We selected Thomasville "Eden" in cherry stained in briarwood. We are VERY happy with them so far. They are installed as of last week, just need to be trimmed out. No, we did not install them ourselves. We used the installer from Home Depot. When we met him prior to signing the agreement, we liked him so much that we ended up asking him to be the GC on our entire project.

Everything has run relatively smooth, with only a few minor glitches. The cabinets themselves seem to be good quality and we have not found anything (yet) that disappoints us about them. We went with most of the "bells and whistles" including soft close, full extension drawers, slide out shelves, lots of trim molding, 6 columns, and the side door things at the ends of every run. We paid $18,500 for them - and got in on the 10% off deal at Home Depot in addition to the free base cabinet with silverware separator from Thomasville. (the other option was a free SS sink, but we'd already decided on Blanco Silgranit). So in answer to your question, YES, I found them to be "reasonable" considering the sale & freebie, compared to other cabinet shops I tried dealing with.

I am going to try to get updated pics today to post on my RMS space and when I do, I'll repost it on here for you to get a closer look.

Another thing - we LOVE our KD from Home Depot. She's gone above and beyone and we've struck a friendship up besides the business end.

Hope that answers your questions. Feel free to ask more if you come up with anything. It's been a very positive overall experience thus far, and I'm happy to share.