Home Marketability and Personal Finance Question

22 years ago

Really want to replace my old, outdated windows and can do it for less than $3,700. Godmother thinks I should delay or eliminate the window purchase and instead, focus on paying off my credit card debt of $16,000. She feels I don't have to get the windows replaced now since I don't plan to sell the house in less than 8 years (my planned retirement time). Fortunately, I'm able to pay much more than my minimum credit card monthly amounts and plan to pay for the windows with my $10,000 HELOC. I calculate the credit card debt and HELOC debt can be eliminated in less than 5 years. By the way, the credit card debt was for nothing frivolous. Also, the appraised amount of my house at this time is about $60,000 more than the mortgage debt. I'm sure the new windows (nothing fancy) would increase the marketability of the house, help to make the house less drafty, and may offer a state tax credit. Thanks for your opinion.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

dave_donhoff
22 years ago
Hi Adnemra,

As answered on your crosspost;
http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/realestate/msg1015371022912.html?5

I'd lay out the details specifically, & compare financially...

1) What is your credit card interest rate? (Note, it is NOT tax deductible, so it hits you full force.)
2) What is your HELOC interest rate? (Fully tax deductible, so factor it reduced by your tax bracket,)
3) What is the realistic energy cost savings (if any) in changing out the windows,
4) Are there any local agency or company subsidies for energy-efficient improvements?

Add up the realistic total benefits, and compare against the realistic total costs.
(In any case, you're likely well advised to pay off the credit card balance entirely with the HELOC.)

Cheers,
Dave Donhoff
Just some mortgage guy ;~)

Here is a link that might be useful: Other thread on Homebuyer's
gina_in_fl
22 years ago
You must be having an 'out of mind' experience. Get rid of your CC debt before you even THINK about more debt. Windows ain't worth what you want to do.
Related Discussions
Building a house on owner financed land, with FHA loan?
Q
Comments (11)
Red flags abound: - A newly built house, even a modular, isn't likely to be less expensive than an existing house (much less a "foreclosed shack"). I think you're using some fuzzy math here; for example, you may have underestimated costs in some places. The world just doesn't work this way. - If the FHA people won't loan you any more than the house + 10K, you shouldn't try to stretch yourself farther. Borrowing as much as the bank says you can borrow typically ends with you being house poor ... and you're talking about borrowing more than they say you can afford. - When you talk to the bank, you will have to disclose any other loans you're carrying. If you're doing an owner-finance deal, you must disclose it. That will change your finances and very possibly decrease the amount they're willing to loan you. - What you don't say speaks volumes: You don't say how much cash you have to put down. If the answer is "nothing much", you really can't move forward on this project. My best suggestion: Save. Work, scrimp and save, and then come back and buy the land outright in a couple years. THEN you'll be ready to build the house, and -- yes -- it will still be available. Once-in-a-lifetime deals aren't real.
...See More
Do svgs int rates, stock market change house financing?
Q
Comments (3)
There's usually major volatility around the market as it works through the bottom, so it would often be well to be making ongoing commitments periodically as one felt that the bottom was being developed. Not getting bent out of shape as the values went down again, figuring that, after while, there'd be recovery in quality companies, and the more commitments that one had made on a regular basis through a prolonged bottom, the larger would be the amount eligible for increased value as the market moved ahead again. But I'm not expecting a major move ahead soon, as I think that our difficulties are much deeper than in earlier recessions. If I'd suggested to you, five years ago, that there might be a possibility, in a few years, of GM being at risk of going bankrupt ... you'd have laughed me out of town! And it seems to me that a number of our problems aren't just cyclical ... they're structural: many of these disappearing jobs aren't going to reappear later ... at least, not in our portion of the global economy. Although several here disagree with me, my feeling is that I'd like to get the debt on the house paid off - to be out of debt. But I'd want to have a substantial cushion available in case of emergency, especially in these times of major economic uncertainty, with so many layoffs taking place. Having lived in 22 locations during my 80 years, I've never owned a home, so never had a mortgage. That said - I frequently lack that emergency fund, myself, of 3 - 6 - 9 months' or a year's income in case of major immediate emergency. But I have a credit card, which I almost always pay off in full prior to due date, and a Line of Credit at the bank, fully secured by stocks and mutual funds, which I can draw on to pay off that emergency loan that I'd put on the card. The Line of Credit bore no initiation fee, and there's none for inactivity, either. Would your lender be willing to offer you a Line of Credit, using stock or mutual funds' certificates (could be part of your emergency fund, if you know for sure that your lender will give you an LoC) along with using the equity in your house, while you still had a substantial amount owing on your mortgage? I don't like to borrow for consumption purposes, but I may borrow to invest in quality assets (whatever they may be!), as I have something of ongoing value to show to offset the loan that I owe. If I do borrow for consumption, I want that on a different LoC, as interest on investment loans is deductible ... that for consumption purposes usually is not. Good wishes for making a decision which will please you on an ongoing basis as you choose which path to follow. ole joyful
...See More
Nursing Home Financing
Q
Comments (1)
I am not the person you addressed, but have had some experience. My husband and I saw an estate lawyer when he was first diagnossed with Alzhiemers to see what would happen to me financially if he had to go to a care home. In your situation you would loose everything and that is as it should be since there is no spouse left behind. The only way to save any for your heirs is to take out insurance and the lawyer told me insurance doesn't completely cover the charges. Just be grateful you have some savings when/if you have to go. In my state you can get a private room if you pay your way and when the money runs out you get to keep the private room. If you have no money at all you go immediately to a shared room. Since my husband has a spouse it is different. I will get the house, the car of my choice and half of the assests up to $90,000., that is the cap. SRS will get anything over the $90,000. The attorney said, make sure I don't spend below the $180,000, if I spend one dollar below the $180,000. I will only get to keep $80,000. He also said to spend all over the $180,000. for anything I need/want, new car, prepay funeral, new roof, etc.. He said they will never question it. He also told me how much income I would get to keep, it is a cut, but I am frugal when necessary. The lawyer also said the day my husband is admitted to a care home I am to check in at the SRS office, he even gave me the name of a man to see.
...See More
Question about financing the home repair projects!
Q
Comments (7)
"The cost of renovating the investment property is an expense (current or amortizable), including the costs of financing. Keep all your investment expenses separate from your personal assets. Don't use a HELOC on your primary residence to finance improvements on your investment property." First, expenses do not get amortized. Improvements and replacements adjust your basis, repairs are expensed. If something is being amortized it is not expensed. Next, always use the lowest interest rate available to finance your rental properties. Which is usually a HELOC. It doesn't have any bearing on the deductibility of interest. From the very beginning (March 1989) my rental properties build equity in my residence, my residence then finances the rental properties. The interest is tax deductible but at a better rate than any loan I can get otherwise. The HELOC on my current house, which I have been in for six years, has purchased several properties. Every penny of interest I have paid on the HELOC has been tax deductible. As for risk... Get umbrella insurance. Otherwise the rules for attachment from investment property to residence are pretty nuanced and likely will attach anyway. So, in most states, you are paying higher interest rates for no additional protection.
...See More
joyfulguy
22 years ago
What interest rate are you paying on credit card debt?

