Cowbird egg in GCFC nest???

18 years ago

We've been very cautious about checking the flycatcher's nest as some of you know.... they're easily spooked. It has been really hard to see what's what with the unique nesting style they have!

As of Saturday - there were at least 3 eggs in there....(never were too sure if there were 4 it was just so hard to see....) Checked today and the view was a lot clearer so I was able to see 4 eggs. At first I was thrilled but as I looked again I realized one looks different to the others... while it is similar at first glance, it's slightly smaller, a different shade (though a shade that could also be a GCFC egg - Sialis site shows a nest with 4 GCFC eggs of one color and one odd like this...) BUT what makes us wonder if it is a cowbird egg is the speckles are smaller, more like dots than what I call 'smudged dots!'

The GCFC egg is the one with the brown smudge type dots...(left) What do you think about the other one? Would you agree probably a cowbird or just an odd GCFC egg? We know how it goes with cowbird babies, so.... we're concerned. Opinions would be appreciated!

Thanks.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

bridget_bb
Original Author
18 years ago
Oops... just looked at the Sialis site again and the pic I referred to above shows 5 GCFC eggs and a cowbird in the middle... darn it....
mullipuff
18 years ago
That smaller egg is definitely a Cowbird egg. I got in a HEAP of trouble a few weeks back when I was trying to get some advice on this subject (see the reg. birding forum under "Cowbird Egg in Finch Nest - probably on about pg. 3 by now, for the fracas...), so tread very carefully. I - how shall I say - "took care of" the egg in question. Only you can choose what to do with your interloper egg, but be ready to get flamed by most of the GW birding world for your "illegal, unethical, criminal, (et al)" behavior if you mention it here.
Related Discussions
cowbird egg in chipping sparrow nest
Q
Comments (10)
Why would you want to let it survive just so it could go on to do the same thing in another birds nest? I would throw it out but you do what you want. Waiting for hatching could still mean death to the others if you don't see that it has hatched right away, it will always get the food whereas the others won't and will die. I am sure you will get other advice but I guess you can do what you want to do. Donna
...See More
Cowbird egg in phoebe nest
Q
Comments (3)
Well, we did eventually. We left it for a few days, hoping the cowbirds would move on. We shook it first so there would be no chance of it hatching. But as the days went on, I was afraid it would hatch and that would mean the end of the four phoebe chicks' hopes for survival. However, the four chicks hatched (after we removed the cowbird egg), two one day, and two the next. Both days, the newly hatched chicks simply vanished from the nest. Is that the cowbird? (We still see them around the yard.) The phoebes are constructing a new nest on the other end of the door lintel as I write this. They are going to try again... I wish I had a solution to the cowbird dilemma! I am wondering if the two (nearly identical) nests will somehow provide some (decoy) protection this time? How smart are cowbirds anyway?!!
...See More
Nest/Eggs - Ohio
Q
Comments (1)
Hi- Not familiar with them, but think you have a Chipping Sparrow nest. & yes, almost certain that's a Cowbird egg. Not sure what law is in your area, but I would pick that egg up & have it ACCIDENTALLY slip through your hands. Otherwise, the Cowbird nestling will hog all the food the parents bring & their young could very well perish. You may want to post this pic on this site's "bird watching" forum to get another opinion, but do think that's what you're dealing with. Best of luck! Nicole
...See More
Is this a Cowbird egg?
Q
Comments (6)
Our native cuckoos rarely parasitize the nests of other species. It's more common intraspecifically. In addition, both Black-billed and Yellow-billed cuckoos have eggs that are unmarked. Thus, this is a Brown-headed Cowbird egg and as already stated, should be left alone.
...See More
erictammy
18 years ago
I've never had a cowbird egg in with my other eggs. So is it the larger one or the smaller one?
lisa11310
18 years ago
UUUMMMM I wouldn't worry about being flamed. We don't know who you are, where you live and we have no clue as to what you have decided to do. The flamers are just words on a page and do not warrent another thought. Angry little people screaming injustice are just not worth the time or effort.
bridget_bb
Original Author
18 years ago
Tammy,
It is the smaller. It is about the size of a BB egg?

Mullipuff,
Thanks for the advice/heads up. We just wanted some others to look and agree with us that it is a COWBIRDS egg. The wife has her FLAME RETARDENT SUIT on, and she looks FUNNY LOL!!!!!!!!!
mullipuff
18 years ago
LOL - the flame retardant suit.

I was thinking over dinner - if the Cowbird egg is that much smaller, wouldn't a chick be also? And if that were the case, would it pose the same sort of threat that it would in the nest of a much smaller bird? This is more the scientist in me wondering, not the Devil's Advocate.

Lisa - Thanks for the kind words. You were supportive of me during that snafu and it was much appreciated. I also get and read Birdscope from the Cornell Lab of Orn. and found the Cowbird article very interesting.
lisa11310
18 years ago
You may want to do a little more research. I don't know the answer, but if I remember right the Cowbird also has a cherry red mouth inside attracting more feedings????? One would like to think that they can all survive. uummm but read you Birdscope again! ;)
luvabird ,,,
18 years ago
Cowbirds lay quite a LOT of eggs in other nests. their numbers are increasing. It's quite distressing, really.

I hear the eggs are quite slippery and are difficult to hold without dropping them.

Cowbird egg in GCFC nest???

Comments (8)

bridget_bb
Original Author

mullipuff

Related Discussions

erictammy

lisa11310

bridget_bb
Original Author

mullipuff

lisa11310

luvabird ,,,

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Cowbird egg in GCFC nest???

Comments (8)

bridget_bbOriginal Author

mullipuff

Related Discussions

erictammy

lisa11310

bridget_bbOriginal Author

mullipuff

lisa11310

luvabird ,,,

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

bridget_bb
Original Author

bridget_bb
Original Author