Are you looking for one you build into a wall, a free standing unit that comes with a mantel, or an insert that goes into an existing fireplace? I have all of those here at Fireplace Treatments, but it's best if you clarify which you want so others can help as well.

I like Houssan's idea of dark shutters. Take the color of your roof and keep going many, many shades deeper on the color wheel until you have dark brown shutters. Add a dark orange front door. If you're getting a new roof in a couple of years, then do nothing now. then get a warm brown roof, which will open up possibilities. Do not, do not paint your beautiful blond brick. P.S. May I ask why you are posting your Dilemma again? You got over 30 responses altogether, pretty much admiring of the house and making similar suggestions. If you come back a third time. instead of asking for suggestions, just ask people for approval of the ideas you already have instead of asking for new ideas--waste of time. Sell the house if you're still so negative about it.

Something like this ?? Remember the smaller the tile the busier it will look.. Maybe larger format porcelain marble look would be abetter choice . Marble floors are timeless the actual marble tiles not fake are already 1000s of years old , pretty timeless to me.

I think it’s important to consider that wall in its entirety or DR will never look its best. First create more balance in LR, as the items are too high, not proportionate/look awkward. See difference below… your room will really benefit with this adjustment. As not comfortable with placement, consider shelves in DR and you can experiment with items (add some black) until it feels right. Note their height and this look will connect with LR. Center between ceiling beam and window, no matter what you add. Place mirror in a hall for example. If not interested, add a large print over a sideboard when budget allows and don’t over accessorize. There are great finds on Marketplace and maybe start there, ie: I found this in minutes.