Mitchell Gold vs Lee Ind. vs CR Laine vs RH Sofa
mandomama
13 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (15)
iCustomSofa
13 years agolast modified: 9 years agomandomama
13 years agolast modified: 9 years agoRelated Discussions
Lee Industries Sofa--Better deal using this Forum info
Comments (32)Hi! Dimensions do tell alot of the story. I give you credit for taking the plunge. Enjoy your new sofa! One thing I've learned - from sitting in so many sofas trying to decide - is that each model, even within the same manufacturer, may have a different pillow depth as well as slant to the back part of the frame. For example, alot of Lee's are just too slanted back for my sitting perference. The Norwalk's are less so and 'fit' me better. But I want the hand tied approach Lee uses, so go figure. I've looked at Sherrill, Miles Talbott, Michael Thomas, Isenhour, and a few others. Unfortunately, I have not yet seen in person a high back which works. They are all too deep in the seat (40"). I have narrowed my search to a higher back, approximately 36" deep seat (maybe up to 38"). I've noticed that all the tags for the ones which are too deep are over 38" - still not sure what the depth measurement means, but I have concluded it doesn't account for the back slant. I am continuing my search, if anyone has come across my future couch, please feel free to share where it is! Oh, has anyone bought Norwalk and what do you think of it? They are not 8 way hand tied and that makes me nervous, especially since I want an extra firm seat. Thanks!...See MoreSmith Brothers of Berne - experience with?
Comments (51)I agree with you Nancy. I do not like to post negative things about a business but what you pay for this furniture you should expect a higher quality and I did not want others to go through what we did to get justification. Shave off the pills that would only thin out your material and possibly in time the material will tear. Of course they tell you it's going to look better over time because by letting it go like they want you to then you will have no recourse due to the length of time. We are in our late 60's and have never had a problem with our other furniture purchases. We buy good furniture to last and that is what I thought I was getting when I purchased from an American made company. I also called the company after Smith Bros. refused to do anything with my cushions and the gentleman that I spoke to was very rude before I even got to tell him what I was calling about. He ask me why I was calling them he said the customer is not to call Smith Bros. you are to deal with your furniture company where you made the purchase. When he finally let me explain to him that Smith Bros was telling me that that was the nature of the fabric to look worn I ask him why the other areas of the furniture was fine except for it looked like where the sewing was done on the arms and on the cushions where the material was flattened compared to the rest of the material. He gave me no answer and basically cut me off. I got no where with them. Sad that an all American company will not stand behind their product. I feel that if they know that a material will look worn or will wrinkle they should put that right on the sample that they have on display better yet why offer inferior materials. I pray your situation will be taken care of....See MoreMcCreary Modern vs. Lee Industries sofa
Comments (4)The main difference between McCreary Modern and Lee Industries is that Lee is 8-way hand tied suspension which is more labor intensive and explains the higher cost. 8-way hand-tied is considered the gold standard for sofa suspensions and will typically hold up better than a sinuous spring or webbing suspension. I have been selling Lee Industries for years and have had many repeat customers who are so pleased with their previous Lee pieces they want to purchase again from them - they last for years! Lee does a good job of offering many high-quality, durable fabrics, but alas there are some that get in there that are less then ideal (this would be true for any sofa manufacturer). Make sure you buy from a retailer that knows their stuff so they can point you in the right direction of a fabric that is suitable for your lifestyle. The down cushions I do not recommend unless you want to fluff them daily. Whatever manufacturer you choose try to get an innerspring cushion wrapped in fiber or down - they hold up the best!...See MoreKiln-dried hardwood, 8-way hand-tie, double dowelled glued & screwed
Comments (27)Jan Moyer you are right on the money. Every single manufacturer knows how to build an upholstered piece the right way, it's not a secret and it's not rocket science. However this is a price-driven industry and the consumer demands lower prices, so most these companies respond accordingly. There are only two ways to lower the cost of the build 1) Reduce you labor costs 2) Reduce your material costs. You take it out of the craftsmanship or the materials. A manufacturer will decide what level they want to produce at - and then target the build to that price point. This is very much a time-business as well, so they are always looking for ways to make it faster to save on labor cost to meet target goals. The result is shortcuts and elimination of time-honored techniques and materials. How much can they eliminate in the cost to build is a meeting they have in staff every single week? Dealers demand it because they have the pressure from the retail consumer. However, everything they reduce - takes away from the quality of the build in one form or another. At some point down the line, they're are producing junk that goes to the landfill rather quickly. Companies that are publicly held and traded on the stock market are under enormous pressure to maximize profits for stockholders. Those that are privately held much less so, depending on what the owner wants to do. Best example I know of this is Hancock and Moore, which was started by Jack Glasheen and Jimmy Moore when they were fed up with the cutbacks at Classic Leather in the early 1980's and decided to go out together and build a new company that doesn't take shortcuts. I know both of them quite well personally and they have never wavered in the quest to build the best in the industry and also take care of any issues that may pop up from time to time. They very soon took over from Classic Leather as the # 1 builder in the USA. Jack and Jimmy retired a few years ago and sold the company, but not just to anyone. There were many who wanted to buy it, but they would only sell to someone who has the same beliefs and would continue the legacy of the build. That was Alex Shuford at Century, who runs his companies the same way. That's why H&M is now a part of Rock House Brands, the parent holding company. I don't carry poor or mediocre brands in my store. I know what makes a good piece of furniture in the 34th year of doing this and I build relationships with both my suppliers and customers, not just "make sales". I know that cheap sofas go to the landfill quickly, good ones actually cost less over time as they are serviceable for many years. It's my job to show clients what makes a good piece of furniture and what they are getting for their money so they can make an informed decision. Knowledge is Power. Empower the consumer through education, which is also why I participate in forums like this and run one myself. How strongly do I believe in that? I even have a cut-away of a Hancock and Moore chair in my store that I had custom made to show those interested how its made. Once you know the right way to do it, it's easy to spot the poorly made stuff. For the most part "you get what you pay for" in this industry. - Duane Collie...See Moremiaochi
13 years agolast modified: 9 years agolukesnanny1990
13 years agolast modified: 9 years agodaphne94
13 years agolast modified: 9 years agomandomama
13 years agolast modified: 9 years agokateskouros
13 years agolast modified: 9 years agokcollier5
12 years agolast modified: 9 years agotibbrix
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agowekick
10 years agolast modified: 9 years agoItaliangirl
8 years agoLynn Hymowitz Greenberg
5 years agoLynn Hymowitz Greenberg
5 years agoAmanda Foshee
5 years ago
Related Stories
FURNITUREYour Essential Sofa Buying Guide
Here’s what to consider when looking for a quality sofa that will last
Full Story
User