my lobelia cardinalis is yellowing ...any ideas?

15 years ago

I originally posted this over on the woodlands forum...and since I planted the cardinal flower for hummers and bees and butterflies, I thought maybe it might do some good to post it here as well. Maybe someone has had something similar happen?

I set out some exceptionally vigorous-looking cardinal flower plants about two weeks back, and I think I am losing a few of them and I'm not sure why. The site is perfect, very moist yet drains well, in sun for about 4-5 hours and then afternoon shade, and the soil is totally purchased mix due to our heavy clay soils being really hard on anything, despite the fact that I strive for natives. Of five clumps of plants, one died completely and two others are acting similarly...with dark green foliage slowly being replaced by yellow streaking and wilting off of lower foliage. ALmost like damping off but the leaves rather remind me of exposure to the family of herbicides that do their thing by restricting photosynthesis. THe other two plants show no sign of this decline and all are trying to send up flower spikes.

I use no chemicals and hand-pick pests, and I did notice an unfamiliar beetle, about 1/4- 1/2 inch long, shiny black and narrowly cylindrical with a cherry red head on several of the plants a week ago. It was a rather beautiful creature but I'm still unsure what it was and wonder if it might have transmitted a wilt/blight?

Just wondering if anyone has had similar experience with leaf-yellowing/streaking and eventual dying in previously healthy and well-positioned plants.... I plan on calling the nursery where I got them Monday, but I think I will lose two more by then.

maybe take pictures ?

Featured Answer

Julie Zickefoose

last year

From southeast Ohio: I've been growing Lobelia cardinalis for a couple decades, and mine have been spectacular until the last three years, when I believe they have contracted a virus that causes yellow marbling of leaves, leaf curl, curled and contorted flower spikes, wilting and then death. The plants will flower, but they die before setting seed. It's very upsetting. I am now pulling all seedlings that show yellow marbling and streaking (which is almost all of them) and trying to keep healthy plants well away from any sick ones. This isn't a question of too much or too little water. Beautiful healthy plants will grow right alongside infected ones, but eventually they become infected. I can't find any information about this suspected virus, but I believe that's what it is. If anyone knows of a resistant cultivar, I'm all ears. My hummingbirds would thank you.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

