No other choices available?

Anyone of these Benjamin Moors colors would look good. I took the shutters off to "paint," but I think it looks better with them. They are a handsome raised panel style. The one set of windows that would be a candidate to not have them is the set of two. But it looks silly without them because of the pediment. So I vote to leave all the shutters as is.

Just throwing this out there. This is Repose Gray (body), Dorian Gray (door/shutters) and Extra White (trim.). RG and DG are both warm grays and might be an option with your stone.

haley, you're going to HAVE to get actual samples and try them out. (please prime over the current color w/white so you get a true color reading) trying to choose off a screen is very difficult. lighting will alter how the actual color looks in person. not sure that I like stone lion (at least in the mock up) its very similar to what you have. modern gray may have too much pink. see the diff here? Athena might be a nice shade. Light Pewter too. I have that in my kitchen. I like these. soft suede might be a better choice. or, try one of the other grieges listed above Dvivine white would also be a nice stucco color. You will have to do samples to see how these colors look w/your stone. what I do is go to home deport and get a color match for sw or bm colors in the behr sample pots. they're only $3 and are very close. (BM has their own tints and is difficult to get an exact match w/other paint) I like using Behr paint, so if you like the color w/the color match sample, just use the behr paint. so, I'd get multiple samples and try them out on the stucco. it's the only way to be sure