skip to main content

Moen shower valve-- concerns about fit

mabeldingeldine_gw

11 years ago

Cross-posted from Bathrooms Forum

I was all set to order a Moen 3330 3-way transfer valve for my shower. I am want a valve that will allow a tub spout, handshower and fixed shower and this seemed to fit the ticket. When looking at it this valve on faucetdirect, it got some bad reviews saying the valves were designed in such a way the valve trim did not fit correctly.

I have done some plumbing and feel like replacing a shower valve should be within my capacity, but now I'm getting nervous. This is our only shower so if things don't go well it makes life even more miserable for us.

Does anyone have any experience with this or advice for me? Should I look for a different brand? I'm not married to the trim or brand by any means.

Thanks for any help or advice you can give. There are two of us on the forum considering this valve and we both would appreciate your insights.

Here is a link that might be useful: Bathrooms forum

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

doug_gb
11 years ago
I looked at the blog - it seems that the installation instructions are poor/incorrect - not the valve.

However I have an opinion as an engineer and long time DIY'er. I have direct experience with Moen and Price Fister faucets that have turned out to be junk. These products may have been good 50 years ago - but not today.

Over the years I've remodeled our entire home and I've used Grohe. We have a Grohe faucet that has worked flawlessly for 18 years - never replaced a single part!

I recently remodeled the down stairs bathroom - I used Grohe mixing valve / shut off. It was $600.

Now I know just because it's expensive doesn't mean it's better quality - but think about it - how can Moen offer a valve the performs a similar function for $159?

I think $159 is too cheap, and you get what you pay for.
kirkhall
11 years ago
I'm hoping to hear from someone who has installed this valve and trim. It seems fairly popular on the site, but the bad reviews make me hesitant.
Any plumbers here with info?
0
Related Discussions
concern about fridge fitting in doorway
Q
Comments (2)
Marlene501, my 33" wide refrigerator from LG with the water on the door and the ice in the freezer would not fit through my sliding door either. The delivery men took the door off and reinstalled the door so it was not a problem. I wanted the 36" LG with no water on the door but a friend didn't think it would have fit the opening in my kitchen but he was wrong since I have 3 extra inches on the side and that upsets me since I did not want water on the door being that I prefer the clean look of a door with nothing on it. I should have trusted my own measurements. But the door comes off and can be installed back on again so you have no worries. I had to hire a plumber since I had no water line and now I have to keep buying filters for my refrigerator but I do love the French Door refrigerator so much. I love having a bottom freezer where I can reach everything since I am not quite 5 feet. I love not having to move a kitchen chair out of the way to open the refrigerator door. By the way, my little dogs get the filtered water for their water dishes now and I use the filtered water for my coffee in the morning. But I still drink Poland Spring Bottled water all day. My dogs and coffee used to use the bottled water also. Hope this helps you.
...See More
Shower/Tub Stop Valve Problem...Moen...Suggestions?
Q
Comments (8)
While the wood they used was "too close to the wall", that doesn't mean it should have been addressed while the wall was open (they know this, too). Just tell them you need it like it's supposed to be, and then they will find the best way to deal with it, given that they know/where the pipe was secured in the wall. But to answer your question, there's a good possibility that, after opening the wall they can just unscrew the clamps (that hold the pipe to the wood), then simply pull it all a bit further in (there will be some play in the pipe & diverter), and then clamp it to the wood in the new position. A piece of wood in the wall might have to be moved a bit to do this, depending on how it was connected, but it can be done. Again, they do understand that it's an issue even if they may not necessarily indicate so.
...See More
removing older-style Moen shower mixer handle cover plate
Q
Comments (4)
Tiled shower stall is leaking at the bottom (or course). There are openings where the cover plate meets the tiled wall and the shower water may be entering through these crevasses. Should I be placing silicone sealer around the edge of the cover plate, or is it necessary to remove the plate and look for some kind of damaged gasket under it? When it was originally installed by the professional plumbers there was no silicon sealer used. Advice will certainly be appreciated.
...See More
Best shower valve to replace single handle Moen Posi-Temp?
Q
Comments (32)
Hi, There is a shower repair plate you may want to think about. We called them Stainless steel Smitty plates. a skilled plumber can cut a hole in the shower a little smaller than the Smitty plate. He then cuts out the old valve, solder in the new valve ,mount the smitty plate, install the valve trim over the smitty plate. Done. Good Luck Woodbutcher
...See More
mabeldingeldine_gw
Original Author
11 years ago
I appreciate that quality components come at a price, but surely their is something in between $150 and $600 that will be satisfactory. It is a shower, not a piece of surgical equipment.

