skip to main content

Sanding/Feathering on Drywall with Knockdown Texture

12 years ago

I'm painting our bedroom wall. Before we paint, I've also just fixed a giant hole in the drywall: cut out a 1'x16" rectangular section and replaced with new drywall piece.

I've mesh/fiberglass taped and applied a fresh layer of joint compound and wet-sanded a bit. Now, I'm starting to sand and my previous experience (twice before) has me worrying about blending into the existing knock-down texture.

For walls with KD texture, is it OK to have less feathering on edges since I have to replace all the KD anyway? ie. going for "smooth as glass feathering" isn't needed? If I apply a wider Skim layer, the additional compound annoyingly fills gaps in existing KD (making it all flat) and then there is more to sand, further outside of the repaired area.

I've done moderate sanding to avoid a straight visible seam, just trying to avoid spreading the compound out even further, ruining more of the existing texture.

Does this logic translate into a decent real world repair?

Thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

sierraeast
12 years ago
"If I apply a wider Skim layer, the additional compound annoyingly fills gaps in existing KD (making it all flat) and then there is more to sand, further outside of the repaired area".

Where the new mud bumps up to the existing knockdown, instead of trying to feather it out with sand paper, use a sponge dampened with water and feather out the mud from the knockdown. Only sand the patched area. When you re-spray, go light where the new meets the existing.
cebury
Original Author
12 years ago
I finished yesterday, before reading your post. Although wet-sanding IS what I did at the edges.

My mistake: I didn't sacrifice (i.e. mud/skim) far enough outside of the patch line. I tried to feather it about only 1-1.5" inches from the tape -- and that caused too much of a "raised border" look that became more visible once painted.

The last two times I feathered it far out, it blended well, but my knockdown-from-a-bottle looked awful. So this time I was trying to limit the area I needed to apply it (i.e. not ruin any existing knockdown). However, I didn't go far enough out and caused the raised border: what do you know? My knockdown this time looked excellent inside the patched area -- just the improper feathering looked amateurish.

Not easy to make it match.... Maybe the 4th repair will be perfect!

And maybe someone else will find this helpful.

