Advice / Recommendations needed for remodel (48' range)

16 years ago

Hi all! I'm so glad I found this site. As all of you know, researching high-end appliances is tough... so hard to find any real reviews / experiences.

We are remodeling our late 70's lakeside house, and completely gutting the kitchen. My wife and I, while not pros, cook a lot, and really enjoy it. We entertain often (6-10 people), so capacity and performance are a must in the products we choose.

We've pretty well decided on Electrolux Icon for our speed oven / micro... and a wall oven (if we end up needing one). Our in-laws have these items, and we've all been very pleased with them.

We are strongly considering the Electrolux Twin all-fridge / all-freezer with separate trim kits. While the build isn't as sturdy as some others we've looked at, the appearance, capacity, and price are in-line with what we want.

This leaves us with the biggie... the range. We had initially decided upon the Electrolux icon 48". It looks nice, has the great ovens, and is reasonably priced. However, I have not been able to find anything discussing reliability / user experiences.

Next, I saw a La Corneu... oh my! While we can't afford one, it did bring up the idea of getting a "funky" range (traditional, old-world style). AGA is a choice, but the oven sizes scare off my wife. Corneu Fe is a thought, but my wife again is nervous. I personally like the Lacanche, and after reading all the reccs here on this one, this is my emotional favorite. (Volnay). Con: Pricey, ? service issues (only one US dealer, etc)

I had never heard of Blue Star, but everyone here seems enthusiastic about it. We're looking at this one.. Con: Pricey.

Finally, there is the least expensive option, from a household brand. Jenn-Air pro-style 48" range. Pros: Easily serviced. Cons: Don't know... no reviews, reccs.

So, what do you guys think? What would you get in the 48" size, $10k or less?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

jab913
16 years ago
I can tell you that I pretty much was having the same dilemna. In my case I chose the Capital 48". Since price was also a major consideration I had to weigh out my options. In my case I decided to order their Precision model but without the self cleaning feature. Of course I do not get the rotisserie either. These were trade offs for the price. You can have these and still be under the $10k price. Basically I found that for a little more than the JennAir I was able to get what I felt was a better value. Unfortunately I am unable to give you any feedback as to how well my decision has gone since I have not yet reached the point of installation for my new range.
soshh
16 years ago
Is the Bluestar MORE expensive than the Lacanche? That surprises me. I remember a recent thread where I read the 48 bluestar was about $7500. I am curious about this as well, esp. one with the grill and griddle.

The Lacanche, I believe is higher, plus there's also the shipping charges.

I don't know much about the Electrolux or the Jenn-Air. We had the 30 inch Jenn-Air dual-fuel downdraft in our old house and I liked the oven but felt the burners weren't powerful enough. It came with a grill top that heated very uneven. I loved the concept and that's why I'd seriously consider a grill on a 48 range for our reno.

The Aga 6-4 lists at about $8500, but it seems they can be found for a little less.

Of all the ones above, I love the look of the Lacanche but think the price is a little too high for us. The Bluestar, from what I've read, would be a very good option.

