I like them all, but not number 2, but maybe that one will work for your taste- it's just not mine. I really like 3 and 4 (the one your husband likes).

Most 'recessed to pendant conversion kits' should allow you to use a variety of cable-hung pendants. As such, you can then 'swag' to relocate the drop point to get pendants hanging directly overhead. You can use Plumen's Ceiling Hook or similar to secure the placement.

The type of lighting that is typically on its own switch includes pendant lights and over sink lights. This allows for more control over the lighting in specific areas of the kitchen. In terms of combining lights, you can consider combining the under cabinet lighting with the pot lights to provide overall ambient lighting in the kitchen. The pendant lights over the seated counter can be combined with the over sink light to create a focused task lighting area for food preparation or other activities at the counter. For the room size of 10'x16', having 6 pot lights should provide adequate lighting coverage. For outlet locations, it is recommended to have outlets installed along the countertops for convenient use of small appliances. Additionally, consider adding outlets near the seated counter for charging devices or using small appliances while seated. Be sure to follow local electrical codes and regulations when determining outlet locations.

some times a light that highights, or lights up the ceiling on it own switch can be nice when you do not want the recessed lights on something that threw light up could be amazing. but not the one you pictured. after reading your notes and replies I would consider it as a light for atmosphere as well.https://www.remodelaholic.com/inexpensive-diy-herringbone-wood-ceiling-using-pallets/