unusual dilemma

19 years ago

hi there,

My husband and I have been married for 4 months. We have been together for 12 years now. The reason for the delay in getting hitched was due to us having different beliefs as far as religion was concerned, but we have sorted out these issues.

We eloped. I felt that my parents would not be able to accept my decision regarding religion, and thought it would be easier to get married overseas. Now 4 months later, I have still not told them neither has my husband told his parents.

I spoke to an aunt, and she said that my dad would be very dissapointed, since he always hopes that I will leave my partner and go back to the faith I was born into.

My husband also does not want me to tell my family. He is a very private person and is not very close to his family. People never ask him about his personal life, not even his close friends.

He says he does not want people knowing about us being married, but I feel that I want to tell my family. I am almost 30 and feel it is silly to be living like this.

I have told some friends of mine and my husband is fine with that.

But I seriously want to tell my dad. We are really close and I feel like I am hiding something big from him.

Whenever I talk to my husband about this, he says, our business is nobody's business and he does not see what the big deal is. We have a very good relationship and I don't want to upset him either.

What should I do?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

sweeby
19 years ago
My husband's sister got married once and didn't tell anyone.
We only found out about it when she had to borrow money to get divorced the following year.

I'm bringing that up because I suspect the issue is probably the same -- Commitment.
How committed are you to this marriage? Or is it just a temporary thing? How about your husband? If it's just a temporary marriage, then the secrecy part sort of makes sense. I mean, why ruffle your families' feathers if it'll all be over in a few years?
But then, it's the marriage that doesn't make any sense...

If you both are committed to this relationship and this marriage, then stand up and tell your parents. You waited 12 years because you knew they didn't approve, and you made the decision to get married because you felt it was the right one. Give them the chance to make a choice now. Invite them to accept your choice of husband, to support your marriage, and to be a part of the lives of any future grandchildren.
If you aren't truly comitted, then have this farce annulled and move on with your lives in your separate directions.
carla35
19 years ago
"What should I do"....

Highly consider an annulment and "Grow Up"

(sorry to sound harsh, but at almost 30 you should know better)
Related Discussions
Unusual Question
Q
Comments (11)
Hi guys: My name is Karen, and I work for Bechtol Engineering in Deland (between Daytona and Orlando). Among other things, we test soils before and during phases of construction; and one of the biggies is buried organic debris underlying new houses: As the organics decompose, a "void" space the size and shape of the original organic mass is created, the subsoils sink to fill it, and all hell breaks loose in the overlying structure - cracked and flooded foundations, cracked exterior walls, etc... It's especially common in relatively newly created subdivisions with man-made canals and ponds - the trees and scrub that used to stand in place of all those building pads and water features have to go somewhere, and greedy contractors may look for ways to avoid the high cost of trucking that stuff out and paying landfill fees. If it's under your house, you can do things (very, very expensive things!) to shore up the foundation; but I know you guys were talking more about your yards. Your best bet would be to call a geotechnical engineering firm near you and have someone come out to do borings. If you need deep borings requiring a truck-mounted drill rig it's very expensive, but if all you need is a guy with a hand auger (typically good enough to get down about 7 feet) it's not. The borings will probably be able to show you where the buried debris is located, and roughly map its vertical and horizontal boundaries for you. If there's no structure overlying the organic deposits, you can just supplement the lowest area inside the boundaries with any cheap fill dirt - make sure you specify that this dirt is just for growing grass & trees, and not to be used for structural subgrade: it'll be half the price, because it won't need to be particularly clean or well-graded.
...See More
Unusual paint color dilemma
Q
Comments (15)
Les, that is what I experienced, the fluorescents washed out the red. I painted a test board which looked more plum than brown, however on those walls, it looked the other way around. But regardless of the tone, it's just too dark a color for this space. All three sides are painted in a space of 13' x 11', and there will be lots of framed art and furniture covering much of the walls. But still, the paint color is the backdrop for the decor, and I want to get it right! I have another booth, and it is painted a neutral off-white/tan. I wanted to be a bit more bold or different in this booth, but just haven't come up with the right color yet. I've decided I am going to repaint, so at this point, I am just asking for paint color suggestions. My only ideas are either a light grey or a terra cotta.
...See More
Unusual lighting problem
Q
Comments (1)
You need to drop that vault down enough to be able to get some recessed lighting into it for your general lighting. Otherwise it will be very dark when the sun goes down. Pendants would work for the island, but NOT if the ceiling for part of it is the 7'4" and the rest goes up to 11'. A single linear fixture with multiple lights would work in that case. An "island fixture" would be the search term. I'd look at raising the ceiling in the shorter part first also.
...See More
Please help with ideas to reconfigure bathroom
Q
Comments (23)
You can lower the ceilings but you'd have a regular ceiling on the first floor. It's not that you can't; it's that you don't want to. Personally for safety reasons, I'd put a ceiling up on the first floor and hide the plumbing in the ceiling. I think a step up into a bathroom is a huge safety issue. I can see the first time someone decides to walk out of the bathroom with some water dripping and they slip down those steps.
...See More
rivkadr
19 years ago
You're adults. Stop acting like children, and tell your parents.
wantoretire_did
19 years ago
Is he currently married to someone else?
popi_gw
19 years ago
I think you are trying to please too many people.

