LED Landscape Lighting & Solar Alternative to Halogen Bulbs

13 years ago

Sorry I posted previously elsewhere and now I cant find the post. Anyway. I wanted to share my experience with outdoor LED lighting and see what others have done and think.

I have a very large yard that has about 20 spot lights and about 15 path lights. all lights have 1.5W G4 halogen bulbs. with average use of 6 hours/evening, that comes to about 350W/hr OR 2100 hrs/day. That is a lot of electricity being used daily. I wanted to save electricity costs and started looking into alternatives.

First I looked at Solar LED's. tried some and what a waste of time and money. Returned back to Costco. Then I thought about adding a 300W Solar panel for outdoor use. then it turned out that for solar I will need to update my bulbs to LED. So, I started looking into LED bulb options.

I finally narrowed down my research to 1.5W LED bulb that would easily replace the bi-pin halogen bulb from existing light fixtues (malibu), the bulb I got was from Amazon.com, link here http://www.amazon.com/Landscape-Lighting-Lumen-Bi-pin-Replacement/dp/B005OFK542/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1319055466&sr=8-1

Here is what I found:

1. Bulb consumes only 1.5W and color of light is a bit whiter than halogen but not white as tubelight. the color I got was warm white.

2. On trees/shrubs, the spot focus was excellent, a bit less than the 10W halogen but once I put two side by side, there was slight difference.

3. At 99 actural lumens, factory claims 130 lumens, it was quite bright bulb.

4. Not knowing how good these bulbs perform in the long run, the manufacturer does say that life span is well over 20,000 hrs. that is a lot of hours of use.

With 35 bulbs to replace, 35 bulb consumption will go down from 350 watts/hr to 52.5 watts/hr. that is dramatic 85% effifiency. Talk about $$$ being saved when you have to use 6-hrs/day on 35 lights.

Back to my energy independence, now the backbone of Solar makes perfect sense. I can easily get a 60W panel and get $$$ free lit backyard.

Just wanted to see what others have done to cut down on their energy costs @ backyard. I am yet to make the change, but easy switch out of bulb and cost savings outweigh the initial cost investment.

Any personal experiences or thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

behlgarden
Original Author
13 years ago
Sorry, all halogen bulbs are 10W and not 1.5W, sorry about the typo.
0
brickeyee
13 years ago
"350W/hr OR 2100 hrs/day"

If the lights run for 6 hours per day you are using 2100 (W-hrs)/day. That is 2.1 (kW-hrs)/day.

Unless you have extremely high electric rates, at $0.10 per kW-hr tat os less than 0.25 per day.