Other, possibly less expensive options might be the Capital Precision and the American Range. I am not sure how these price out.
Related Discussions
need advice on buying a range hood for my 48' bluestar
Q
Comments (3)
Unless you have a grill, I wouldn't sweat the particular fan unit or CFM's. A good large hood, yes, and quiet on the lower speeds, but I have a feeling that the diameter of the duct (larger is better) and how it exits the home is more important than the brand. If you like to grill fatty meats, then a fan hood becomes a very important subject.. Including the 'capture area' over the cooktop, and the blower power. Some of the items people like to 'grill' on top, cook very nicely under the broiler in the oven, and it helps to keep down the smoke.
...See More
Please recommend a 48" range for me!
Q
Comments (5)
Hey julie1973 Ã¢ÂÂ¦your description sounds pretty much like my life too! I might do a bit more baking, but the rest is just right! We just finished a big renovation, and I installed a 48" GE Monogram 6 burner/griddle dual fuel. I am so, so happy with it. I'd not had gas before, and I LOVE it! I've only put 2 burners to work at one time right now (we tend to grill outside a bit during the summer!), but the control is great. The clean up has been super easy thus far. I love the ovens - we mostly use the smaller one, but I've used the big one a few times. I love having the options. Functionally, it seems to work great. Aesthetically, it makes me smile. There wasn't a lot of information or reviews on it, so I just crossed my fingers. So glad it all worked out! Below is a link to our kitchen thread. Good luck! Here is a link that might be useful: Garage to Kitchen Reveal
...See More
Need some kitchen remodel advice/recommendation
Q
Comments (1)
A few suggestions to get you some replies: -include a picture of your cabinets showing style and stain color. What are you considering staining or repainting them to? Do you want white or black cabinets or some other color? Either one might look nice with blue eye granite. What is your style? You might have seen them already but do a search on the forum for painting or staining cabinets and you will find photos of people's kitchens who have done it, and even instructions. -do some research about faucets by looking at some faucets online and then repost when you have an idea of what you like and ask a more specific question. Do you like pull out, pull down, separate sprayer, deck mount or wall mount, modern or antique styles, etc.? Many people have trouble finding a faucet they like even when they know all those things. Ask about particular faucets you like and do searches for those faucets on this forum. Many people who have them will tell you why they chose them, if they would get them again, pros and cons, etc. There are hundreds of faucets in satin nickel available. Good luck. Sue
...See More
Advice needed: Island range hood for 48 inch bluestar cooktop
Q
Comments (6)
dueceluxe I'm not sure if you ever got an answer to your question, but I'm going to chime in because in 2008 I was in the same boat. We have a 48" BlueStar in a 12' island, with a prep sink located about 48" away, which is where I spend my prep time. Frankly I wish people would focus on answering the direct questions, vs. lecturing about what percentage of prep/cook/cleanup time people "should" be spending in their kitchens, or in which direction they should be facing when doing so. The OP stated they were looking for an island hood for their cooktop, not IF they should be putting the cooktop in the island. For us personally, my prepping and cooking is very intertwined, and we entertain a lot. Ergo, I want to be facing my guests while prepping AND cooking, and not facing my guests during cleanup (THAT sink is behind the prep area against a wall), so the cooktop in the island is what we did and we (and guests) LOVE it and wouldn't go back. It's not for everyone, but it's definitely right for me. Having said all that, yeah, sadly the hood is going to be expensive. We went with a Best by Broan IEX222 51" with a 1500 CFM externally mounted blower. The pros are that the thing will suck up ANYTHING at full speed. The con is that we've had it for 7 years, and unfortunately have gone through 4 control modules or transformers on the thing (everything on it stops working). So nn my frustration I'm now researching replacement hoods, which is going to be $$. It's the price you pay for the style you want. Currently evaluating Cavaliere and Imperial 54" hoods....
...See More
alywa
Original Author
16 years ago
Soshh

The Bluestars vary a lot in price. Overall, it is less than the Lacanche, but to get an all-burner top (8 burners) it jacks it up a lot. I can't imagine using a griddle, and the grill option sounds messy to me. We have a nice Weber gas grill, as well as a Big Green Egg smoker, so it would be a rare occurrence for me to grill indoors.

As far as Capital Precision or American: Are these any good? What about DCS?
soshh
16 years ago
Capital Precision and American have started receiving quite a bit of airtime on Gardenweb as of late. Much of what I have read on both of these has been positive.

DCS is another one I don't see mentioned too often.

Re: the griddle...I realized there are quite a bit of things I cook on flat pans that I could use the griddle for. My kids love "hibachi" shrimp, and obviously there's the breakfast thing...pancakes, french toast, eggs, etc. We have a weber grill too, and I love doing veggies, salmon, etc. (Don't eat meat or cook it much.) but if it's just our family doing it inside (esp. in the winter months) would save me a lot of footwork. A recent thread had a lot of people mentioning they do like grilling on the bluestar. I do enjoy grilling outdoors now though, esp. because my kitchen is horrid!

How have you gotten specific pricing info? Have you called around? Most of the sites don't list prices off the bat.
coleen3201118
16 years ago
FWIW I got the Capital Precision 48" self clean/rotisserie - with griddle for $7999.
julier1234
16 years ago
I have the Capital Precision 48" self/clean with grill. I have yet to try the grill and will let you know how well that works. We had a custom hood made for it because of a location issue in our kitchen. I heard from GC that the hood will be installed within the next week or so (most likely "or so" [sigh]). Since that grill (which is adjustable from lite to high) is one of the main reasons we bought the Precision, we are very curious to see if it lives up to the hype. As far as the rest of the range goes, the ovens have worked well and the SS top is extremely easy to keep clean (easier than I was afraid of).

I have not used any of the other ranges suggested. I was tempted by the Bluestar burners, but Capital had more features for the money including windows on both ovens (I do not like windowless ovens).

Last night I was thinking about what I don't like about the range. I do wish it had some sort of signal when the oven temp reaches the desired temp. It is silent and kind of a hassle to go check to see if the light is on or off.

Oh yes, another thing I do like is that my oven door/handle and knobs stay cool at all times.

Advice / Recommendations needed for remodel (48' range)

Comments (6)

jab913

soshh

Related Discussions

alywa
Original Author

soshh

coleen3201118

julier1234

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Advice / Recommendations needed for remodel (48' range)

Comments (6)

jab913

soshh

Related Discussions

alywaOriginal Author

soshh

coleen3201118

julier1234

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

alywa
Original Author