Work out your priorities and stick to them.

I think your hubbie should take his marriage more seriously and start understanding your need to tell your father. I would worry about his indifferent attitude to the union.

If your Dad is disappointed, well he will get used to it. Always best to know the truth and not live a lie. Its not a bad truth....you are an adult you should live your life the way you want to live it, not the way other people want you to live it. As long as you know you are doing the right thing, then it is the right thing for you.

What will happen when the children come along, regarding religion ?

Popi
Meghane
19 years ago
I must have a totally different idea of what a good relationship is.

When I think of a good relationship, I think of truth, not lies. I think of being proud to be married or or in a committed relationship, not secrecy. I think of being involved with all aspects of each other's lives, not having one person isolate the other from her family. I think of being supportive, not driving a wedge between a daughter and her father. I think of agreeing on life's major choices and decisions, not one person live as if married and the other living as if not.

Abusers usually try to isolate their intended victim from family and friends. Just something to consider.
naughtykitty
19 years ago
The longer you wait to tell your family, the harder it will be. I can't imagine saying "Oh, by the way, I've been married 6 months and didn't want to tell you". My family would be devistated. (and they would probably never let me live it down either). You need to talk to your husband and decide how you want to handle it. It would eat up my insides having to "hide" something that big in my life to anyone.
azzalea
19 years ago
A strong marriage is based on honesty, truth and commitment.

I would never be able to be married to a man who was, and expected me to be so dishonest.

I suppose you have your reasons for letting this man do these things to you (take away your religion, your family, your self-respect while not offering you the support of standing beside you as his husband), but I'm truly flabberghasted that any young woman today would sit by and allow herself to be taken advantage of that way.

Sorry--I'm with the rest. You don't have a marriage. And you don't have a man--not a real one--in your life. Although, I suspect that it's very possible he has another woman or 2 in his life.
Vickey__MN
19 years ago
We have a rule at our house...If it matters to one, it MUST matter to the other it's called respect. If it matters to you that you tell, it MUST matter to him, if it doesn't he doesn't respect your wishes. You cannot turn this around...his NOT wanting you to tell your family is being respectful to your wishes. If he doesn't want to tell anyone, that is his wish, but that shouldn' stop you from telling ANYONE. If you REALLY have a good relationship, why are you worried about upsetting him. I think you are lieing to yourself.

Vickey-MN
Vickey__MN
19 years ago
I forgot to add, this isn't so unusual, isolation is common...among abusuers as stated before. HMMMMMM it doesn't start as abuse usually, starts small, controlling small things, then gets bigger. So see, he isolates you here from your family, then it will grow because he has no respect for your feelings, which in turns says he has no respect for you which in turn says....you get the picture. TELL PEOPLE, take the control back.

Vickey-MN
bnicebkind
19 years ago
Are you receiving money from your parents to cover living expenses, and you both are afraid that if they find out the truth, that they will cut you off finacially? Just wondering, because I cannot imagine keeping such a secret from family, unless they REALLY hated the guy/gal. And I cannot imagine the guy wanting his marriage to be a secret, unless he has something to lose...or he is hiding something. Think about all of the people you know. Do you know ANYONE who does not celebrate their marriage, but keeps it a secret? I agree with the others...if you plan on staying in this marriage, then you need to tell the truth. It is much harder to tell the truth the longer the lie has gone on. And it is harder to forgive the lie if it has gone on for a long period of time. Your dad will remember all of those phone conversations with you, where you had so many opportunities to tell him, and instead, he will realize that you were able to act totally normal on the phone, while hiding something REALLY big. And it will hurt.

I have heard of someone who was unable to tell the parents about the elopement, and they had an actual wedding, never telling the parents that they actually married 3 months earlier. They just pretended that they were just then getting married.

What a mess of things we make,when we are trying to deceive.

I also would really wonder why this guy you married wanted this kept secret so badly. Why does he want to hide your marriage so badly? What does he have to lose if people know that you are his wife?
jojoco
19 years ago
My parents got married overseas in the 1954. He was a good jewish boy, she a good catholic girl (convent school and all). My dad's father basically refused to meet my mom when they were dating. Once they came back from Japan as Mr and Mrs. the scenario changed and my mother was warmly welcomed to the family. Was it the marriage my gp's wanted? No, but they changed with the situation because they loved their children.
Tell you dad and let him act like a dad.
Jo

unusual dilemma

Comments (12)

sweeby

carla35

Related Discussions

rivkadr

wantoretire_did

popi_gw

Meghane

naughtykitty

azzalea

Vickey__MN

Vickey__MN

bnicebkind

jojoco

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US