need input on bathroom plans

15 years ago

Hi all,

This is my first post in the bathroom forum. We're just about to start on a remodeling project that involves our kitchen, dining room, laundry room and powder room. In fact, demo was supposed to start today, but has been pushed back to Friday.

I have been so obsessed with our kitchen plans for the past 4 months that I've barely given our bathroom a second thought, and all of a sudden I'm realizing I have to get serious about the bathroom. I made some good progress this week, and here's what I've purchased so far:

This is the medicine cabinet:

From Last Import

This is the light fixture (with white opal bell shades):

From Last Import

And this is the sink. It's a Kohler Bancroft, and a very close match to an original sink in our 1910 home.

From Last Import

Where I'm getting stuck is with the wall and floor tile. Due to an error made by the guy who ordered our master bath tile, we have a whole bunch of white, brown and black hex tiles left over from that project, and we'd like to use the black and white ones in the powder room. I would also like to use honed carrara subway tiles on the wall, and we will only be tiling the 40" wide niche that the sink will sit within.

Here are my main questions:

1) While I've seen lots of people use white ceramic subways on the walls and marble on the floors, I haven't been able to find the reverse (carrara on the walls and black/white ceramic on the floors) as we'd be doing. Do you think it would look OK?

2) Since we'll only be tiling the sink niche, rather than all the walls, I'm not sure how to handle the baseboard issue. There is a 6" coordinating marble skirting we could use in the niche, but the wood baseboards throughout the house are 10" deep. Should we just put the field tiles on top of a wood baseboard and skip the skirting? Or should we nix the baseboard and carry the skirting onto the non-tiled walls? Any other ideas?

3) Another issue with the sink niche is that the two parallel walls aren't equal lengths, and I can't figure out if we should tile them as is, or if we should bring the tile on the longer wall just equal with the shorter wall. (This would actually simplify the placement of the light switch and an outlet since they wouldn't have to be in the field tile.) Another thought I had was that maybe we could just tile the wall the sink sits against, and not the two side walls. Here's a drawing that hopefully better illustrates my dilemma:
{{gwi:1502434}}From Last Import

This last photo is the only one I had that shows the border and field tile of our master bath - this is the tile we have available to use in the powder room. I could do a simple black border and/or replicate the "flowers" (visible in mirror) in the powder room, but I worry that the flowers might be too much in such a tiny space. I don't know...

I'd be grateful for any input.

From Last Import

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

plants4
15 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
I can see no reason why having the marble on the walls and the hex tile on the floor would be an aesthetic problem. It sounds very nice.

I'm not sure what I would do with the baseboard/skirting issue (the one thing I haven't decided for my own under construction bathroom yet) but I think I would work from the following: (1) ease in cleaning in a tight space (argues for the marble); (2) leaving some blank space between the marble and the floor tile (just my aesthetic preference -- argues for no marble skirting); (3) continuity issues (at the very least, use the same thing throughout the bathroom). OK, so what I get out of that is a total toss-up! Sorry.

As for your last question, I'm sure others will have their opinions but the first question I would have is what the edge of the marble will look like. If it were a bullnose tile then it seems leaving some space between the wall tile and the door would be fine, even a good idea as you point out for the light switch. If it's not bullnose, then it would look better butted up against the door casing.

I'm wondering if you should just eliminate the marble on the wall altogether and put something simple (white 4x4 or subway) behind the sink niche or just a little tile above the sink? This might be a better approach if you have a fancy floor anyway in such a small space to avoid visual overload.
pepperidge_farm
15 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
1) While I've seen lots of people use white ceramic subways on the walls and marble on the floors, I haven't been able to find the reverse (carrara on the walls and black/white ceramic on the floors) as we'd be doing. Do you think it would look OK?

Sounds nice to me...

2) Since we'll only be tiling the sink niche, rather than all the walls, I'm not sure how to handle the baseboard issue. There is a 6" coordinating marble skirting we could use in the niche, but the wood baseboards throughout the house are 10" deep. Should we just put the field tiles on top of a wood baseboard and skip the skirting? Or should we nix the baseboard and carry the skirting onto the non-tiled walls? Any other ideas?

I think you could go either way, but as this is a powder room and not a "wet" bathroom, I think the wood baseboard would look nice all around. I tend to think that a tile base often looks like one didn't want to spend the $$ to tile the whole room (the areas on the untiled walls), IMHO.

3) Another issue with the sink niche is that the two parallel walls aren't equal lengths, and I can't figure out if we should tile them as is, or if we should bring the tile on the longer wall just equal with the shorter wall.

