Which FD Refrigerator is More Reliable? LG or KitchenAid ?
sarapamela
12 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (16)
sas95
12 years agomojavean
12 years agoRelated Discussions
Please help! Which french-door refrigerator LG or KitchenAid
Comments (16)We have the first generation of LG French door, purchased about 4 or 5 years ago for our renovation. At the time, it was the most highly recommended fridge both in here and in other media. Big mistake...we never had any problems with the lights burning, but the cheap plastic interior crisper bins and shelves kept breaking. Now the freezer door will not stay closed. We are getting rid of it and replacing it with the Samsung CD FD. We just purchased it today at Lowe's for $2069...it's about $3300 at Sears. Lowe's is having a big sale, plus some rebates and WA State energy rebates brought it down to the price we got. It's frustrating...originally I wanted the SZ 650, but didn't want to spend 5-6K. Now between the LG and the new Samsung, I could have purchased the SZ. And I hate the idea of getting rid of a fridge only 5 years old...talk about a waste of resources. By the way, customer service at LG was horrible every time I called. Never again....See MoreKitchen Aid vs LG bottom freezer refrigerator
Comments (4)LG had some serious problems with their French Door models that used incandescent bulbs for the interior lighting. What would happen is the lights would occasionally stay on after the doors were closed. This would eventually cause the light fixtures to melt the plastic inside the fridge. Not good. LG has now gone to LED lighting which is what we have in our fridge. We are quite happy with the performance of our LG fridge so far, but from what a lot of other people have told the forum when they ran into trouble with the LG meltdowns they got nothing but grief from LG over it. So I would not buy any LG with incandescent bulb lighting period, and I would also be sure that whoever sells you the unit has a good solid repair capability. If they don't, I'd blow off the LG and try something different. The model you specified, when I looked it up on the LGE site, says it uses 2 40 Watt lights. Those would be incandescents; I'd be a bit wary....See MoreKitchenAid vs. Frigidaire (or Ikea) refrigerator
Comments (10)That CD Electrolux FD model that akchicago linked to --- I think that is the one for which holiday weekend discounts or rebates took the price at or below $2k a few months ago. On akachicago's suggestion to look at Samsung CD fridges: Consumer Reports gives Samsung fridges high marks for quietness, temperature performance, etc. Samsung's fridges seem to have average reliablity in the membership surveys. Note that the LED interior lighting is not to everybody's taste. Good idea to get a look at it. (LEDs are theoretically more energy efficient than other appliance bulbs, but the actual improvement in efficiency of the fridge is going to be negligible unless you have teenagers who hold the doors open for use as kitchen lighting.) AFAIK, the biggest benefit to LED lighting is that the "bulbs" do not get hot. No chance of a broken door switch leaving the light on and heating up your fridge or freezer compartment. (I forget whether it was LG or Samsung, but two or three years ago one of them had a spate a problems with defective swtiches and a lot of very irate owners of SxS fridges. A few of the units reportedly overheated and caused fires. A lot of irate postings about that problem, as you might imagine.) I do not know anybody with a Samsung SxS model, let alone a CD version, but several friends do have CD Samsung FD models and have been very pleased with them. Pretty much everybody who buys a Samsung fridge likes it unless and until they happen to need service. Samsung's warranty service and support practices have been uneven and have sometimes generated a lot of ire. Check them out on www.consumerafairs.com. Check for regional patterns, too, because service and support might be better in NYC than, say, my neighborhood in rural Montana. One of the attraction of the Samsung fridges is having dual evaporators and separate fans. Not quite the same as dual compressors but theoretically the dual-set-up lessens the chances of freeze-ups in the venting system and theoretically makes for better temperature regulation. I say "theoretically" only because I haven't seen any testing or data that shows that they are noticably "real-world" better than the current good WP/KA and Frigidaire/Electrolux models. AFAIK, all of the SxS Samsung CD models have through-the-door ice and water dispensers (TTDDs) which may be an issue given your preferences. This is definitely a YMMV thing, however. As I have said before, TTDDs are so important to some of my friends that, for them, fridge storage is merely a nice accessory to the TTDD. As for akchicago's points favoring FD over SxS, I pretty much agree that FD models have more usuable space and give more flexibility in the use of space. Of course, if those were the sole criteria, we'd be buying top-freezer models. :-) A couple of places that I sorta differ. First, while I can see gary dodge's point -- cited by akchicago --- about some of us older folks maybe having trouble pulling on a bottom-freezer drawer and therefore preferring a SxS model, that point strikes me as a six of one and half dozen of the other