New Geothermal System Installed

14 years ago

The crew just left after completing the install of the ClimateMaster Tranquility system with a Marathon waterheater hooked up to the system. At the very least we will save about $1200.00 ( 2008 prices) a year on propane (hot water & furnace) and we will have to wait and see about how the electric bill looks. It should break even in about 5-6 years. The old system was taking us in the wrong direction.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

geothermalexpt
14 years ago
That's great! Do you like your new systems so far? It should be quieter, have better humidity control, and reduce your bills. Best of luck to you!

Here is a link that might be useful: Geothermal Experts
gpaintjr
Original Author
14 years ago
So far.... Highs in the mid to high 70's lows around 60. Loving the weather but not much opportunity to check out this system. Maybe next week. Looking forward to all the benefits you listed. Thanks
Related Discussions
Geothermal Hot Water +/- On Demand +/- Circulation System
Q
Comments (7)
Who thought hot water could be so complicated huh? Iam doing a similar set up right now except we are using a heat pump water heater as the main/back up. Highly recommend you look into them if you have the appropriate climate and space. Be aware that the Desuperheaters usually only produce measurable hot water during the cooling cycle which could be seldom depending on climate and efficiency of the building envelope. If you go tankless (personally not a fan in most situations) be sure its capable of handling pre-heated water. Holding or Buffering tank is a good idea no matter what the back up tank is. A cheap electric storage without the power hooked up is fine. I would add insulation to the tank(s) and absolutely insulate ALL hot water lines as much as possible. Obviously, energy use matters to you so be very careful with how you set up a circulating pump. A manual or occupancy switch located in the farthest bathroom is the best bet. Continuous circulating pumps could easily end up burning more energy than what youre saving with the Geo. I would also recommend monitoring the energy use of the circulating pump for the Geo. COPs usually ignore this part of the equation. Check out the below link and do someother keyword searches. Here is a link that might be useful: GBA link geo + tank Q &A
...See More
geothermal residental system
Q
Comments (4)
Sounds like you have an ideal set up for geothermal. Try asking for information on the www.geoexchange.org forums, quite a few professionals are on there and will give you solid advice. I know that a few do pond loops all the time because they talk about them. And, some live in florida and the south so could give you tips as well. As for me, I live in a coastal area in the northeast and my vertical ground loops go through a mix of sand and gravel, but it sure looks like sand to me when it gets drilled. My loops work very well. I LOVE my geothermal system. It was just put in in late December and has kept our house so warm and cosy.
...See More
Geothermal System with backup heater
Q
Comments (5)
yup I live in the mid-atlantic region and a backup to my GT is a must. When we lose power in the winter (usually ice related) we can be without GT for a day or more. When temps are in the teens, you want heat. We didn't have the gas second stage heat as an option for the GT, so we went with a wood burning fireplace insert that is rated as heater. My gas fireplaces are also rated as heaters but the single wood burner is all I need to keep the house warm enough. I have a small backup generator that provides enough power for the controls and internal fans on all fireplaces as well as portable fans that we use to move the warm air around the house. Regardless of your backup heat approach, you will need a power generator to drive the HVAC fans, tstats, and controls on the gas unit - or fans on the fireplaces. You won't need a lot of power but you have to figure that cost into the equation. You could also look at putting in a whole house backup generator to drive the GT heat pumps but when I looked at that option, the generator size was just too large and that would have cost a lot more than the backup approach we put in.
...See More
Avoid Econar Energy Geothermal Systems
Q
Comments (2)
Woke up today realizing that since we had our system installed (August of 2010) we have had virtually no colds, no static, no hot noisy AC on the patio, and our fuel consumption is much less than our "most efficient neighbors" according to Xcel Energy. We do utilize the heat byproduct to raise the temp in the water heater (not to heat it to hot). We have been very pleased with the system. Our system has 4 vertical bore lines mostly into sandy soil (ideal, as we are on a lake). From your description it sounds like your system is more complex. We have had no issues with it. Knock on wood! I was going to share my thoughts on FB and link to Econar when I saw your comment. Just thought you would like to hear that there are satisfied Econar people out here. I am sorry your experience was not a good one. (BTW I am not connected to the company in any way, just a customer.)
...See More
formerlyflorantha
14 years ago
How is the system faring now?
sunnyflies
14 years ago
I just put in a geothermal system, a six ton Waterfurnace Envision with a desuperheater and with vertical ground loops, this past December 2009 and I am thrilled with it! I saved $4000, maybe more over what it had cost us to heat our house for the past two winters with oil.

