Help selecting boiler for NG conversion

12 years ago

Please help me select the right boiler for a NG conversion. We (soon to be 4 people) live in the NE (Outside Philly) in a 50 yo two story brick colonial about 1400 sq ft. We currently have oil with a summer/winter hook up and have the radiators with the fins, not the cast iron ones.

I have three bids from BBB accredited contractors overall the prices are comparable at $11k for the high efficiency units with indirect hot water. All three have been in business for a very long time and my husband and I genuinely liked each one of them so the decision really boils down to the best most reliable equipment.

Contractor 1 - proposes to install one of three Utica boilers (range of 5k - 9k) - the MGB Series, UB-90-100 or the UB95M-200 (a modulating boiler). Both the UBs are condensing gas boilers, though I am unsure what the benefit of this is? I have one of three hot water options as well 2 Bradford Whites 40 or 50 gallons and then the Smart 30 which I see is from Triangle Tube that I keep hearing such great things about (range 700 - 1800).

Contractor 2 - proposes to install a Dunkirk Plus 90 (his other two were WMs and from what I have read, I'll stay far away!) This is not a modulating boiler. For HW he proposes either a WM indirect (11k) or a Bradford White 50 gallon (9700). This contractor specifies that a new chimney liner is additional. We already know we need a chimney liner and again from research we need a SS liner as opposed to aluminum when converting from oil to gas. This could end up adding another 1500k to the bid. But if the quality of the boiler is that superior, I'd still consider this guy doing the install.

Contractor 3 - proposes to install one of three Peerless boilers (range 7-11k) - the M1-04 Sprk-N, the PSCII04, or the PF-80-NG. It's unclear to me from the bid or the Peerless website if any of these are modulating. Boilers M1-04 Sprk-N & PSCII04 both propose the BW 40 gallon HW heater, the PF-80 is the Peerless 60 gallon indirect.

Here are some questions; does a smaller home with no zones really need the modulating? What benefit does it really bring? Is a high efficiency system compatible with the radiators we have (one other contractor told me no)? Does a small family benefit from an indirect hook up? IN terms of energy cost, since we have summer/winter hook up our furnace was always running, how often might the boiler run in the dead of summer to maintain its temp?

If there is anything else I'm missing or should consider, please do let me know. And many, many thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (2)

tk03
12 years ago
If your home is 1400 sq ft I am not sure why the boilers and indirect water heaters are so large.
Did any of them measure the home for a heat loss? That is the first step. This does not mean measuring the radiation as that has nothing to do with boiler sizing.
Then choose the boiler size from there.
badgerboilermn
12 years ago
The time a company has been in business is not necessarily a good thing. In this industry, being behind a dozen years or so is considered a good thing.

There are many condensing boilers on the market today and all modulate flame and feature out door reset which will save fuel and increase comfort at once.

I would start over in your search.

http://www.badgerboilerservice.com/contractor.html

As tk03 suggests the boilers look too big for your application. They are only properly sized after a contractor performs a computor-generated heat load analysis.

Boiler contractors should not do this for free, but should provide a sample and bid the job for a condensing boiler sized to the load. The indirect should be the same way.

I perform heat loads and specify many residential natural gas boilers around the US and Canada and always look for local support and factory trained technicians first.

By insisting on a sample of their heat loads you may eliminate 9 of 10 contractors but like a good vinegar it is worth the work.

Here is a link that might be useful: Choosing a residential boiler
Related Discussions
Help! At a loss about how to improve heating (and add cooling)
Q
Comments (9)
Leaks in supply ducts depressurize the building. Leaks in returns make the pressure positive. That sucks outdoor air in, and blows it out, respectively, through any air leak in the house. Note this is for "outdoor" ducts only. If you create fur-downs inside the house envelope, you can tolerate duct leakage. Sucking air in randomly causes a lot of problems in my climate where condensation can readily occur. Central ducted AC systems also tend to cause pressure differentials between rooms unless there is a return in each room. Keep in mind that you will have to undercut each door halfway to your knees unless you have a return in each room or install jump ducts of some sort. Ducts in conventional attics pick up a lot of heat in the summer too. These are all reasons that I installed 7, high wall units in my home in the hot, humid South. Keep in mind that there are other types of mini-splits that do involve shorter duct lengths that might be more easily accommodated by fur-downs. There are also ceiling cassettes.. FSQ4CW, do Al and Fe radiators "require" different temps or are they just sub optimal on the same loop? If the latter, how bad is it really?
...See More
Worthwhile to Convert Oil Boiler to Propane or Not?
Q
Comments (27)
Tekmar control systems have been in use for years now. They have been installed on both residential and commercial projects we were involved with. My understanding is that they have an outdoor reset that monitors the exterior temperature and adjust the boiler temperature to meet the heating needs. If it is cold (0 degrees) they let the boiler fire at max temperature or what ever upper limit that is set. If it is a mild day (45 degrees) that may only allow the boiler to fire to say 145 degrees and provide for a moderate heating temperature. New boilers like Buderus have the option of Logamatic controller which does a similar thing. They will make old boilers more efficient, but new boilers with these controls are even better. Apparently Buderus even makes a oil fired condensing boiler which is 91% efficient. With gas or oil boilers the lower water temperatures can only be reached with these type of boilers as condensation will occur and they are designed for this. If your boiler is good and you install a tekmar you will save money. If you need an upgrade then the new boilers will save on oil consumption, but cost a lot more to buy and install. Tekmar will also control the indirect water heater. These type of boiler controls can prioritize the hot water and fire the boiler at a much higher temperature when hot water is needed. You have a lot of choices from adding controls to your existing system, changing to a new higher efficient boiler with integrated controls, or even going up to a condensing oil boiler with integrated controls. If you are remaining in the house for years to come then maybe replacement in the long run is best. If you don't want to spend a lot of money and still want to save the Tekmar will definitely help and make the house more comfortable. I am not n HVAC contractor, but we have these systems installed on all our projects or they come with new boilers we are installing. I am sure installers can explain better than I can as to exactly how these controllers work. I have a gas fired boiler with outdoor reset built in and it worked great this winter. It is the same principle as the Tekmar and it controls a modulating condensing gas boiler.
...See More
sizing a boiler
Q
Comments (2)
You must have a Manual J calc done to know for sure. Go the website below and follow the links for "Free Heat Loss Calculation" to get the SlantFin CD to estimate it yourself. You probably still want a pro to do his own calculations but this will put you in the ballpark and let you toss out unsuitable tradesmen. Doc Here is a link that might be useful: Here's a site that may help
...See More
System 2000 Gas Conversion
Q
Comments (3)
Hello nellsland, I know this thread is 4 years old but I was wondering how you made out with converting your Energy Kinetics boiler from oil to natural gas? I have the same boiler and am looking to convert it as well. Information about this is pretty scarce on the internet so any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks
...See More

Help selecting boiler for NG conversion

Comments (2)

tk03

badgerboilermn

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US