Thanks for the reply.
Related Discussions
Skim coating textured drywall
Q
Comments (11)
SOS-feeling like this thread might have the answer I need! Skim coating over a really bad knockdown texture. I have done three coats with all purpose lightweight joint compound overall it’s looking pretty good! Only issue is there are still some high point from the knock down still showing through. I don’t think I can sand them at this stage without destroying all the work I have done. What should I do? Additionally, on the walls that look ready. I’ve gone over everything with a light and touched up the places I noticed. I’ve run my hand over the wall more times than I can count to make sure it’s smooth. However, I’m really worried that when I paint sections that aren’t level will be very apparent. Does anyone have any other tips to make sure everything is ready to prime and paint? Would priming the walls and then If anything comes through doing another coat be a terrible idea? It’s been a messy and time consuming process and really can’t wait for it to be over hahah Thankful for any advice!
...See More
Drywall Textures - Which One???
Q
Comments (1)
This is such a regional issue: here in New England, textured walls are not in vogue; they tend to connote cheaper construction. But I know they are standard in high-end homes in other parts of the country and can look smashing in the right context. I once had knockdown plaster kitchen walls in a rental in California, and must say that the walls got pretty disgusting -- greasy grime that was impossible to clean because of the rough bumps. Is there any way to keep the kitchen smooth and still transition nicely to the other rooms?
...See More
drywall texture - orange peel vs knockdown
Q
Comments (37)
I had orange peel in my last home (Southern California) and flat in my new home (Pennsylvania). I don't know that repairs are any easier or more difficult. Flat is just a matter of smoothing the repair. Orange peel is a matter of matching the orange peel texture - too heavy or too light and it doesn't match. I saw a lot of holes repaired in homes with orange peel where they didn't bother to spray texture where the repair was made and it was quite noticeable - even with small repairs. With flat the biggest problem is if you need to use tape - it is tough to cover and keep everything smooth. Painting edges is way easier with smooth - no worry about bleeding under the tape - Orange Peel you have to tape, paint with the color you have covered with tape to fill any little holes under the tape and then paint over it with the other color to get a really clean line. I don't think either one looked inherently better than the other.
...See More
Ceiling paint showing texture/roughness on fresh drywall
Q
Comments (12)
Hi all - thanks for the comments. Yup! I did the mudding/taping myself. By no means an expert, only have done a few jobs. In other areas it looks great! I waited at least 24h before sanding/ painting / 2nd / 3rd coats of mud The primer was "drywall primer" - https://www.canadiantire.ca/en/pdp/premier-active-interior-drywall-primer-0488652p.html Paint - "Rolls on pink" - https://www.canadiantire.ca/en/pdp/premier-rolls-on-pink-ceiling-paint-white-3-78-l-0488775p.html @cat_ky I think you're onto something here. I did notice in some places, rolling back over, mere seconds after first roll sometimes small amounts of the paint peeled off. Same happened with the drywall in some cases! What a nuisance. Are you suggesting rolling over the same area again, with floetrol mixed in? Others - any suggestions for remedying? Do I need to sand with a rough grit, re-mud, and re-paint or is there an easier (hopefully!) solution? Than you all for your help!
...See More
sierraeast
12 years ago
There are a lot of variables when matching most any texture. The first being whether or not you know what type of texture materials were used on the existing. As an example, trying to match up using joint compound when a bagged texture material was used on the existing rarely works unless you spend a lot of time experimenting with the mix. Joint compounds differ in consistency and so do texture materials. You can typically play around with it until you get it close or even dead on, but it takes patience unless you just happen to hit the mother lode on the first try. If you aren't happy with the outcome, play around with the mix and you can even experiment on a scrap piece of wall board until you get it right, then transcribe to your repair.

Related Stories

HOUSEKEEPING Quick Fix: How to Patch a Drywall Hole

Dents and dings disappear, leaving your walls looking brand new, with this fix that even a novice can do

MATERIALS Raw Materials Revealed: Drywall Basics

By Buckminster Green LLC

Learn about the different sizes and types of this construction material for walls, plus which kinds work best for which rooms

MOST POPULAR The Right Way to Test Paint Colors

By Erin Carlyle

Here are 5 key steps to take to ensure you're happy with your wall paint color

PAINTING Knotty to Nice: Painted Wood Paneling Lightens a Room's Look

By No. 29 Design

Children ran from the scary dark walls in this spare room, but white paint and new flooring put fears and style travesties to rest

PAINTING Bulletproof Decorating: How to Pick the Right Kind of Paint

Choose a paint with some heft and a little sheen for walls and ceilings with long-lasting good looks. Here are some getting-started tips

BATHROOM DESIGN 7 Striking Paint Colors for Your Powder Room

By Jennifer Ott Design

Whether you opt for a little or a lot, see why the petite bathroom is the perfect place for a fun hue

WORKING WITH PROS 17 Things Color Consultants Want You to Know

By Becky Harris

Dithering over potential palettes for your home? A color pro might be the way to go. Here's how it works

DECORATING GUIDES From the Pros: How to Paint Interior Walls

By Vanessa Brunner

A slapdash approach can lower a room's entire look, so open your eyes to this wise advice before you open a single paint can

COLOR 11 Reasons to Paint Your Ceiling Black

Mask flaws, trick the eye, create drama ... a black ceiling solves a host of design dilemmas while looking smashing

REMODELING GUIDES Original Home Details: What to Keep, What to Cast Off

By Laura Gaskill

Renovate an older home without regrets with this insight on the details worth preserving

More Discussions

Please Help! Palette & Style Conundrum-Modern Tropical Glam vs Coastal

111

Struggling with Paint Decisions

16

can you spray paint a shiny brass lamp?

6

Help soften stark white stucco exterior without complete repaint

5

Kitchen cabinet color advice

9