Michael De Luca on light placement

17 years ago

I have a book by Michael De Luca, CKD, ASID, called Kitchen and Bath Lighting Made Easy. It's a good book with loads of information. Heavy on the math and formulas, light on design, which is what I was looking for. However, he seems to have an interesting take on the placement of recessed lighting in the kitchen. He uses formulas based on the ceiling height, work surface height, light size, candlepower, and beam angle to determine where to place recessed lights. In my opinion, it works well everywhere except at the counter. He doesn't advocate placing the light at the edge of the counter, which seems to be the prevailing opinion amongst most professionals, but instead using the formula (or his software) so the edge of the beam intersects the junction of the wall and the work surface (in this case, the counter). His view is lights at the edge of the counter result in "light scallops" on the wall cabinets, and undercounter lighting should be used to fill in the counter area.

In my kitchen, with 9 foot ceilings, using a 4" recessed light with a 50w PAR 20 bulb with a 40 degree beam, that puts the lights 34" out from the wall, rather than the 25" that would put them over the edge of the counter. While that looks good on paper, in practice (my kitchen is gutted and I'm doing the work myself, so I've been playing around with placing the can lights in various positions)I find it casts a very dark and distinct shadow of me on the counter surface. I would think it would take some fairly powerful undercabinet lighting to overcome this.

Anyone here have any experience with DeLuca's books/ideas or any other thoughts on the subject?

Thanks in advance.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (2)

Jon1270
17 years ago
"the edge of the beam intersects the junction"

Generally, there is no 'edge of the beam.' The light from most bulbs is brightest in the middle of the beam and gets less bright as you go out from the center. The gradient is narrower for spot lights and wider for floods. The 'beam angle' tells you the approximate angle at which the light is half as bright as it is in the center of the beam.

I haven't read DeLuca's book. He is right that placing the lights closer in is likely to place scallops of intense light on the upper cabinets. That can look odd if the placement of lights has no relationship to the placement of cabinets and thus appears random, but it can be done thoughtfully and look fine. If you don't like the scallops at all and prefer to place lights further out, then you're going to get the shadows. Oh, and yes, you would want to get good UC lighting if you want the counters well-lit. Even with them you'd never eliminate those shadows, but you could make them much less noticeable.

If you were to move the cans toward the cabs and use them for task lighting, I think you'll find that 50W par20 bulbs are a little underpowered for 9' ceilings. Even if you spaced them 32" apart, you'd only have about 40 footcandles on the front of the counters, which may be enough if your eyes are good. Stepping up to par30 bulbs could give just as much light with the same amount of electricity and fewer fixtures, or more light with a similar number of fixtures.

It's worth mentioning that you have to think about your own needs to make sense of the options; formulas can help you attain a particular light-level target, but you really ought to be sure that the target the formula aims for is appropriate for you and your lifestyle. If your counters are primarily used for opening takeout food, task lighting may not be very important. If you do a lot of chopping and mixing and reading of recipes then you may want much better than average lighting.
hatman52
Original Author
17 years ago
Thanks for the response, jon1270. You might check out DeLuca's book, you'd probably find it useful. Skip the software, though -- has to be one of the most poorly designed and difficult-to-use programs I've ever experienced. Save your money on that one.
Related Discussions
Can I grow Gallicas in the South? Recommendations please!
Q
Comments (20)
Thanks to all who responded; since it is too hot here to mail order anything I can only look at my little Belle de Crecy and plan for next year and talk. Thanks for giving me the chance to learn. Ann- I forgot to say how much I liked your comment "none of this screaming magenta that sellers want to call purple." There is a lot of wishful thinking out there when it comes to colors - almost as much as with fragrance. Lynn- I hope they do well for you, but please let us know regardless. This is "zone pushing" from the other side. Melva- Thanks for the information. What is "Rush Family?" I couldn't find it on HMF - is it a found rose? Olga- I see now why Michael made the comment he did. Wow! (Perhaps it is best that I can't order right now after seeing that list.) I hope some of you will post full bush shots when your roses are in bloom. Elizabeth
...See More
Around the Yard -- photos
Q
Comments (44)
John --- I am surprised and pleased to see this thread pop up again too. Unfortunately, My yard did take a hard hit from the freezes but all was not lost. Glad that your banana is growing well for you. This variety recovered very well from the low temps. Hi Mark, nice bamboo pic. sharbear --- The bamboo is called "blue bamboo". I can look up the botanical name if you need it. It is my favorite variety. The plant is tall but I consider it to be the perfect height because it's not too tall. mammie --- In the picture the blue bamboo looks variegated. It's not. It has a blue coating on the canes that reflect the light differently. Luckily, only the leaves got damaged last winter. It has fully recovered and it's looking great. Hi Tom, I've got a newly picked squash pic to post this week. It weighted in at 14 lbs. Christine
...See More
Finally figured out the trick to installing lighting cans!!
Q
Comments (10)
I had similar issues but then figured it out. The trick is to slide the can housing over as far as you can to one side - then hold the can pushing it against the truss or rafter you are nailing into with one hand. With the other hand nail the two rails on that side in and that should hold the housing in place. Then swing around and you can do each of the other two rails one at a time. When nailing - use one sharp blow rather than small taps. When I tried to take smaller taps I had a greater tendency to bend the nails. The screw thing works too but it is more time consuming. Another trick I figured out was how to spot cans. I took a 4" piece of PVC drain pipe and cut it about 1.5 inches lower than the height of the ceiling. Then took a toilet flange and turned it upside down and stuck the pipe into the flange - so I could stand the pipe vertically and it would stay there. I used round cardboard cutouts and layed them on the floor where I wanted the center of the light beams to shine - then used my pipe jig to make sure the housing would fit in between the joists with enough clearance. Made adjustments by moving the cardboard pieces around on the floor. Once I had the right spots - I spray painted around the cardboard cutouts to mark the locations. I did this for 87 cans without ever getting on a ladder. Once all the cans were spotted, i went back and placed my pipe jig on the painted spots. Got up on a ladder and hammered in the can - using the top of the pipe as a reference. One shot install - never had to play around on the ladder with adjustments of the housing due to joists in the way. This really works well if you have a cluster of lights and you want perfect spacing between them. Plus you get precise markings on the floor so when the drywallers cover up your cans - you know eactly where they are. I had about a dozen cans covered that were easily located.
...See More
Looking for a book series recommendation
Q
Comments (58)
Romy, yes, we had the same initial reservations about Tom Cruise playing him, but agree that he actually did a good job. FUN: regarding Dorothy Gilman, I fell in love with her young adult books when I was a kid. They were written under her then-married name of Dorothy Gilman Butters. I eventually went on to read her Mrs. Pollifax series and many of her other books. I was totally shocked to find out that she was living in Albuquerque at the same time as we were in the 80's, as one of her sons lived there. I actually got a chance to meet her at a book reading and signing she did. I took along my very favorite of her young adult books, "A Calico Year" for her to sign. She was so surprised to see it and we had a wonderful chat. Lovely lady. She passed in 2008, I believe.
...See More

Michael De Luca on light placement

Comments (2)

Jon1270

hatman52
Original Author

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Michael De Luca on light placement

Comments (2)

Jon1270

hatman52Original Author

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

hatman52
Original Author