Considering that most of the regular cards charge rates around 15 - 18% (most store-issued cards charge 25 - 28%) you should not pay only minimum required monthly payment.

Suppose I loaned you $100.00. I said that you had to pay me $28.00 annually as rent on the money. That'd be before you paid off $1.00 of the loan. You'd swear at me and call me a stinker - and you'd be right.

But many people willing pay stores $28.00 per year as fee for carrying a $100.00 loan.

Not my idea of a good time.

Best save every dollar that you can and pay the card debt(s) off as quickly as possible, paying largest amount on the cards charging highest interest rate.

If possible, find a way to use heavy sheet plastic to make a storm window on the inside of the current windows. If you'd like some ideas about how to do it, email me. If they leak air around the outside of the frame, caulk that area.

Get your dollars working for you, not the store or the bank.

Good wishes as you get your priorities lined up with regard to the bills and proposed window replacement.

joyful guy
CindyBelleZ6NJ
22 years ago
I agree with the above posts, get rid of the credit card debt first; then save what you were paying "more than the minimum" up until you can replace the windows. Think about using anything else you can to make the windows warmer-draft snakes; bubble wrap for those windows that don't face neighbors, maybe the back ones, or the pink styrofoam insulation; maybe cut up some mattress pads and make linings for your drapes, buy shades or mini blinds, cheap, on sale if you don't have anything on the window under your drapes now. I eventually should upgrade my windows as well, but the cost is huge, lots of windows, so I am "making do"; also wearing lots of layers, etc.

Home Marketability and Personal Finance Question

Comments (4)

dave_donhoff

gina_in_fl

Related Discussions

joyfulguy

CindyBelleZ6NJ

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US