I would almost bet that the Chinese made solar powered lights actually cost more when you factor in their short life span.
0
Related Discussions
Should I get these solar landscape lights?
Q
Comments (9)
Somewhere around 30 years ago (when solar pathlights were really, really new) I got an elcheapo set of four all-in-one units; came with a one year guarantee. They lasted about 25 years, and then I discovered no one makes the replacement batteries. So I finally replaced those with a pair that run off a separate battery/PV unit, aimed at the back steps. Points to consider: Price means almost nothing -- you are paying for the frame not the lighting (If you want stainless steel expect to pay $$$, plastic lamps are Â¢). But LEDs and the PV panel are very old-hat, there is no excuse for non-functioning. Count the number of LED bulbs in each unit; 6 will give the effect of very bright moonlight from 6 feet away, while 3 will barely show the path 18" away. IMO, those with a separate PV panel do a better job of battery-charging because you have more options for optimum replacement (and those panels have been around for decades and are nearly trouble-free). Look at the estimated length of time lit because that is best guess -- reality will depend on how much sun the PV receives and how good the batteries are. However, my backstep light (6 LED; one of a pair of units) does stay bright for the full 12 hours, the PV panel gets about Â¾ day of sunlight. Most units come with a warranty or guarantee, if there's no warranty, no sale. The only upkeep is monthly, to wipe the face of the PV panel to remove pollution. My solar light has done well for three years and counting. Andie ~ link is to the one I'm presently using. DH decided 2 were too bright, and thus only one lamp is linked to the PV. Here is a link that might be useful: solar path lights
...See More
halogen to led conversion
Q
Comments (5)
The need is to design for LED lighting from inception; retrofit will be very difficult due to the LEDs requiring good heat-sinking, which takes more space than allocated to an R-20 or other incandescent bulb design. A design from inception would have to take advantage of all the metal in the hood to be used for a heat sink, and/or allowing the ventilation fan to pull in air that is not heated and cause it to flow around the LED fixtures. A sensor to turn the LEDs off when overheated for whatever reason would be needed. Alternatively, turning the LEDs on with heat present would force the fan on independent of being turned off. Not an easy problem, and one that might require some retraining of the customer, which is always fraught with difficulty. kas
...See More
Closet lights - fluorescent, halogen or LED??
Q
Comments (8)
Per NEC section 410.8(B), the only types of luminaires allowed in a closet are: (1) A surface-mounted or recessed incandescent luminaire (fixture) with a completely enclosed lamp (2) A surface-mounted or recessed fluorescent luminaire (fixture) Also, per 410.8(D), there are the following restrictions on location: (1) Surface-mounted incandescent luminaires (fixtures) installed on the wall above the door or on the ceiling, provided there is a minimum clearance of 300 mm (12 in.) between the luminaire (fixture) and the nearest point of a storage space (2) Surface-mounted fluorescent luminaires (fixtures) installed on the wall above the door or on the ceiling, provided there is a minimum clearance of 150 mm (6 in.) between the luminaire (fixture) and the nearest point of a storage space (3) Recessed incandescent luminaires (fixtures) with a completely enclosed lamp installed in the wall or the ceiling, provided there is a minimum clearance of 150 mm (6 in.) between the luminaire (fixture) and the nearest point of a storage space (4) Recessed fluorescent luminaires (fixtures) installed in the wall or the ceiling, provided there is a minimum clearance of 150 mm (6 in.) between the luminaire (fixture) and the nearest point of a storage space I note that "storage space" is defined in 410.8(A). I doubt that track lighting is considered "surface-mounted luminaires." In any case, it is rare for a track fixture to be "fully-enclosed."
...See More
LED MR 16 in a halogen fixture
Q
Comments (17)
Yes, then it's the low voltage transformer. I don't know what's what. With LEDs some people call transformers drivers and vice versa. I know MR16 GU5.3 bulbs need a low voltage fixture. Whatever the terms, they were saying low voltage halogen fixtures can fail prematurely because they are not made to handle the much lower wattage of the LED bulbs. I asked Chris if I would know right away if it the fixture would have a problem running an LED bulb and he said yes. But when I called USALights they said it could work fine in the beginning. Then I chatted with TotalTrackLighting.com that had what looked like the same fixture, only it was listed as an LED fixture. I asked if it had a special transformer to handle the lower wattage and he said it was the same as the halogen model only they offer compatible LED bulbs. But those bulbs are not high CRI. Here's the two fixtures: http://www.usalight.com/Theatrical-Track-Light-Low-Voltage-p/us-904w.htm http://www.totaltracklighting.com/led-white-theatrical-track-light-12v-mr16-cool-or-warm-white-kit.html They are inexpensive either way but USA Light even warns that their $65 track heads say they are for halogen only. I got inexpensive track light fixtures 20 years ago and I've still got half of the originals (but they are fading fast) so I'd like to avoid speding a ton on fixtures if I can. These have several vents that I figured would help in cooling. I have been wanting to replace them with LED for several years. I've looked at native LED fixtures but even models costing several hundred dollars do not have high CRI values. I thought I finally had something with this fixture and the Creative Green MR16 bulbs but I don't want to buy a bunch of bulbs,especially expensive Soraa bulbs, and find out the fixture fails right away. They said line voltage isn't a problem but there are very few reasonable options for high CRI bulbs in PAR 20 or MR16-G10 and they all put out far less lumens than my current 50 W halogen (at 800 lumens).
...See More
Related Professionals
Green Bay Lighting · Oshkosh Furniture & Accessories · Rochester Furniture & Accessories · Rome Furniture & Accessories · Clark Furniture & Accessories · Crofton Furniture & Accessories · Holliston Furniture & Accessories · Queens Interior Designers & Decorators · Solana Beach Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · American Fork Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Larkspur Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Mastic Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Minneapolis Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · West Bend Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures · Truckee Decks, Patios & Outdoor Enclosures
behlgarden
Original Author
13 years ago
well, 2.1KW/day, my rate is hitting 3rd tier on So Cal Edison, pricks have electricity very expensive, 3rd tier is $0.23/KW. so daily use of electricity would cost about $0.48/day or about $15/month OR $180/yr. If bulbs last longer than halogen that burn out frequently, LED use cost would be about 0.315KW/day or $0.072/day, $2.17/Mon. or $26/yr, electricity cost saving of about $155/yr. based on manufacturer's guarantee, these bulbs are great payoff around 1st year to 14 months.

I still need to find someone who has been using these 5050 9SMD type LED bulbs for a while and find their reliability.
0
brickeyee
13 years ago
"$0.48/day or about $15/month"

how long do you expect eh other lights to last exposed to the weather?
It costs money to replace them.
0
zeak8892
10 years ago
Hi all. I'm researching solar powered outdoor lighting for my walkways and garden. Reviews in the past have been mixed. Has anybody found anything that they're happy with and provides adequate light? Thanks in advance.
0
behlgarden
Original Author
10 years ago
yes, after extensice research I found that switching to LED was best choice with or without added expense of solar. also, no need to replace fixtures, this website that I found has almost every application of LED direct replacement available and the most resonable cost.

link to website is here www.mygreenpros.com

I replaced all my yard lights with combination of SMD chips, MR11, MR16 and some Disc. leds and so far I am on month 22 with no problems. very reliable LED's and good customer servivce too. I triled Ebay but found a lot of issues.

this this website a try, they take it back if you are not satisfied. good luck!

This post was edited by behlgarden on Tue, Apr 8, 14 at 14:01
0
zeak8892
10 years ago
thanks! looks good. Anybody have any positive experience with solar powered free standing lights? I'm looking for the easiest option in terms of installation.
0
behlgarden
Original Author
10 years ago
I tried westinghouse solar led lights in bought from costco and ended up returning. So far have not found good solar but leds sort of cost next to nothing on energy costs.
0

LED Landscape Lighting & Solar Alternative to Halogen Bulbs

Comments (8)

behlgarden
Original Author

brickeyee

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

behlgarden
Original Author

brickeyee

zeak8892

behlgarden
Original Author

zeak8892

behlgarden
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

LED Landscape Lighting & Solar Alternative to Halogen Bulbs

Comments (8)

behlgardenOriginal Author

brickeyee

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

behlgardenOriginal Author

brickeyee

zeak8892

behlgardenOriginal Author

zeak8892

behlgardenOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

behlgarden
Original Author

behlgarden
Original Author

behlgarden
Original Author

behlgarden
Original Author