Well, again, I don't think any of the above are wrong. I think I would go with the symmetry of the tile being equal on both sides due to the configuration of the room.

fern4 mentions the finish edge... you would need a trim piece or bullnose, I think, but you probably have that worked out already ;-) Nice choices!
Related Discussions
Bathroom remodel input needed
Q
Comments (5)
At first glance, what about moving your tub to the opposite wall and put a nice long vanity where your tub is now. Agree that area with the TV just doesn't work. I would play with this a bit more with paper cut outs and a scaled graph. It helps to move stuff around that way. Also keep in mind some areas need a certain amount of clearance to work properly. I would try and move toilet if you could somewhere else. It's kinda just sticking out there. Look into moving doors and/or moving into closets. You mentioned your on a budget, before you get too in love with a freestanding tub, do a little on-line shopping on that it's a budget buster.
...See More
Bathroom Add-on / Remodel - Input needed
Q
Comments (8)
The 5 foot turning radius is only important for public access. If a person needs a wheelchair, it is always possible for the person to get a zero turning radius wheelchair, so only a 32" turning radius is needed. More important is a roll-in threshold for the shower, adequate access for the toilet area, and either a door that opens outward or a sliding door for the toilet compartment. Also allow for a roll-up sink. When I remodeled my bathroom, I added a sink to the toilet compartment that could easily be replaced with a roll-up sink should the need arise. Another thing to consider is to allow for things like soap and shampoo and other shower toiletries to be accessible to someone in a seated position.
...See More
I need some input on remodelling SIX bathrooms!
Q
Comments (29)
I put in a curbless wheel chair accessible shower in my only fill bathroom. I had my builder add a floor drain to the room to act as backup in case the shower ever floods. THAT is what you should do if you want a curbless shower in a rental. BTW, I recently did overflow my shower for the first time. My brand new thick cotton mat was between the shower and the floor drain. It was so heavy with water that I could just barely lift it onto the grab bar in the shower to let it drip dry. Two days later, I had to hang it outside in the sun to get it dry. What did I do to flood outside of the shower? I am not sure! I suppose I could have let the hand sprayer turn toward the curtain. Or maybe the big wad of hair that I had peeled off my fingers that had crossed between the shower floor and the room floor had made a bridge for the water to follow. I have been shedding a lot of hair lately and it has gotten quite long during the stay-at-home time. Whichever it was, I have not had so much water leave the shower before. My trench drain is in the front of the shower, between the shower floor and the room floor. But it would not take long for a clogged wall-side trench drain to let water leave the shower, either. A trench drain is no different than a single middle drain, it just has a long, skinny collection trench on top of the drain hole. I would not put one in a rental unit. Another way to have an even more foolproof shower is to get a solid surface (like Corian) shower pan. Since they can be installed in a day, the money you spend on a higher price material can be offset by lower installation cost. Corian walls are also foolproof. The cleaning people can’t hurt it. Any scratches that happen (though it is not easy to scratch) can be buffed out in place. No grout lines. No mold or mildew. Waterproof and it does not fail. See if you can see a Corian or Swanstone shower in a local showroom. Swanstone has some nice patterns now, too. You can get a white-on-white granite look, white with colored specks, or a white and gray swirl. Here is a link https://swanstone.com/en/collections-and-finishes/collections/swanstone to their site. People with Swanstone and Corian showers say that they look the same as the day they were installed twenty years later. Be aware that Swanstone Veritek is not the same as their solid surface Swanstone product. It is fiberglass, I think. At least consider a true solid surface shower.
...See More
Design input needed bathroom- window and mirror trim
Q
Comments (3)
Looks great but I would have wanted another layer of lighting.
...See More
slateberry
15 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Well, I looked online and it's not up yet, but the bhg september 2008 issue has a bathroom on page 52 (in an article called Retro Fit) that has a subway carrara shower surround, subway walls, and white hex floor with black and gray accents. It looks very nice to me and I think your bathroom will too.

I was thinking of doing carrara subway walls and tub surround, white hex with carrara hex custom mosaic on the floor, dark wood vanities with carrara tops, and dark stained wood door and moldings. I might switch to ceramic subways and just settle for a few hexes and the countertops in carrara at the rate my budget is getting burned, but if not, I will post pics when it's done.

Your master bath is STUNNING. Could you please add a couple more photos to this thread; they will come up in searches for years to come, and I think it's such a great example of what can be done with hex tiles. And great wainscoting. And well-coordinated hardware choices. And a dropped accent rail, and....

As soon as I saw the picture of your master bath, I thought, this poster has such good instincts, whatever you choose to do in the powder room will surely come out looking great. I hope you post photos of your kitchen too.
scalawag
13 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Can you please tell me the brand of your sinks and the stands they sit in? I love this!

need input on bathroom plans

Comments (4)

plants4

pepperidge_farm

Related Discussions

slateberry

scalawag

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US