Magic Erasers are good for lots of things but should never be used on a painted wall IMO. When light hits the scrubbed spot just right, you can see how the Magic Eraser left an uneven finish behind. SuperPaint is honestly one of the best values on the paint market today. Value meaning you get a lot of good stuff in the can for what you pay. Including a perfectly lovely final finish/result. Especially if you hit it on a sale or have coupons. But Super Paint is not a top tier can of paint. The more upper tier, better grade of paint you go, the more durable. Usually. In general people take the notion of "scrubbable" too far with all tiers of paint. Better grades are going to be tougher, but they have limits. You can only clean within reason. There is a breakeven point where you have to objectively look at the ding or scuff and determine it needs to be touched-up, not scrubbed.

yikes. I just came across this after having an issue with Sherwin WIlliams Duration Interior in Matte. I purchased mine Fall 2020 and painted one room and I'm usually not bothered by paint smell, but I got lightheaded pretty quickly and donned a respirator. It took a solid month for the smells on the walls to dissipate. I used the same paint, but in another can for a second room. I painted that in May 2021. It is November 2021 and my room still smells and has been unlivable. I'm not sure if it was a bad batch or what– but I tried VOC Charcoal air purifiers, charcoal in bags, plants, vinegar, baking soda, washing the walls with Dawn, and enzyme odor eaters, candles, "cooking" the room with a space heater, lemon-water, carpet cleaning, etc. Nothing– it still smells. It's like I opened the can and never shut it. You can sit in there for 2 hours and will be light headed! I have had it sealed off with the window open for 6 mos! The other room seems OK however, but when I called SW they said, "Oh, wow, this has never happened before!" I went into SW and they said I needed a sales rep to come out and see it (or smell it). No one has called, stopped by or anything. I have repainted that room w/ one coat with Zissner BIN to seal the smell in but I need a second coat bc the smell is that bad. Zissner BIN smells better than SW! I will never buy from SW ever again, esp for the price. I had Benjamin Moore for the rest of the house and no issues. I have been painting for 25 years and never had this problem before.

catkin - after the raw wood is primed, I'd put in a vote for SW Pro-Classic waterborne in a satin finish. Cashmere is a unique finish - it is not the toughest stuff around. Its final finish is luxe i.e. the Cashmere name. Most all of the SW products are DIY skillset friendly IMO. Duration, however, can be a challenge but anything that goes on at such a thick film, or mils, rate it's no surprise. You 'apply' Duration more so than 'paint' with it. If that makes any sense. SW vs. BenM -- it's all about matching the right product from each brand to the project and painter. Success and failures happen with each brand. Duration's gloss levels are shinier than general industry average. The matte is PLENTY shiny for me and just one or two more degrees of gloss and it would be too shiny IMO. The satin is equivalent to some semi-glosses if ya ask me. There are no industry standards for gloss levels. Every store should have samples so you can see and touch and evaluate -- be sure to ask to see them if they are not on display. It does make it difficult sometimes. Duration is a good example. Some people have very strong feelings about dead flat finishes. It does not meet their personal tolerances and in extreme cases it's been described to me as 'making my teeth hurt'. So, when I spec Duration Matte for one of those extreme tolerance cases, there's always a discussion about how it's not flat and shinier than you might think. Managing and spec'ing gloss levels is almost as much work as spec'ing color.

Their Pro Mar paint 300 is very good. It's what the builders use, but having used it for 12 years, I will continue to use it. It's not on display and you have to ask for it. One of the counters guys told me it was the same thing as the HGTV paint line. Anyway, I called a while back and the HGTV paint will be about 20 a gallon.