skip to main content

Paper bag treatment for concrete basement floor

11 years ago

Have you guys seen any of the web pages talking about covering floors with torn up grocery bags or pieces of brown craft paper? You tear the edges to make a deckled edge, crumple the paper, dunk it in watered down Elmer's glue, then smooth it down on the floor. After it dries, you can stain it if you like, then coat it with multiple coats of polyurethane. Everyone says it makes an inexpensive hard wearing slightly resembling leather flooring.
Many people claim to have done concrete basement floors in it with no problems.

We have a concrete basement floor that has a thin scraped residue of some sort of carpet or vinyl adhesive (very small trowel marks, white In color).

I'd be thrilled to have a smooth durable flooring since I work with stained glass there and the texture that is there, even though very small, still is enough to trap tiny glass shards and make cleanup difficult.
I don't usually like crafty finishes, you are not going to find me sponge painting walls etc, but this finish to my eye doesn't look terrible. Just google paper bag floors, hundreds of examples pop right up.

I know that concrete floors allow moisture to transpire, so does it sound like this could really work? We eventually want to put in heated tile floors, oe a heated concrete floor, or maybe eventually some sort of hardwood. So I don't want to find out down the road that my cheap crafty solution has actually caused a much bigger problem.

Thoughts? Could this work and be durable? Will it cause a problem with future options?

Thanks for any help!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

glennsfc
11 years ago
Anything you apply on the substrate at this point must come off when you change your flooring...except if you replace it with a floating floor of some kind, most of which I personally don't like. Floating floors are not adhered to the substrate, so there are no bonding issues.

I don't know how this would work either, because you are correct in stating that all concrete slabs emit moisture, especially those installed on or below grade.
User
11 years ago
I'll second glennsfc's answer. Those were my concerns exactly.
Related Discussions
New concrete in basement gets damp.
Q
Comments (1)
There are several possible causes of the dampness. To begin with, new concrete contains a lot of water that will evaporate over the years. Secondly, the drains may be overwhelmed by the flow during heavy rains. Or there may not be enough slope to the sump outlet. Finally, the drains may have been laid with the drain holes up rather than down, so a lot of water may be sitting there. Mould is literally everywhere. A damp portion of the concrete doesn't cause mould; it just provides the moisture that mould needs to grow and multiply. Runnng a dehumidifier may help to dry out these sections.
...See More
X-post flooring, paper bag floors
Q
Comments (5)
Here's my understanding of how concrete floors behave. Concrete does pull moisture up, and when it's unimpeded, the moisture (unless it's excessive) dissipates into the air. If untreated and unprotected framing goes down on a concrete floor, it can rot. Flooring laid on concrete without a vapor barrier under the framing and some air space between will eventually fail. Polyurethane isn't a waterproofer. It can keep water out from the top of a coated surface, so long as the water isn't allowed to stand for long, but water coming up through concrete will cause polyurethane to lift and peel. So I would doubt that paper, water glue, and polyurethane on a below-grade concrete floor would be anything but a colossal mess after one or two seasons. If someone knows better, please enlighten us!
...See More
Best/good cement patch for basement floor?
Q
Comments (3)
Thanks, I want to fill a gap between a floating slab that is in very good shape and the cement block wall that is also in very good shape. There are no water problems, but my Radon is a bit high. I figure filling the gap will reduce the inflow of Radon, I need to get the count down only a couple of points. Again, there is no water problem. The walls have a modern footing and "French Drain" with a gravity feed "sump" line (comes out down the hill below the footing level).
...See More
Rain on freshly poured concrete basement floor. What should I do?
Q
Comments (5)
Thanks for suggestion about epoxy. In the room that was supposed to be just concrete floor, our builder was not planning to do any treating, coating, or texturing - I didn't realize this was a safety concern and am surprised it wasn't mentioned. So, regarding the safety texture created by the rain, are you saying because of this an epoxy installer could (and would be willing to) skip a step, hopefully reducing the price?
...See More
User
11 years ago
Crap idea that will create nothing but problems down the road.
gregmills_gw
11 years ago
Although i agree with everyone above. I guess my concern would be the number of coats of poly you would need to lay down?

