skip to main content

Love my new, QUIET Sub Zero

11 years ago

After reading so many posts on this forum about annoyingly noisy refrigerators I was really worried when the time came to replace our 25 year old Sub Zero 501R. It was getting a frost buildup inside on the rear panel where the coils are located. We managed to use it for a few months by using a hair dryer weekly to melt the ice but that soon became tiresome. The estimate to repair the leak in the sealed system was around $1100 since it was a 2 man job and the freon had to be recovered. Initially we thought we'd repair it since it had a wood panel that matched the cabinets and a new unit would be taller requiring the removal of the upper cabinet. However we've been in our home for 30 years and now that DH is retired we might be downsizing so replacing the unit made more sense from a resale point.

The new refrigerator is a BI 36R. This model has one large door with 5 shelves and 3 drawers that glide in and out smoothly. It's well lit inside and QUIET. We were concerned about the possible noise level but I can honestly say that we don't even hear when it cycles on and off. Our kitchen is large with a porcelain floor and granite counters and minimal sound absorbing materials.

The BI 36 R is 84h x 36w x 24d while the old 501R was only 74" tall. The 501 freezer is on the opposite wall rather than a side by side install so we didn't have to deal with mismatched units. And it was relatively easy to remove the overhead cabinet and trim the gap between the unit and soffit. Fortunately our cabinet company can mill a new door panel and stain it to match the rest of the cabinets.

I think the 501s were the only counter depth all refrigerator/all freezer units available when we remodeled in 1986. Now the consumer has many more choices and it can become overwhelming. So far we're thrilled with our choice. Now if only it will last another 25 years!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

friedajune
11 years ago
Vey nice review! Thanks! I wish I could fit an all-fridge in my kitchen, but I can live vicariously through you :))
jakvis
11 years ago
Hi maire_cate
Glad to hear you like your new Sub Zero as they are nice machines.
However whoever the service tech was that told you that the refrigerator has a freon leak owes you an appology and your money back!!!
If the unit had a freon leak your refrigerator would not have been frosting up on the rear evaporator cover. It would have had zero frost on the back wall and no need for using a hair dryer to melt the ice. Also if there was a freon leak there would have been no refrigerant to recover since it all leaked out.
At most you had a bad defrost timer, defrost heater, or defrost limit switch. This would have been a 1 man job and cost under $200. to repair. Your description of the issue was exellent and could have been used to semi diagnose the refrigerator over the phone so the tech could bring the right parts to fix it in one trip.
Sorry to give you this bad news but maybe you can get a refund from the service company for botching the diagnosis.
Related Discussions
New Sub Zero Models
Q
Comments (24)
our model is the bI36R/s and the bI36F/S We had on order for 8 months the monogram all freezer and fridge but changed when they came out with announcement. We ordered these about 6 weeks ago fully expecting them to come in October. To our surprise they came in early. We are in California and bought them thru Pacific Sales. I love the looks of them! :)
...See More
New Noisy Sub-Zero
Q
Comments (28)
Hi what was your resolution? We also just got a brand new 18” Column freezer and it runs almost constantly and so very noisy. We’ve had technician out three times. They replaced the control board but nothing changed. We’re really hose to have spent $9K on a freezer that never shuts off. We can even hear it downstairs.
...See More
Is it Crazy to miss my Sub Zero! Moving, need new Frig & Faucet?
Q
Comments (0)
Am I being silly, because I already know, that we will really MISS our Sub Zero - Moving in a few weeks - Now What To Buy? Finally Sold House but little profit, we are very blessed to find a house in our new city that we can afford, barely! Thank you St. Joseph & Mother Mary. NEED another Refrigerator: Cabinet/Counter Depth, Bottom Freezer, Height 70" or less, Stainless Steel - Any Ideas on best Brand for the buck, in a New Refrigerator? What would you select & Where did you purchase your new Frig.? THANK YOU so much for sharing your Best and Worst Choices! Someone recommended a Samsung, does anyone have this brand and how do you like the way if functions inside and looks on the outside? Have you seen the White Pearl finish on the Samsung Refrigerator or do you know anyone who has this brand - what is your experience with Samsung? And we Need a New Kitchen Faucet, single hole - we like the Pull Out Sprayer and High Arch look - are these tall Faucets functional for you, do they splatter, outside of the sink? New house has large, double bowl Sinks, of Stainless Steel. Thinking of a Chrome Faucet - what is your Favorite Style, Brand & Finish and best suggestion? How do you clean the water spots, on your Faucet? Will also, miss our large White Sink, Villery & Boch by Franke! Thank you for your help, so much to do on this tight budget. Just want to get most reliable, functional and the best bang for The buck, guess we are all trying to do this, right! roseofblue
...See More
Replaced my Sub-Zero
Q
Comments (5)
I had a FD in my last kitchen and I must say that the ability to get in a whole lasagna dish or a platter, was so nice. I had a narrow SBS that drove me nuts at my last house. Had to have an extra refridge in the garage because there was never any room in it. I even like the old style swing single door refrigerators better than those SBS. The new SZ FD is a beauty!!! How long did you own the old one? Did it ever have maintenance issues? I find people run hot or cold on the SZ. Some people swear by them and other curse them every week because of failure.
...See More
maire_cate
Original Author
11 years ago
Jakvis - thanks for the info. and you could easily be correct but I sure hope not. It's also possible that I didn't describe the problem in complete detail. I wasn't home while the tech was here so I'm relying on what DH repeated to me. The service tech did call Sub Zero while he was here and described the situation - whatever the problem was required recovering the freon. The tech told DH that the repair itself would only be a couple of hundred dollars but the additional cost was due to the freon recovery and second tech. He even suggested that we consider buying a new unit. We've used the same repair company for 16 years and we've always thought they've been honest and fairly reasonable in their charges. DH originally gave them a $300 check to cover the service call and for the parts that he would have to order. When we canceled the repair they promptly refunded all but $75 to cover the service call. I would hate to think that the tech was incompetent.