Elly_NJ
15 years ago
Are you watering them? Newly established plants need water.
catherinet
15 years ago
Maybe its just sort of delayed transplant shock? I planted a gorgeous ligularia. Now it looks like crap. I think they give those plants hormones/steroids at the nursery!
Is it getting enough oxygen in the soil around it? Can you cultivate easily around it? Do you think it might need some fertilizer? Another possibility is the stuff my bottom tomato leaves get. Forget what its called. Its a type of fungus/mold? I've found that lots of my stuff around here gets it.
Do you plants get enough air circulation?
Sorry I can't help more Dirtgirl.
Don't take it personally though. (the yellowing).
Related Discussions
Penstoemen and Lobelia Cardinalis?
Q
Comments (5)
I have both Penstemon 'Husker Red' & 'Mystica' in my garden beds and love both, as do the bees. Both were grown from seed via winter sowing and have thrived since I planted them out (in 2010). I don't pinch or prune my plants--in my experience they're entirely care- and worry-free. I'm particularly impressed with the fact the foliage of P. 'Mystica' not only came through this horrid winter but did so with both its color and form undamaged. As for how to care for them, if you have healthy soil, they should prove virtually carefree. I've never done more than prune the seedheads in late fall & collect the seeds. If you're a stickler for appearances, the stems could be cut back I suppose. I just leave them standing through the cold months and cut them down during Spring clean-up. Where I am Lobelia cardinalis dies back completely in the fall and disappears until it shows itself again the following growing season. After several years in my garden beds, I can honestly report it has needed zero attention or care from me and has not been bothered by any predators, vermin or insects.
...See More
Lobelia cardinalis native/McAlpine park
Q
Comments (6)
Thanks for the pic. My husband innocently cut mine down a couple of months ago, but I kept it watered and it came back nicely. It has several bloom stalks now instead of the original one; what a treat. This is one I bought fron NCNPS and planted near the house. There "were" some along the creek, too. Also, there are some growing in a natural wetland visible from the entry to Elon University's football stadium, in case anyone's here this fall, keep an eye out. they usually bloom about a month.
...See More
What eats Lobelia cardinalis greens?
Q
Comments (6)
Both woodchucks and rabbits have bit plants off near the base here to eat the plant on the spot or drag it off with them to eat elsewhere. Of course sometimes they decide after biting off the plant that they really don't want to eat it. The rabbits did that with my gas plants. Left the nipped off plant carcases for me to find. You'll need to watch or examine your plants more closely to determine exact causes. You can protect them with barriers of some sort to discourage the non-insect pests. Insect pests need hand-plucking and squashing (what I do) or some sort of insecticide. FataMorgana
...See More
Lobelia Cardinalis[Cardinal Flower]
Q
Comments (28)
I have found colonies of this plant, in the wild, harvested their seed, and hope to expand their grounds. Said colonies are streamside, and most often UNDER water in the winter and spring. I plan to carefully remove plants for my water's edge (same river, just down-stream), but am undecided regarding the best time to so-extricate. Much of my concern has to do with which rosettes are best to harvest, ie., the single plant rosettes, or those with 'babies'?? SO MANY large rosettes this spring, and I wonder, did they similarly exists last fall?? As mentioned, I have harvested seed (last fall), probably a quarter pound of said seed, and will be curiously scattering it in places which are wet, but likely have not been so fortunate to have seed ever reached there. The seed is so small, has little likelihood of being carried by wind or birds. This should be interesting and fun.
...See More
dirtgirl
Original Author
15 years ago
It could be anything BUT lack of water. In fact if it weren't for the fact that only a few of the plants look this way, I'd guess it was TOO MUCH water. The day after I planted everything we had a three inch rain, followed by half-inch showers every few days after that. The last week has been the first time since they were put out that it did not rain and I did water them day before yesterday for good measure. The water is not ponded but the soil is completely moist.

Cathy...I wonder if I tamped the soil down too firmly when I set them out. Yes the transplant shock started within 24 hours of setting out the joe-pye and the lobelia, but the joe pye snapped out of it and then the lobelia went from good to poor . The only thing that did NOT ever droop or change appearance was the blue mist (eupatorium coelestinum) and it came from a different supplier. (Hmmmm? maybe that is a factor) I have to say if you want healthy natives shipped to you in excellent condition, Shooting Star Nursery in Kentucky gets my vote of approval!
catherinet
15 years ago
Hi Dirtgirl,
If you did step on the soil too much, you can still take a hand rake and cultivate around it, so that O2 can get down further.
I have my lobelia in a pot sitting in my pond, so I don't think it can get too much water.......although if the soil is compacted, that could be a problem.
I'll have to check out that Shooting Star Nursery.
Jillian Kern
last year
North Carolina and picked up a Lobelia siphilitica at the nursery a few weeks ago that is displaying exactly this kind of odd yellow marbling - it’s a really distinct pattern of chlorosis. Search is showing that tomato spot wilt virus can infect L. siphilitica so I wonder if that would make crossover to L. cardinalis easy/likely. https://www.invasive.org/browse/detail.cfm?imgnum=5482561
Viral transmission is via thrips, apparently, so control of nearby thrip host sites as well as plant isolation sounds like a good start. Hoping this doesn’t become widespread!

my lobelia cardinalis is yellowing ...any ideas?

Julie Zickefoose

Comments (6)

Elly_NJ

catherinet

Related Discussions

dirtgirl
Original Author

catherinet

Jillian Kern

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

my lobelia cardinalis is yellowing ...any ideas?

Julie Zickefoose

Comments (6)

Elly_NJ

catherinet

Related Discussions

dirtgirlOriginal Author

catherinet

Jillian Kern

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

dirtgirl
Original Author