The system was expensive, and I thought long and hard about getting it, but I am very glad I did. Our house has never stayed so warm and cosy, the system is much quieter than our old oil furnace had been and it's so nice to know that there is no flame burning downstairs, plus I will never have an oil truck leave me a bill again. Now, that's priceless!
marc1583
13 years ago
I am looking at installing a system, I live in northeastern part of Florida. Our city water is very hard, I just had a 500 foot well drilled for my irrigation, but have not had the water test yet. I had a couple companies give me a quote on a system. One wanted to use the irrigation well for the water and drill a new well for the return water. This company made a comment that the system coils will get covered with minerals, but made it seem like it was not a big deal to have him come out and clean it. The second company wanted to use a closed loop system because of the mineral in the water and he made it seem that it is not that easy or cheap to clean. He said, if it was his house he might go for the pump and dump, because he knows how to work on the system, but he would recommend a closed loop for anyone else.

What is everyone thought or comments on Pump & Dump vs a closed loop with about 4 or 5 well points?

Marc
fsq4cw
13 years ago
Closed loop will be more reliable, require less energy to pump, require less maintenance and a longer, more trouble free life cycle.

SR
marknmt
13 years ago
SR is right of course. I have an open loop system and even though I'm only lifting the water 60 feet or so it costs almost as much to run the well pump as the Tranquility. If you have to lift it 500 feet it would be expensive.

I do circulate dilute hydrochloric acid through the coils once a year on the advice of my installer. It isn't hard to do and only takes half an hour or so, but eventually I'll probably end up paying somebody to do it for me.

I'd definitely go closed loop if at all feasible, which it just wasn't for me.

Good luck,

Mark
sunnyflies
13 years ago
After struggling with the cost factors, I decided to use a closed loop because our water is hard also, lots of calcium, manganese and iron. I'm glad I did as I have heard a number of stories about people in my area who went with an open loop and have had mineral build up problems.

Closed loops are more expensive, so that is a real consideration, but I decided I'd rather have a loop system that lasted for 50 years than pay to have the coils cleaned yearly and still have to have them replaced every so often. Got to be expensive, plus they might fail at the worst possible times.
Marc Well
4 years ago
Like any system, there are geothermal energy pros and cons. The hardest thing to accept about a geothermal heat pump system is that the average cost of initial installation is higher, and a good bit so, than a traditional central system or even an air source heat pump. It’s this upfront cost that steers many buyers away.

IS A GEOTHERMAL SYSTEM WORTH THE INVESTMENT?

Geothermal heat pumps are the most efficient. A high-efficiency furnace or central system achieves around 90-98% efficiency on fuel or energy consumption. That’s pretty good, for sure. But geothermal? 300% or more efficiency! How does that work, you might wonder? Well, the number cited represents the amount of thermal energy being generated per use of unit of fuel, which in the case of a geothermal heat pump, means that they are generating more than they are using, whereas a furnace, even of the highest caliber, doesn’t quite use the fuel source to 100%.

A geothermal heat pump saves on heating and cooling costs. Your average home equipped with a geothermal heat pump will save around 10-15% per month on heating and cooling costs, and in many cases that percentage is much higher. That means over time your geothermal system begins to pay for itself!
ulisdone
4 years ago
Yeah, in about 300 years...

New Geothermal System Installed

Comments (10)

geothermalexpt

gpaintjr
Original Author

Related Discussions

formerlyflorantha

sunnyflies

marc1583

fsq4cw

marknmt

sunnyflies

Marc Well

ulisdone

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

New Geothermal System Installed

Comments (10)

gpaintjrOriginal Author

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

gpaintjr
Original Author