I hope I'm not merely rationalizing since this was not an inexpensive purchase - I don't regret replacing the unit because it was definitely showing it's age and the abuse it received from my 4 sons. At the very least if we do list our home potential buyers won't be turned off at finding out the frig is nearly 26 years old and At that point we'll also have to decide if we want or need to replace the freezer - but we have other options if that happens. There isn't a soffit over the freezer and it's at the end of a cabinet run next to a doorway so we could easily opt for a smaller, less expensive unit.
jakvis
11 years ago
Sorry for the alarm but being in the Appl Serv business myself I'm always sensitive to poor service or sloppy diaganosis as it seems to drag down those of us who take pride of themselves and profession. There may be more to your former refrigerators issue than what was described and my diagnosis may be wrong as it is only as good as an internet diagnosis can be (can't see, can't hear, can't touch)

I know that you will love your new SZ and I hope you get many happy years from it.

Related Stories

GREEN BUILDING Zero Net Energy: A Hardworking-House Term to Know

By Steven Corley Randel, Architect

Homes that consume only as much energy as they produce by renewable means are a goal for builders. Learn what ZNE means for you

PRODUCT PICKS Guest Picks: 20 Quiet and Contained Kids' Toys

No batteries. Minimal losable pieces. And they engage the imagination. Need we say more?

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen Counters: Elegant, Timeless Marble

By Ivon Street Studio

Ever classic and with unrivaled beauty, marble countertops bespeak quiet luxury in the kitchen — with a few caveats

KITCHEN DESIGN 10 Creative Kitchen Backsplashes

By Laura Gaskill

Patterns, bold colors, natural wood, beveled mirror — even a favorite photo — sub for standard white behind the counter

HOME TECH Coming Soon: Furniture That Charges Your Phone

Countertops, tables and home appliances with wireless charging capability mean less clutter — and zero effort powering your phone

KITCHEN DESIGN Countertop and Backsplash: Making the Perfect Match

By Jennifer Ott Design

Zero in on a kitchen combo you'll love with these strategies and great countertop-backsplash mixes for inspiration

KITCHEN OF THE WEEK Kitchen of the Week: Casual Farmhouse Looks, Pro-Style Amenities

By Becky Harris

Appliances worthy of a trained chef meet laid-back country charm in a Connecticut kitchen and pantry

KITCHEN DESIGN Pro Chefs Dish on Kitchens: Paul Kahan Shows His Urban Sanctuary

By KitchenLab Interiors

Peek inside Kahan's newly redone home kitchen and learn what he considers most important for a cooking space

KITCHEN DESIGN 10 Big Space-Saving Ideas for Small Kitchens

By Laura Gaskill

Feeling burned over a small cooking space? These features and strategies can help prevent kitchen meltdowns

HOUZZ TOURS Houzz Tour: A Nature-Loving Compound Relaxes Into the Landscape

By Vanessa Brunner

Local materials, native plantings and organic shapes help four structures blend beautifully with their Sierra foothills site

Sponsored

More Discussions

36” Induction Range — Wolf, Thermador, Bosch, or ???

2

Bosch Benchmark Wall Oven not baking center of cakes

16

Good quality countertop microwave ovens?

7

Any advice on a vent liner?

4

Kitchen Island design conundrum

5