SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
fish7577

Load calculations for new home Geothermal

fish7577
14 years ago

Please help. I'm builing a new home (or at least planning it). I have 2 quotes for a geothermal system to do forced air on main 2 floors and radiant for the basement + garage. The 2 load calculations, supposedly both using a manual J calculation, differ slightly. One contractor suggests a 4 ton system, the other a 5 ton. I'll list their calculated heating load, cooling load, gains, set points, and delta T. Obviously, I don't want to undersize or oversize the system. Price isn't much different for the 2 systems despite being different sizes. How do I compare these? I assume the gains must be factored in to decide a size? I don't want to be running auxilliary heat with an electric coil unless it's VERY cold. I'm in Pennsylvania, so I shouldn't need it too often.

QUOTE 1: Recommended 5 ton system

Heat load- 62672

Cool load- 36884

Gains- 11704

Heat set point- 72

Cool set point- 75

Delta T 68 and 17

QUOTE 2: Recommended 4 ton system

Heat load- 56617

Cool load- 42000

Gains- 12626

Heat set point- 70

Cool set point- 75

Delta T 70 and 20

Thanks!

Comments (5)