Another Attic Insulation Question & Help

13 years ago

Just purchased a 1951 brick rambler in the northern Virginia area. It is about 1,500 sq ft up and another 1,500 sq ft down in a fully finished basement. Need some help in deciding the route to take on adding insulation keeping in mind I want to do the work myself.

The upstairs attic with 1x6 inch flooring over the entire space is completely floored and usable as attic storage. Pulling up some of the flooring after noticing some cold rooms, I found that all of the attic flooring is sitting on 2x8 inch ceiling joists 16 inches on center above downstairs ceiling plaster/some drywall. The sad thing is that there is only about 2 or 3 inches of blown insulation between most of the joists. Over quite a few places in the house, mostly over new bathrooms and bedroom additions, there is ZERO insulation at all.

So there is some blown at no more than 3 inches in height and some areas with nothing between downstairs and attic other than drywall.

I would like to be able to keep most of the attic as storage. This is one of the real nice things about this house. But I want to add insulation and can't decide on which R-factor to go with when I get started.

Ripping up the floor in sections is easy enough and I was hoping to do the attic in sections. Add insulation and then place the flooring back in place and move on to another section. This will allow me not to have to empty out the attic too.

So, after pulling floor boards and opening up to the 8 inch high joists on 16 inch center, I know I could easily add unfaced R-19 which is about 6.25 inches thick. That would bring the insulation right to the top of the joists where there is some blown insulation. Other areas where there is none, it would be below about an 1 1/2.

But, I would really like to get the R30 value between the joists and then put the flooring back on but the unfaced R30 is about 9 1/2 inches thick. I put a piece in today to check it out and you can get the flooring to settle down on to the insulation and the joists but is this advisable? Would the compressed R30 wreak havoc on the plaster and drywall ceilings below? I know that insulation works best without the compression but will I be better off with less insulation (R19) and not always filling the joists completely or better of compression the R30 just a bit into the joists?

Batt fiberglass would be easiest since I am doing this in sections but am I just going in the wrong direction and really should be looking at blowing cellulose with a rental unit a couple of different times?

8 inches to the top of the joists of cellulose would be a rating of R29.60 if the R value of 3.70 is correct.

Any thoughts and I really appreciate the advice and help here.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

zippyhvac
13 years ago
Why not option #3 - pull the boards yourself and have a crew blow in cellulose? You'll get the full r-value, and save yourself some labor. A pro crew can joist-walk to do the install, they do it all day.

For my previous insulation projects, buying batts and laying them myself was about the same or slightly higher cost than hiring someone to blow-in cellulose. Might be worth looking into.

Cellulose is a better barrier to air movement than fiberglass, so you'll get slightly better performance with cellulose than glass, and you'll be able to go to the tippy-top of the joists without compromising the r-value.
energy_rater_la
13 years ago
in the areas that you want to keep for storage
you could do this:
toenail 2x6's across the ceiling joists
(I use screws rather than nails for toenailing
and decking ...less banging = less damage to ceiling..)
this will raise the area to be insulated without
compressing the insulation.put R-19 in joist bay
and another batt (unfaced) in the area created by
toenailed 2x6's.

then you could blow the rest of the unfloored
attic.

personally I would look for air leakage sites and even get
a blower door and duct test. Seal all leakage sites
then insulate. once you insulate..you won't be able to address the infiltration as easily.

when holes that allow air leakage are sealed, then the insultion can perform. with air moving through the insulation, it robs the insulating values.

personally I don't care for cellulose. I find that the fine
dust it makes finds its way into the living space below via
recessed lights, poorly sealed vent fans, small cracks and
holes.