The Moen valve was highly recommended to me by the largest plumbing supplier/plumbing service in my geographic area. They do not offer any Grohe products.

I'd love to hear some more thoughts on this.
0
doug_gb
11 years ago
@kirkhall and @mabel: The deal is that the 'run of the mill plumber' who doesn't read, who throws away the installation instructions, who doesn't think about the thickness of the cement board and tile, will quite possibly screw up this installion. That's what I've gleaned from the other blog posts.

Now a thoughtful plumber will install it correctly.

But I have to back up to my original statement that you get what you pay for. 40 years ago - these valves were $100. Now they're $150. Something got to give.

After a month, the porclain on the shower handles cracked. Both the bath sink and the shower handles come loose all the time. I added lock washers - still come loose, Price Fister has sent me multiple ceramic cartridges - normally these should never wear out.

The Monen single hanldle sink - after a year need a new cartridge, then the faucet was hard to turn - new O rings - then the side spray didn't work - needed new diverter - the POS never worked correctly after the first year.

The plumbing suppier doesn't give a rat's a** about your fauct, they want what's easy for them.

Just the fact that they don't offer any Grohe products shows that they aren't serious.

I'm not saying Grohe is the best, but IMO you are being steered to the low quality, crap product - cause that's what they want to sell.
0

Related Stories

KITCHEN SINKS Everything You Need to Know About Farmhouse Sinks

By Anne Ellard Design

They’re charming, homey, durable, elegant, functional and nostalgic. Those are just a few of the reasons they’re so popular

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING 28 Outdoor Projects Everyone Should Know About

By Mitchell Parker

Learn how to refinish your wood deck, make a garden fountain, add a shed and more

BUDGETING YOUR PROJECT Construction Contracts: What to Know About Estimates vs. Bids

By Ventana Construction LLC

Understanding how contractors bill for services can help you keep costs down and your project on track

MOST POPULAR 19 Kitchen Projects Every Homeowner Should Know About

By Mitchell Parker

Could your kitchen use a new sink, a backsplash, updated hardware, better organization, a good cleaning? Here's how to get started

REMODELING GUIDES What to Know About Budgeting for Your Home Remodel

By Incite Design

Plan early and be realistic to pull off a home construction project smoothly

COMMUNITY Community Building Just About Anyone Can Do

By Vanessa Brunner

Strengthen neighborhoods and pride of place by setting up more public spaces — even small, temporary ones can make a big difference

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen of the Week: Making Over a Rental for About $1,500

By Becky Harris

Fresh paint, new hardware, added storage, rugs and unexpected touches breathe new life into a Los Angeles apartment’s kitchen

EXTERIORS Great Design Element Our Grandparents Knew All About: Awnings

By Becky Harris

This time-tested feature for shading and cooling is enjoying a resurgence

BATHROOM DESIGN Convert Your Tub Space to a Shower — the Fixtures-Shopping Phase

By By Any Design Ltd.

Step 2 in swapping your tub for a sleek new shower: Determine your mechanical needs and buy quality fixtures

HOUZZ TOURS Discover a Hobbit House Fit for Bilbo Baggins

Part art studio, part guesthouse and all charm, this imaginative Colorado cottage looks like it grew right out of the earth

Sponsored

NME Builders LLC

2 Reviews

Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, OH

More Discussions

Why don't more people have Farmhouse sinks in the Bathrooms?

43

Brizo Matte White has changed

3

wall mount faucet for this freestanding tub

0

Which wall-hung toilet model actually works well?

1

1961 apartment gas pipe challenge

3