kind of thing. I says this as a certified chronic old fart. Us oldsters are as apt to have bending problems as problems pulling on a freezer drawer. My personal preference is for FDs in order to have the crispers and deli-drawers up closer to waist level because those are the things I will use the most frequently. Also, my perception from fridge shopping last fall was that bottom freezer models (including FD fridges) seemed to have a bit more crisper space than the drawers in SxS models. WIth the freezer drawer in my KA FD fridge having a couple of sliding compartments inside the drawer, I haven't had any trouble finding and retrieving frozen goods. Although the capacity is slightly less than the freezer compartment of the top-freezer fridge it replaced, I actually find it easier to sort through and find things. OTOH, freezer capacity in FD models will be reduced -- at least compared to a top freezer model --- by the space needed for the compressor and other sealed cooling system components at the bottom rear of the fridge. In top freezer and SxS fridges, that space reduces the space for the bottom mounted crisper drawers. If you go by specs, the specs for SxS freezer compartments may seem a little bit larger than the specified capacities of FD models. But, when you talke usable freezer capacity, I think FDs are a better buy. (Mind, we are talking about 36" wide units here. It hink it is a completely different story when you get to 48" built-in SxS models and the "twin tower" combos.) For me, the problem with freezers in 36" wide SxS fridges is that they have a series of narrow, small compartments. I call it the "card catalog" effect. Handy for folks who like that arrangement but, for me, however, the full width freezer drawer in an FD model results in more spacious, flexible and useable capacity. All the more so because I don't use the ice maker. This post was edited by JWVideo on Sun, Jun 16, 13 at 16:03...See MoreKitchenAid reliability/quality
Comments (19)We have a KA dishwasher and SxS fridge. Both have been in for 18-24 mo.s. The DW has been great- no problems. Every once in a while, something (usually plastic storage containers) comes out a little dirty. Likely due to my intensive stuffing of items into the DW before running. When I think about it, I run the longer cycle if I'm worried at all. With the serious drought in GA, we don't rinse for the most part. I almost exclusively use the hot rinse and no heat dry. We're still using our free supply of Electrosol tablets that we got w/ the washer. It has a pretty high phosphorus level (good for cleaning, bad for the water), so I don't know what we'll switch to when we use them up. The fridge has been good, but the icemaker has now broken for the 2nd time. At the first of '07, it broke and I ended up replacing the control module. Now it looks like the water valve is leaking, which causes the fill tube to freeze up. Total cost in parts has been ~$100, plus a few hours online figuring out what to do. So far, mechanical aptitude has been cheaper than an extended warranty....See Morefivefootzero
12 years agosarapamela
12 years agofivefootzero
12 years agosarapamela
12 years agoa2gemini
12 years agowestsider40
12 years agofivefootzero
12 years agolindy1096
11 years agomike_73
11 years agofauguy
11 years agomike_73
11 years agofivefootzero
11 years agolindy1096
11 years ago
Related Stories
KITCHEN DESIGNStay Cool About Picking the Right Refrigerator
If all the options for refrigeration leave you hot under the collar, this guide to choosing a fridge and freezer will help you chill out
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNSo Over Stainless in the Kitchen? 14 Reasons to Give In to Color
Colorful kitchen appliances are popular again, and now you've got more choices than ever. Which would you choose?
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESGet the Look of a Built-in Fridge for Less
So you want a flush refrigerator but aren’t flush with funds. We’ve got just the workaround for you
Full StoryHOUSEKEEPINGHow to Clean Your Fridge, Inside and Out
Keep your refrigerator clean and fresh, while you gain storage space and lose those ‘UFOs’
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNStandouts From the 2014 Kitchen & Bath Industry Show
Check out the latest and greatest in sinks, ovens, countertop materials and more
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNA Cook’s 6 Tips for Buying Kitchen Appliances
An avid home chef answers tricky questions about choosing the right oven, stovetop, vent hood and more
Full StoryFEEL-GOOD HOME21 Ways to Waste Less at Home
Whether it's herbs rotting in the fridge or clothes that never get worn, most of us waste too much. Here are ways to make a change
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNHow to Find the Right Range for Your Kitchen
Range style is mostly a matter of personal taste. This full course of possibilities can help you find the right appliance to match yours
Full StoryKITCHEN OF THE WEEKKitchen of the Week: The Calm After the Storm
Ravaged by Hurricane Sandy, a suburban New York kitchen is reborn as a light-filled space with a serene, soothing palette
Full StoryCRAFTSMAN DESIGNHouzz Tour: A Craftsman Cottage Expands for a Growing Family
Not wanting to give up a house full of memories, a Texas family chooses to build up and out
Full Story
buffalotina