best of luck.
Related Discussions
OT, attic insulation question
Q
Comments (3)
I blew my own insulation in with the help of my wife. I had 4-5 inches of insulation when I started. After blowing 40 bundles in I had about 30 inches of insulation. I used cellulose. Total cost was $200 because I had coupons. Without coupons it would be $300. My house is 1500 square feet for reference. It only took me 1 hour of time. Questions I would ask for those giving you bids: Approximately how many hours are you planning? How many employees would be working during this time? How many inches of insulation will be there when complete? If you have 1500 square feet and they are adding 24 inches it would be $300 for the materials. Add about $25/hour for each employee they state. For 2 employees taking 2 hours and approximately $300 in materials Anywhere near $500 would be a reasonable quote to me.
...See More
Question on attic insulation
Q
Comments (0)
I need the input from some of you insulation gurus to know how to proceed with this house. Originally a ranch, it is now conisdered a cape, since part of the attic was bumped out to form two extra bedrooms and a bath. A door in the hallway leads to the unfinished part of the attic. There is ample room to stand up in most of it, and there is a crawl space over the bedroom wing. There are two air handlers (system is hydronic forced air), one in the standup part, and one in the crawl space. The old insulation, rock wool, is mostly exposed and dirty at this point, and dried out and flaking. I know we get some of the filaments coming down through high hat openings in the bathrooms, and I'm convinced, althoughthe HVAc company says "no", that a good bit of it is getting into the duct work, which explains a very dusty house, and problems breathing since we moved here three years ago. W had major ice dam issues for two years, owing to the heat in the attic,and a warm roof. We just had a second roofing job done (yes, we have done two), now bringing the ice shield down over the eaves onto the soffits, to prevent water backup from the gutters as the ice melted. This has also, I think, warmed up the attic even more. The HVAC company does not want to see the temps dropped up there, due to the equipment. I had two insulation guys here, one of whom wants to rip out everything accessible, including the insulation in the crawl space, which is stuffed between the beams . There is no actual floor in that section. I worry about the electrical and plumbing lines, and damage which might be done while they rip out and replace. They also want to insulate the ceiling, effectively making the attic part of the living space - which would aso, they say, keep the warm air from going up to the roof, and protect the equipment. Second insulation guy says it is imppossible to rip out the old insulation on the floor of the crawl space ( perhaps it is just too much work??) and wants to staple new insulation over it, but remove and replace what is accessible in the main part of the attic. He has said "no" to insulating the roof line, stating that in the summer it would be hotter than Hell!! Someone else told me it could cause the roof to rot (vapor barrier?). So now I have two different takes on this, but my major concern is getting rid of the loose stuff which is permeating the house, as much as possible, and possibly keeping the air a little cleaner. Another aspect of this might be keeping the warm air on the first floor from going up to the second floor, costing a lot more to heat the house. I just don't know which of these guys makes more sense, and whether one or the other has a valid argument. Can anyone help with this??? Thanks!
...See More
Another spray foam in attic question. Please help.
Q
Comments (2)
have a foam company come and take a look. lots of times we cut thru a wall to allow access. if you only foam part of the roof, you aren't achieving a lot as you will still have air leakage from unfoamed area. if it is truly not acessable then you need to put a wall(..can be felt nailed to studs) between foamed and unfoamed part of attic. foam company can spray the 'wall' to make it air tight to the unvented portion. most companies should be able to figure it out and give you a better idea. shop around. best of luck.
...See More
Attic insulation ventilation question
Q
Comments (6)
no foam mike_home, contractor is proposing blown insulation either fg or cellulose, only OP knows. just google baffles for attic ventilation OP. lots of pics there.baffles are installed on roof at eaves to do two things. one is to keep insulation at low point of eaves/soffits from clogging up air flow. the other is to establish a pathway for air to enter attic at soffit/eaves. attic ventilation that works is one of these three methods. all are stand alone, not strategies to be mixed. gable end vents. soffit/eaves may or may not have vents cut into them. soffit/eaves vents with ridge vent at peak of roof. or lastly soffit/eaves vents with passive vents installed on roof. the idea is to take air from soffits & vent from gable end, ridge vent or passive vents. google attic ventilation for more detailed info. prior to adding insulation minimal air sealing of air barrier (ceiling of living space) from living space to attic is done. for example recessed lights (Insulation contact not IC air tight recessed lights) would be addressed prior to insulation. much harder to dig out each area to be air sealed with newly installed insulation. fortunately, you can do a lot of air sealing from inside the living space. making as tight of an air barrier between living & attic spaces is one of the first steps to efficiency (and better air quality that goes along with it). it is easier to heat/cool a house with minimal air leakage. first area to air seal is house to attic. then floor to crawlspace (now that we have that info) once the air sealing is completed...then insulate. (3" closed cell foam installed on underside of floor, installed from under the house) if you have 8, 12 or 20+ inches of insulation & there is air moving through it...then it isn't performing. keep in mind that there is a diminishing return for more inches of insulation. the first 6" of insulation does most of the thermal barrier work, added insulation above this 6" saves you less & less $$ in utility costs. meeting code minimums is the least you can do. here in La. R0-30 is code, but people often have R-38. not a big jump in price, and not a big savings in utility costs. you make your own call on what to be installed. are you willing to do any work? (ie caulking etc) whats your location? best of luck
...See More
david_cary
13 years ago
I'm unclear on the flooring myself - I guess there are beams going the opposite direction of the joists. Ok - I can picture it.

What about your r-19 grouped with some foam? I am imaging 1 inch of foam on the plaster/drywall sprayed in to seal it. It also adds some R-value and thickness. Then if you wanted some more r-value, you could do 1 inch rigid foam (or 2 inches) on top of the joists. This would help with thermal coupling of the joists.

Getting to a magical R-value is not the only concern. Sealing properly is worth a lot. That being said, you would be at r-27.

Spray foam is about a dollar per sq foot at an inch thickness. So you are looking at $1500 - but you might use less because of the joists. The rigid foam is about 1/3 of that so you would need $500 for that. Not cheap but 30% tax credit would count.

I think you would be fine from a vapor barrier standpoint. 1 inch of rigid foam does not count as a barrier but 3 inches would. I would want some independent confirmation on the vapor barrier question.
jackcal
Original Author
13 years ago
Thanks for the input. I think after pulling floorboards and checking what I have up in the attic, I have decided to blow insulation to the top of all the 2x8 joists and then put the flooring back in place after sealing all air leaks. I am pretty confident that will put me just below R30 and if I need more, I can lay R30 fiberglass on the floor but I think I will be pretty good to go with the blown insulation. I should be able to handle the job myself...

Again, thanks and if any one has any further advice or suggestions, please have at it.

Another Attic Insulation Question & Help

Comments (4)

zippyhvac

energy_rater_la

Related Discussions

david_cary

jackcal
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Another Attic Insulation Question & Help

Comments (4)

zippyhvac

energy_rater_la

Related Discussions

david_cary

jackcalOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

jackcal
Original Author