Doing this type of "craft" idea is solely because its easy and cheap? Well it seems like just painting the slab would be easier and probably cheaper ( in the long end)
doug_gb
11 years ago
What a potential mess. Paper bags and Elmers gule - does this idea come with a warranty? Just think you are sealing papber bags to the slab. If you get moisture under there the paperbags desintergrate.

It's going to take considerable Elmers and poly. I bet you could install some water based epoxy floor paint for the same price.
kiki_thinking
Original Author
11 years ago
Thank you for the feedback : ). I just really wanted a cheap smooth surface, it did sound too good to be true..
pbarky
10 years ago
I have now done two rooms with concrete subfloors using this paper method. My floors are not completely smooth, probably due to my application. I used 10 coats of water based poly for sealant. It is very slippery which is my major concern. I used contractor paper from Home Depot and an Elmer's glue water mixture. I used a little over 1 Gallon of glue and less than a roll of paper and less than a gallon of poly for a 12x12 room. The appeal of this method is the cost and look. I didn't want the look of a painted floor. This looks similar to leather or stained concrete. I won't do a floating floor because of pets. For me, it is a temporary fix for FILTHY carpet which smelled. I'm hoping to get a few years out of it. The labor is extensive. I had to pull carpet nails and scrape and prep the floors. The papering itself is time consuming too. But I am extremely pleased with the outcome. I scraped my floor with a putty knife after papering and before applying poly to search for loose spots and knock down wrinkles. The paper came up off the concrete fairly easily pre-poly. I can't imagine it would be any worse than scraping all the carpet adhesive was. I may have a mess down the road--only time will tell. For now it is a very low budget but attractive fix for the nasty carpet.

Related Stories

GREEN BUILDING Considering Concrete Floors? 3 Green-Minded Questions to Ask

By Melanie Loftus

Learn what’s in your concrete and about sustainability to make a healthy choice for your home and the earth

FLOORS Know Your Flooring: Concrete

By Rebecca Gross

Concrete floors have a raw and elegant beauty that can be surprisingly warm

FLOORS 5 Benefits to Concrete Floors for Everyday Living

By Natalie Myers

Get low-maintenance home flooring that creates high impact and works with home styles from traditional to modern

MATERIALS 10 Cool Things to Do With Concrete in Your House

By Susan Redman

Humble concrete is being reinvented in everything from bathroom fixtures to lampshades

STAIRWAYS The Upstairs-Downstairs Connection: Picking the Right Stair Treatment

By Laura Gaskill

Carpeting, runner or bare wood? Check out these ideas for matching your staircase floor treatment to upstairs and downstairs flooring

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen Details: Out-of-Sight Paper Towel Holder

By Mary Jo Bowling

See how some homeowners are clearing the counter of clutter while keeping this necessity close at hand

LIFE The Absolute Right Way to Hang Toilet Paper. Maybe

By Mitchell Parker

Find out whether over or under is ahead in our poll and see some unusual roll hangers, shelves and nooks

KITCHEN DESIGN Super Backsplashes to Pair With Recycled-Paper Counters

By Becky Harris

Aesthetics and personal ethics come together for most folks who opt for this eco-friendly material

CONCRETE Why Concrete Wants to Crack

By Matt Clawson

We look at the reasons concrete has a tendency to crack — and what you can do to help control it

KITCHEN COUNTERTOPS Kitchen Counters: Concrete, the Nearly Indestructible Option

By Ivon Street Studio

Infinitely customizable and with an amazingly long life span, concrete countertops are an excellent option for any kitchen

Sponsored

More Discussions

Coretec Conch Ash, need pictures & review of this flooring

7

What type of oak is this?

8

Need your help fining the right direction to install my vinyle planks

2

Help - Hardwood floor mystery!

8

Transition strips at a three way

2