Retain Architect or Psychoanalyst?

16 years ago

Hello, IÂve commented a time or two but this is my first original post. Sorry I couldnÂt make my debut a bit shorter. IÂm looking for input on the style of house IÂm considering for the pretty 20-acres we bought for our horses at the edge of a very small town.

For the last 16 years, weÂve lived in a 1920s tudor in Oklahoma City, and I dearly love the details from the turn of the 20th Century up through the 1930s or so. We searched for an older house in the country without success, so IÂd like to incorporate period details into our new build.

Now IÂm torn between a single-storey brick/stone European country "tudor-ish" plan and a Victorian plan. My furnishings and 1920s light fixture collection would be right at home in the European country plan. But, there are a handful of fairly simple old white Victorian farmhouses around the area and to me they just seem to fit the site. That style would also allow for wonderful porches to enjoy the view of the creek and the horses grazing. IÂm nervous though. The few modern "Victorians" IÂve seen built in these parts are downright awful. Is the style just too "costumey" -- for lack of a better word Â to pull off successfully? I fear IÂve looked at so many plans that IÂve lost my perspective and objectivity.

It is with enormous trepidation that I post a photo of a house built from a plan IÂm considering as our jumping off point. IÂd really appreciate input on whether it could be "tweaked" to make it more appealing in general and more appropriate to a farm-like setting in particular. Of course, IÂd also like to hear if you all think it falls into that "awful" category I mentioned. IÂll also post the floorplan, but IÂd make substantial alterations -- detaching the garage and putting it off the kitchen side of the house for starters.

Whew! I didn't expect posting this to be so traumatic. It's like one of those dreams where you're trapped at school naked! I await your feedback with fear and trembling. Thanks.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

dixiedoodle
16 years ago
I definitely do not think that house is "awful!" In fact, I really like almost everything about the exterior besides the dormer window. I would add gable pediments in the front.

I certainly hope that the owner of that home is not a poster on this site!

Good luck with your planning...I would suggest utilizing an architect to help you to determine just what style would suit you and the home site the best.
nutherokie_gw
Original Author
16 years ago
Thanks for your input Dixiedoodle. Yes, that dormer bugs me too. I'm trying to crystalize my thinking a bit before we approach an architect.

The photo was submitted by the commercial builder to the site that sells the houseplans.
Related Discussions
Call for help - new retaining wall is a budget killer
Q
Comments (10)
It actually was a series of walls. I will try find a good pic/drawing. Our architet is very good, but has seemed to reach a creative block on this one - all of her solutions bust through 25K. I will say we live in a neighborhood were some people wouldn't blink at 50-75K, but we blink, choke, then pass out. So she is used to working with those people. We are probably talking about 120-150 sq ft of wall plus steps and entryway, holding up about 6 ft of earth at the highest.
...See More
Rights + Contract with architect
Q
Comments (6)
It is standard for architects to retain copyright to the design, docs, etc. You cannot even make a photocopy of the plans. You are not buying the design and docs, you are licensing them. You don't own the design, you own the building that results. Unless the contract states otherwise the architect can use the design or portions of it for other clients. I have never heard of an architect that would allow the homeowner to retain the copyright. Most architects have a certain "style", there really are no unique houses. Their education, experience, creativity is where the design comes from, they retain that and use it from project to project. If I was spending a lot on an architect I would want the right to use the plan for a rebuilt (after fire, etc.) and I would want some type of assurances that the same design will not be built within a certain proximity of my house. If you want the right to build the house again (on another lot) you will have to pay additional for that. This is all "generally speaking"...
...See More
Mythreesonsnc - re: retaining walls
Q
Comments (18)
I don't think you are crazy either. The house goes in the south as well. The older section of Mountain Brook, AL has numerous stone homes. None are for sale at the moment, so no pictures online. One thing I was told when we were building, is mortar mix has changed. The older mortar mix contained more lime, and was more chalky in appearance. Your stonemasons sound like they know what they are talking about. Our home is a mixture of three stones as well. I don't necessarily think square stone look more formal than round. Ours are more square, but hand chiseled on-site. I have seen cut square stones and they are more formal looking to me. That said, I had originally torn out a lot of magazine pages of the style of stone you are wanting to do. The thing that stopped me in the end, I think, was fear of it not looking like those pages so I went this route. For me, it was the right choice. If our entire house was stone, I would probably have gotten the stonemasons to give your version a shot. But I felt the way I went blended more with the mortar washed brick portions of our home. I haven't regretted my decision. You're taking the time with yours, so I don't think you will either. Scary, all the same! Love your home and can't wait to see it finished. We live in a horse community. athensmomof3, I read about your appraisal woes. The mistakes of lenders has caused a multitude of problems. Hope yours is resolved soon!
...See More
Retaining walls -- concrete vs. boulder
Q
Comments (7)
You are not giving us very much to go on (like location, height and length of wall(s), frost depth requirements etc.) but in general, poured in place concrete will be more expensive than a wall formed from stacked landscape boulders. Not hugely so - depending on the material costs, rock/boulder walls run about $25-40 (or more)/square foot with PIP concrete running $30-50 (or more)/square foot. But this does not take into consideration any engineering requirements or specific site conditions that could bump up the costs. Also, different areas of the country tend to have different (higher or lower) labor costs which could also impact overall totals.
...See More
mightyanvil
16 years ago
An architect would be much cheaper than a psychiatrist.
Ask him/her about the Shingle Style. It was a reaction to the overly ornate late Victorian house styles and the cut up floor plans. Great open rooms, covered porches and easy to maintain cedar shingles. Even Frank Lloyd Wright designed a few houses in this style before he developed the Prairie Style. McKim Mead & White were the best known proponents in the northeast.

The first photo was built in 1881 and the second in 2004.

Whatever you decide to do be sure to find a carpenter who knows how to build a proper cornice return. The ones in the photo look like a vinyl siding salesman just passed through town.
nutherokie_gw
Original Author
16 years ago
Those houses are beautiful, MightyAnvil. I'll definitely do some research on Shingle Style. I appreciate the direction toward other styles that lend themselves to large porches, and I've seriously admired houses you've posted before. Oklahoma just turned 100 years old, so our architectural heritage is not as extensive as yours on the East Coast.

I think I'm afraid any architect I talk to is going to pass me off to a shrink. Then again, that might just be the one architect with whom I'm personally acquainted! Thanks again for the inspiration (and the caveat regarding cornice returns).
oruboris
16 years ago
Never mind whether we think its awful or not, what do YOU think?

Does it suit your region, location and neighborhood, as well as your lifestyle?

Do you want/need 2 eating and 2 living spaces on the main level? Are you comfortable having all the bedrooms on the second floor?

It will be fairly pricey per foot due to the level of detail and complicated roof and footprints. Things like the alcove in bedroom #2 are wonderful but come at quite a price.

I'd say say the overall look bit earlier than the design period you mention. It's elegant on the outside and welcoming inside, but a little decorated for my taste-- I guess I prefer a little more arts and crafts influence.

I like the lack of hallways [hate paying for square footage just to walk through] but I'm not sure how I'd use the 'study': too many windows for a good computer room unless you keep the blinds pulled, which seems a waste.

Retain Architect or Psychoanalyst?

Comments (5)

dixiedoodle

nutherokie_gw
Original Author

Related Discussions

mightyanvil

nutherokie_gw
Original Author

oruboris

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Retain Architect or Psychoanalyst?

Comments (5)

dixiedoodle

nutherokie_gwOriginal Author

Related Discussions

mightyanvil

nutherokie_gwOriginal Author

oruboris

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

nutherokie_gw
Original Author

nutherokie_gw
Original Author